Your browser is not supported. Please update it.

18 October 2006

BT Movio looks for transition plays from DAB IP to DVB-H

There are precious few mobile TV services up and running in the world, and BT’s desire to get into the market first, albeit with what we believe is a dramatically inferior approach to either multicasting or DVB-H datacasting, has had the effect at least, of waking up equipment makers to the sales to be made in its Movio service.

Both Siano and rival Frontier Silicon have come out with announcements this week designed to carve out a chunk of the BT Movio handset business, as it rolls out initially with Virgin and BT’s MVNO, and later potentially with other larger operators, if it can attract them.

BT Movio is early to market with mobile TV because it chose to use the very limited 1.5 MHz DAB multiplex that operates over the UK. As a result it was forced adopt either DAB IP or T-DMB for its transmission.

This has, of itself, created a new route to market for mobile TV, where an operator starts with DAB IP on existing transmitter sites and switches later to something like DVB-H or one of the other multicasting variants. Both vendor announcements this week relate to multi-standard chips being able to be used both with the DAB IP system, and then later also working with DVB-H.

DAB itself can’t be used for mobile TV as it stands because is doesn’t include video codecs in the standard, but both Digital Media Broadcasting and DAB-IP are extensions that do, and so can offer mobile TV on any DAB transmission network, as a sub-channel.

Siano’s CEO Alon Ironi told Faultline, ‘BT provided us with video streams from its Movio service and we made a few minor firmware modifications to ensure that our chips worked well with them. This opens the door for ODM handset makers to offer Movio handsets on their own phones and on other operating systems than Windows Mobile.’

BT Movio managing director Emma Lloyd said, ‘Our approach to mobile TV and radio is to deliver the best consumer experience without confusing the market with technology choices. Siano’s multi-mode, multi-frequency solution complements our approach perfectly, as it opens up the possibility of offering more channel choice as and when new spectrum is released in the UK. Siano’s solution will also enable handset manufacturers to develop devices targeted at all consumer segments for the UK and other markets using one hardware platform.”

It really is an important step, because of the weakness of the DAB IP proposition. A video stream runs in about 70 kbps in Movio, and it is no better than existing unicast streams that companies like Orange and Vodafone already offer in abundance. The idea is to move those existing TV services off the cellular network, which is good for the operators, but not radically improve their quality, and then be in a good position to bid for next April’s L Band spectrum that regulator Ofcom has freed up.

On the one had BT will be forced to bid pretty high, because it cannot afford NOT to get DVB-H spectrum, because the quality of the existing service will be made to look awful once DVB-H or MediaFLO hits the market. But on the other hand, if it can tie up deals with all of the major cellcos, it will give BT a year’s start to build up customers, which can lower the risk substantially of bidding high for the spectrum.

Ofcom said that it will auction 40 MHz from 1.452 GHz to 1.492 GHz, spectrum outside the optimal spectrum that was hoped for by DVB-H protagonists. Even if a chunk of that is used for another application (it has been suggested that digital radio might be another likely application) then there’s still enough for around 30 plus full QVGA channels at 30 frames a second, roughly using 400 kbps of data each.

Frontier already contributes the chip that was in the first handset commissioned by BT Movio from HTC, which uses the Windows Mobile operating system and Windows formats for video and DRM. Now it has partnered Penthera to use its Viewer application on the Frontier Malibu platform based on its Paradiso FS1030 multi-standard system-on-chip.

Penthera is rapidly making a name for itself, along with one or two other software houses like Packet Vision and S3, as well as the mighty Nokia, as a provider of software to drive mobile TV services at the transmitter and also on the handset.

Penthera has already been contracted to provide a transmitter side software suite to Modeo for its DVB-H roll out in the US, and is working with Arqiva on a UK mobile TV trial in Cambridge.

In fact Penthera is really working with everyone, and was showing its platform on a Siano chipset at IBC, among others, so the only important message here is that Frontier, the first chip supplier to HTC, is not being left out in the race to provide a future proof chip and software stack for the UK’s peculiar spectrum requirements.

But this is perhaps not so peculiar really, with about half of Europe in a similar position, unsure of what spectrum they will eventually get for mobile TV, often expected to be taken from the analog TV spectrum as it is retired between now and 2012. In the meantime everyone can’t wait to get mobile TV off the ground and despite a number of vendors, such as SIDSA, saying to us recently that ‘there’s no call’ for multi mode chipsets, it appears that a transition through DAB IP or even T-DMB may well be required in multiple countries.

Where anyone provides multi-mode protocol support with a software downloadable upgrade it makes the handset makers happy and more able to enter a market. They can benefit from economies of scale across multiple markets, while the operators themselves can contemplate a complex cocktail of mobile TV offerings, spanning unicast, DVB-H, multicasting, T-DMB, MediaFLO and DAB IP ‘ and one day, not too far from now many combinations these will all be feasible on the same phone

Frontier is yet to shift to volume manufacturing in its Malibu platform, that’s not due until December, and while dominant on T-DMB handsets, it is playing catch up with DiBcom, Siano, Philips and Texas Instruments, but this type of dual mode layered introduction of mobile TV may give it time to catch up.

Emma Lloyd, managing director of BT Movio was also quoted on the Frontier release saying very similar things to those she said about the Siano move and you really can begin to see how it’s strategy is unfolding.

We have criticized Movio in the past and many of those criticisms remain valid ‘ the picture resolution may be so bad in its initial services that it may put everyone off mobile TV for a long time; it is only simulcasting what’s on normal terrestrial TV, so during the day as people try out mobile TV when they are at work, or traveling, they will find themselves watching children’s programming. It will of course be fine for going out in the evening and keeping up with your favorite TV series, at the same time, but that’s not really how mobile TV usage is working out.

Siano boasts that it offers multi-band, multi-standard mobile TV on a single chip the SMS1000 family supporting DAB-IP, DVB-H, T-DMB as well as DVB-T, in a range of spectrum bands, from 170MHz to 1680MHz.