Broadcom vowed this week to continue with its legal battle against Qualcomm, despite a US judge saying that there is no basis for a federal anti-trust suit.
Broadcom will continue with a similar suit filed with the European Commission, and expects a decision later this year as to whether the EC will launch a formal investigation into Qualcomm’s anticompetitive practices.
“Qualcomm should take little comfort in the court’s decision,” said David
Dull, Broadcom’s Sr. Vice President, Business Affairs, and General Counsel.
“The decision does not find that Qualcomm’s alleged misconduct was lawful or that Qualcomm honored its promises to standards setting bodies. Rather, Judge Mary Cooper simply held that Qualcomm’s alleged abuse does not give rise to federal antitrust liability.”
The judge expressly granted Broadcom the right to file an amended
complaint for Qualcomm’s alleged misconduct, the company said.
Broadcom continues to believe that the Judge decision is directly at odds with established precedent and, particularly, the Federal Trade Commission’s recent decision in the Rambus case.
Broadcom will now evaluate what its next best US legal step is, which could include moving for reconsideration by the court, appealing the decision to the US Third Circuit Court of Appeals, or filing an amended complaint.
Last May Broadcom and Qualcomm filed tit for tat legal actions, triggered by Broadcom’s desire to make CDMA chips and Qualcomm’s use of its Bluetooth patents on Qualcomm chips. After Broadcom filed anti-trust moves, Qualcomm counter sued and then in October filed a second suit against Broadcom alleging it used two of its patents for compressing digital video without authorization. It filed another suit this April. Broadcom also claimed that Qualcomm is in breach of 10 of its patents.
Broadcom has filed a separate action with the US International Trade Commission alleging that Qualcomm has acted unfairly by importing chips that infringe on its patents.
In our view there is little possible here other than a negotiated court enforced settlement, sometime in the 2008 time frame, at best. There are too many patents involved and too many separate actions. But the two companies will fence for a while longer in order to work out which of them has the stronger negotiating position.