Your browser is not supported. Please update it.

12 October 2005

Blu-ray Backers Hiss at Intel, Microsoft; Call Claims ‘Erroneous’

Blu-ray Disc backers HP and Dell this week responded to what they called “erroneous” claims by Intel and Microsoft that HD DVD is the superior next-generation optical disc format for PCs. The two Blu-ray Disc Association members said last week’s joint Intel-Microsoft statement was “not aligned with the vast majority” of other computer industry participants.

Blu-ray and HD DVD technology seek to fill a vacuum in the market caused by the inability of current DVDs to store full-length movies in high definition. The new formats will have other uses as well, such as for consumers and small businesses to backup important files.

‘Microsoft and Intel’s announcement erroneously indicates HD DVD has an advantage in a number of areas,” according to the Blu-ray crowd. Specifically, they cited as incorrect Intel and Microsoft’s statement that HD DVD offers more storage capacity than Blu-ray discs.

Dell and HP also labeled as erroneous the Microsoft and Intel claim that that HD DVD is the only format that allows users to make “controlled copies” of content stored on the disc. That is a function of the AACS copy-protection scheme, the Blu-ray Disc Association said, and AACS is also part of the Blu-ray specification.

The Blu-ray Disc Association also said the Blu-ray spec permits hybrid discs, backward compatibility with existing DVDs, the capability of being used in the slimline drives that go in notebooks and interactivity. Those are all functions Microsoft and Intel said were only available with HD DVD, according to HP and Dell.

“Dell has no doubt that Blu-ray Discs best meets the needs of computer users and provides the type of open industry standards needed to drive innovation and growth of the format across all platforms – consumer electronic, personal computers and gaming consoles,” said Dell CTO Kevin Kettler.

“From a PC end-user perspective, Blu-ray is a superior format. It offers 67% to 150% more storage capacity, higher transfer rates, slim line notebook compatibility, broadband connectivity and a proven interactive layer with Blu-ray-Java,” said Maureen Weber, general manager of HP’s Personal Storage Business. “The technical merits and consumer benefits of Blu-ray Disk make it the ideal solution for HP’s customers.”

Endorsers of the Blu-ray Disc technology includes Apple, Dell, HP, Hitachi, LG Electronics, Mitsubishi, Panasonic, Pioneer, Philips, Samsung, Sharp, Sony, TDK, Thomson, Twentieth Century Fox and Walt Disney.

“Every computer manufacturer in the BDA carefully reviewed both formats and ultimately chose Blu-ray as the superior solution for meeting customer demands and providing the best possible end-user experience,” said Weber. She said it was surprising that last week’s Intel-Microsoft announcement was “not aligned with that of the vast majority of the computer industry and is contrary to our consumer research.”

Here are the counter-claims the Blu-ray crowd made this week:

Capacity: Blu-ray Disc’s capacity is 50GB. This will be available at launch for BD-ROM, BD-R and BD-RE. This is 67% more than HD-DVD’s 30GB ROM capacity and 150% more than its recordable storage capacity – a critical issue for computer users.

Managed copy: Managed Copy is not a function of the optical disc format, but a function of the content protection system. The AACS content protection system, which is used by both Blu-ray Disc and HD-DVD, enables managed copy and network streaming functionality. It is not format specific.

Hybrid Disc: Blu-ray Disc was the first format to introduce a hybrid disc that could hold both high and standard definition versions of a movie on a single disc. The Blu-ray Hybrid Disc is the more elegant solution as it holds both versions of the film on the same side of the disc, which provides for easy labeling and greater ease of use for consumers.
– Backward Compatibility: Blu-ray Disc players and recorders can and will support DVDs through the addition of red lasers in the hardware. In order to be backward compatible with DVD, HD-DVD must also include a red laser.

Interactivity: Blu-ray disc is built on BD-Java, which leverages years of industry investment and experience in the set-top box, PC, and cell phone industries. BD-Java provides a mature, robust platform for authoring and delivering unprecedented interactive capabilities to the user for movies, music, and games. BD-Java was selected over iHD, the developmental Microsoft technology used in HD-DVD. The BDA carefully compared both iHD and BD-J, and concluded that iHD didn’t go far enough in providing a compelling feature set beyond DVD, while BD-J offered studios a much richer palette for providing a compelling interactive HD experience for consumers, particularly when a player is connected to a network.

HD DVD discs are reportedly cheaper to make than BDs are. BD offers greater storage capacity – 50GB to 30GB, with dual-layer media. That gives it room to store a full-length HD movie and the extra scenes and other goodies that the studios use to enhance their videodisc products when compared to what they show in theaters.

Josh Peterson, the director of strategic alliances for the Optical Storage Solutions group of HP, said in an interview with Tom’s Hardware Guide that the Blu-ray Disc Association was making inroads with the one-half of Hollywood studios and content providers that had expressed support for HD DVD. Peterson said it will be the major studios whose decisions over the coming weeks may lead to the kinds of compromises that can avert a repeat of the VHS/Betamax format war. The interview took place prior to Paramount’s announcement to use Blu-ray discs.

Peterson said that one factor that is important to the studios is the inclusion of extensive content protection and digital rights management features. The studios, he said, want a pro-active technological method to pursue content pirates and minimize damages from the distribution of unlicensed content.

Last week, Microsoft and Intel claimed Blu-ray had no policy with regard to managed copy – the capability for users to make legal backup copies of licensed content to recordable discs or hard drives, for streaming elsewhere in their networked households. Peterson disputed their claims. Managed copying, Peterson said, is part of the DRM system they chose to adopt, called Advanced Access Content System (AACS), which is also used in HD DVD, but which in Blu-ray is complemented by two other technologies, both of which are also independent of Blu-ray’s format specifications.