Around 3% of this year’s broadcast upfront, some $270 million, is expected to be advertising that is not sold onto the existing TV networks, but onto a combination of VoD, digital broadcast and internet advertising online, according to a TV Week investigation this week.
While at Faultline we don’t think this is enough, certainly the strategy is valid and may stop there being a major drop in the annual US advertising negotiation that takes place each year at this time absorbing about $9 billion of ad spend in as little as a single week of joint negotiations. This is followed by around $6 billion being spent on the cable Upfront.
Every major broadcasting network is now offering online delivery of some part of its portfolio and increasingly is putting the same programming onto its VoD services. Most of this is thought of as catch up TV, much of it free, and the idea is that advertisers will opt to advertise in both portions of the program, online and broadcast.
The flaw in the strategy is that the networks still expect to be increasing the take for the year by at least inflation, a healthy 3% or 4%. Chances are that this isn’t going to happen and once again, for the second year running the Upfront, especially for broadcast TV, will shrink with everyone hiding the fact that the amount of money spent on TV HAS to shrink to accommodate the 30% rises in internet advertising.
The online services of the US networks carry a trivial amount of internet traffic compared to partners like Google and AOL, who will want to sell their own advertising around catch up versions of the same video programming. Apple’s video iPod will also begin to take away from the total viewing hours, but with no recourse to advertising.
So this idea of mixing the ad teams of the digital side with the analog broadcast side and trying to cut joint deals, while a good idea, should not be enough to make up the shortfall, and we still expect there to be one or two nasty surprises for the big US broadcast networks, something that will begin a global trend in TV advertising sales reduction.
Advertisers know that their 30-second TV spots are less effective because they can measure them, they know that less people are watching each of them, and they need to get more impact for their ad dollars. So far the Internet is the best place where the impact of the spend can be best measured, although this is gradually being augmented by in-game advertising networks, and web TV services.
Major advertising agencies no longer feel that if they fail to buy up enough TV space, that somehow they will be denied sufficient impact for their clients, instead they can always made up the difference with increasingly effective internet campaigns. The result of this is that money no longer needs to be committed upfront and agencies can adopt a wait and see attitude. Look out for a long, drawn out and inconclusive upfront.
Separate Upfronts are already undertaken by the major portals AOL, Yahoo and MSN, and other video-rich sites, including news sites, while Cinema and VoD are both trying to create their own process so that they can take a piece of the discounted, bulk buying that was previously reserved for TV.