BT last week announced that it will become the first pay TV provider to offer ‘buy-to-keep’ movies and box sets in the UK. Sony and 20th Century Fox will make their films available on YouView boxes, for BT pay TV customers to keep ‘indefinitely.’
The news comes as rumors abound that Digital UK (a nonprofit comprised of the BBC, Channel 4, ITV and Arqiva) is looking to distance itself from YouView with the new Freeview Connect brand ‘ reported by many to emerge as an app on smart TVs.
YouView was meant to be the next iteration of Freeview ‘ the digital terrestrial TV service, which replaced analog TV in the UK. YouView is jointly owned by the broadcasters BBC, ITV, Channel 4 and Five, as well as telcos BT and TalkTalk, the seven-party venture is rounded off by broadcast infrastructure player Arqiva.
The YouView boxes combine the digital broadcasts with on demand content from the BBC, ITV, Channel 4 and Five available on the box, as well as the ability to record content to hard drives in the DVR versions.
However, YouView did not take off on anything like the scale of Freeview, largely due to the fact that Freeview has not been removed as analog TV was with digital switch over.
Consumers buying new TVs throughout the multi-year digital switchover period found that Freeview was integrated into them. Freeview adaptors were also widely available, for viewers who did not want to buy a new TV, which allowed them to upgrade to the Freeview experience. Consequently, Freeview was pushed into UK households gradually, before the analog signal was switched off and sold off as 4G spectrum.
But there is no such pressure to move from Freeview to YouView, and its uptake has suffered to such an extent that the publicly funded BBC now wants to distance itself from what has become a pay TV platform.
The Guardian quotes one off-the-record partner bemoaning the fact that ‘YouView was meant to be the champion of the next generation of free to air, but the involvement of the internet service providers means that it has become a pay platform. YouView isn’t the champion of the free, it’s the home of the pay.’
BT and TalkTalk have used a bundled YouView box and bonus channel packages as a selling point for their broadband lines, as YouView allows users to subscribe to premium channels in addition to the free content. Of just over 1 million YouView boxes in UK homes, only around 3% were bought from retailers.
Only two manufacturers produced YouView boxes. Huawei made TalkTalk boxes (about 700,000 of them) that were never offered retail, and Humax offers a 500GB and 1TB model for £229 and £249 respectively. These are not cheap, and explain the poor sales to the public of only around 30,000 units.
Freeview is found in upwards of 11 million UK homes, with Freesat in 1.8 million, and YouView shows no sign of overtaking either from its 1 million-strong user base, despite claiming to be the fastest growing TV service in the UK.
The seven parties had equal shares of 14.3%, and split the costs among themselves equally. It is reported that the BBC, Channel 4, Five and Arqiva want to reduce their financial contributions from April, which amount to around £6 million each per year.
Aside from the troubles that YouView is facing, there are more practical concerns with the BT offering. With HD films starting at £8.99 to buy and SD versions beginning at £5.99, BT is not offering a service that undercuts something like iTunes on price.
BT told us that the films will only be viewable on the YouView box, although an app for portable viewing is currently in development. As customers would void their warranty if they removed the hard drive from the box to try and copy their purchases, as well as the other necessary workarounds in the way of such a process, and the fact that it would be in breach of copyright laws, the ‘buy-to-keep’ films are firmly locked down to the BT YouView platform. Once it is full, what do you do? If you delete it, then really this is a ‘buy to keep for a while’ proposition.
It is unlikely that this option will be especially popular among consumers, or a large revenue generator for BT. It is not particularly competitive on price, locked down to an unpopular platform that looks to be in decline, and the extent of ‘buy-to-keep’ currently extends to a YouView box, a possible mobile app, and the offer of a DVD copy if you choose to leave the BT service ‘ but explicitly not a Blu-ray copy for HD versions.
YouView ran into difficulties securing TV manufacturers, as it was not a European standard. If Freeview Connect does surface as an app on a smart TV, then it can hope to be found in more than 3 million smart TVs that are projected to be in UK homes by the end of 2014. Those TV will almost certainly also have the HbbTV broadcast broadband standard built into them, because then all the devices made for the rest of Europe can be sold in the UK.
The future of YouView looks rocky, with broadcasters looking to move away from the platform and cut their contributions. It has low market penetration, and if around 1 million YouView boxes have made their way into UK homes, BT only has around 250,000 boxes to sell films on, and it has also hamstrung itself by not competing heavily on price with other buy-to-keep platforms or SVoD services.