For once a piece of research said more about the company that issued it, than the subject of the piece, in this case Apple, with analyst group Forrester saying that iTunes transactions were down by 65% in the first half of the year.
Our first thoughts were ‘We don’t believe that’ and then we thought a little bit more. It was quite clearly insane. The number of iTunes tracks sold are cited by iTunes every quarter, or at least periodically, and the quarterly revenues of Apple showed the company was storming last quarter, reported only in October. Then there was the fact that Apple had added huge numbers of video to the mix, and that video revenues were considered high enough to attract yet more video sources. Finally iTunes opened up in two or three more territories recently. All of these would have the effect of raising revenues not lowering them.
The Forrester statement was supposed to be based on the analysis of credit card data, but the firm has not yet said whose data exactly or just how Forrester came by it, nor whether or not Forrester has ever used this kind of data in the past as a source of accurate consumer behavior before. Our guess is no. In fact our guess was that this was designed to inflict as much financial damage on the Apple share price as possible, so that someone could benefit from that. But that’s just a guess, one almost as nasty as Forrester’s implication that the Apple phenomena was a bubble that was about to burst.
Either the sample was too small, or it didn’t take in last year’s credit card data, only this year. Whatever it was it was a bad research technique, and it probably allowed some third party to place a spin on the data that Forrester found compelling because it was so unlikely, but in this case it was unlikely because it wasn’t true.
Today, as people cancel their Forrester subscriptions, it won’t look so compelling. It was counter intuitive, it was poor research practice and now it turns out it was plain wrong. comScore Media Metrix which bases its results on internet traffic monitoring and online surveys, and Nielsen SoundScan, which uses the same types of techniques, both say that Apple iTunes content sales are rising as they have risen for the past three years.
ComScore has iTunes revenues up by 84% for the first three quarters of the year with a 67% increase in the number of buying transactions and a 10% increase in the dollars spent within each transaction.
SoundScan reported that overall the online music market had grown 67% over this time last year counting 49 weeks of the year so far, and was up to 525 million downloads, beating 2005 totals by 173 million, which isn’t so much in line with ComScore’s numbers as identical, if Apple is rising with the market.
SoundScan also reports that digital album sales were 29.7 million, up more than 100% from last year’s sales of 14.5 million and that 54 tracks sold over 500,000 units during the year. This was true of only 22 tracks last year.
US financial analysts failed to panic at the sight and publicity that surrounded the Forrester report, and the Apple share price took the value of the company this week to an all time high of over $74 billion.