Your browser is not supported. Please update it.

12 April 2005

Blockbuster prepares to repel boarders, and the Fifty rises

The Faultline Fifty has risen 1.26% against a Nasdaq composite index that only lifted 0.75% during the past week, moving more that 0.5% ahead of Nasdaq.

The gains immediately eliminate weeks of gentle sliding and were seen as emanating from lower oil prices and few earnings fiascos. There were no earnings reports from any of the Fifty this week.

One of the biggest movers was the content sector, almost entirely due to Blockbuster, a stock that we only included last week in the Faultline Fifty. The stock moved up 14% to $1.94 billion in value, due to a spat between 9.7% shareholder Carl Icahn and the current board. He is putting up outsiders to replace existing board members and clearly wants to take control of the company one way or another.

He was one of those funding the failed bid to buy Hollywood Entertainment, the second largest retail DVD rental group in the US, that eventually went to third placed Movie Gallery, for a lower price.

Icahn is effectively launching a proxy battle to get rid of what he sees as weak management that pay themselves too much and don’t do enough.

Icahn said he is nominating Edward Bleier, previously president of a Warner Brothers Entertainment marketing division and Strauss Zelnick, former CEO of BMG Entertainment, as board members.

Icahn is 69 and has been around the block a few times on investment, and is known as a very active investor. He holds 9.7% of Blockbuster’s Class A shares and 7.7% of its Class B shares currently.

Icahn is also fond of investment in casinos, and owns the Stratosphere Hotel and Casino, and Atlantic Coast Entertainment which operates The Sands Hotel and Casino in Atlantic City, New Jersey.

He is calling for a one time payout to shareholders which company insiders have referred to as ‘a short term payback’ for his disappointment in not landing Hollywood Entertainment.

Investors see the fight as one which may drive the price higher, hence the shift in value.

Meanwhile there was an 8% sigh of relief that lifted the share price of Qwest, as it appeared to be losing the fight to acquire MCI to Verizon .

Verizon’s latest move however, a private deal to buy a 13.5% stake in MCI from Mexican mover and shaker Calos Slim Hel’m, designed to shift the momentum in the fight for MCI ownership its way.

Instead New York analysts are saying it may well backfire. Investors are now faced with a ‘fait accompli’ with Verizon having bought out the biggest shareholder already in an all cash deal.

Other shareholders will have to wait a long time for completion and take shares and future cash, amounting to a few dollars less per share than ‘Slim’. And why? So that the company can sell for a lower price, given that the Qwest bid was substantially higher.

In other financial regimes a side deal with a lead investor would be illegal, but not so the US. It is merely frowned upon.

In the end shareholders are trying to hold Verizon to ransom and squeeze just a little more cash out of the deal.

Qwest has still not said it is out of the running, but the likelihood is that it will not win even if it increases its bid, hence the relief we have seen in its shares.

Elsewhere in the Faultline Fifty we see a huge upswing in the Technology stocks, driven there by gains at Microsoft and more gains at Apple, which between them took this sector up $11 billion. We looked high and low for the rationale for the Microsoft increase and in the end came up with ‘habit’ as it is simply a place to put your money when you have nothing else to do with it. Apple’s value rose when a Piper Jaffray analyst said that he had dealer evidence that Apple would beat it’s estimates because it was getting its hands on more iPod Shuffles than it expected. Apple reports in just a couple of days.

The CE segment was up slightly, 1.5% entirely on Sony and the increased media noise around its shipments of PSPs.

The only segment that was down was the cable and satellite operators, but that segment has been holding up the entire Faultline Fifty of late and it was only off 0.25%.