The price gap for broadband service between that of the cable TV and phone companies widened to an all-time high in August, according to a report from Wall Street firm SG Cowen. On average, the report says, cable modem service in August was 75.8% more expensive than the telcos’ DSL service, up from a 53.3% gap in July. Phone carriers cut prices an average of 9.2% compared to the cable TV companies’ average increase of 41%.
Verizon and SBC, the nation’s two largest telcos, are now selling broadband for $14.95 a month. Verizon adds a free month if the subscriber commits to a one-year deal.
The two largest cable TV services increased their monthly prices. Comcast raised prices an average of 7.9%; Time Warner Cable raised its price by 5.8%.
By reducing their monthly rates, the telcos have cut into the cablecos’ once two-to-one market share advantage. SG Cowen analyst Lowell Singer said that during the first and second quarters of 2005, cable companies captured 47.8% and 46.3% of net new broadband subscribers respectively, down from 50.3% in 2004 and 60.8% in 2003.
What the US Telcos Charge for Broadband
Here’s where the four major US telcos stand with their entry-level broadband pricing
Company Monthly Download Speed Upload Speed Other (Mbps) (Mbps)
SBC $14.95 1.5 0.384 Credits toward home networking, DSL modem
Verizon $14.95 0.768 0.128 First month free with online orders, free modem
Qwest $19.99 1.5 0.896
Bell South $24.95 0.256 0.128 Free modem and free digital camera or MP3 player with three months of Napster
SG Cowen estimates that cable companies will capture about 47.3% of net new broadband subscribers in 2005.
Cable companies “must continually reassess whether to accept share losses or to fight back by reducing high speed data pricing and accepting lower margins,” Singer said.
Cable TV Companies Share of New Subscribers
Period Share of New Subscribers
2003 60.8%
2004 50.3%
1Q05 47.8%
2Q05 46.3%
Forecast for 2005 47.3%
Source: SG Cowen
US Only
Cable TV companies 53.4%
Phone companies 46.6%
This coverage originally ran in The Online Reporter at Rider Research, email peter@rethinkresearch for contact details