Your browser is not supported. Please update it.

2 October 2014

Cablecos without the cables – says planned FCC ruling

It is tough to understand the US situation surrounding what TV programs you can use on a pay TV environment in the US, especially if you don’t live there or haven’t lived there during the past 30 years of legislation.

But it is a highly regulated environment, and because of this it remains unstable to this day, with key decisions made 20 and 30 years ago, affecting the profitability and success of today’s broadcasters, cable companies and getting in the way of the development of brand new Online Video Providers. It now looks like the FCC is going to make the overdue and obvious move of allowing OTT or over the internet video the same benefits as cable and satellite.

The story broke when a number of US sources, including the Wall Street Journal, cited FCC insiders readying a rule-making that will allow Online Video Providers to benefit from the 1992 Cable Act, when it introduced Program Access rules.

This is really simple and at the same time, really complicated. Program Access Rules were designed to protect Local Broadcasters by making sure that every cable company carried local broadcasting without charging the broadcaster for it, but there is an opt out where any broadcaster who thinks its content is compelling, does not have to allow the cable operator to simply carry it, but can insist that this permission or retransmission consent is secured by paying a significant price. So small local broadcasters who paid for a proper free to air spectrum license from the FCC, get to be delivered on cable without paying for it, while the larger national broadcasters can charge a fortune to allow pay TV to carry their signals.

In order to qualify as a multichannel video program distributor (MVPD) under the FCC rules, the pay TV provider had to own the infrastructure that delivered the content – the cable, wires or satellite broadcast. This has effectively meant that delivery over the internet has not qualified for Program Access, and it is this tiny point that the FCC is discussing changing, as well as the fact that what an OVP must produce has to include a series of linear TV channels.

Just which constituency does this affect most? Well it’s not at all obvious and we think that the one thing it will do, is put Local Broadcasters on most OVP services. What else might it do?

Well, it might open up competition by lowering the price of entry to becoming an MVPD; it might also open up an argument that says that broadcasters can no longer decide to license content just for one technology – like cable, but not the internet; and that might mean that TV is TV, however it gets to a screen, including over wireless networks, so on the move and out of home. So there is a case for this opening the market for an Aereo style business, for a Netflix style business and also for Comcast and other cable companies, as well as AT&T and Verizon.

Looked at from the Aereo point of view, it wanted to carry broadcast free to air TV without paying for retransmission consent. So this doesn’t help, because it would have to pay the types of fees that cable has had to pay. It is more straightforward, and if a company comes along that has the price of a seat at what is a very expensive poker table, it doesn’t have to go away and build a network. That’s good for consumers, if it actually happens.

On the other hand, unless it has OTT video peering relationships worked out with the major ISPs (who will also be its rival pay TV providers) or is capable of paying for such connections at a decent speed, then this also doesn’t help.

From the point of view of Netflix it is interesting in that it currently does not offer linear programming and much of what it has done in original program consumption, in stimulating binge viewing, would go out of the window if it offered this. But it COULD offer linear alongside what it already offers, without killing off binge viewing, and to do this it might enjoy a huge advantage over others, having already worked out its relationships with ISP peering.

We have not seen the form of the ruling, but there must be an argument which says “Hey look I already pay you for the content on cable, and since I don’t have to own the delivery mechanism, surely I can deliver this over the open internet for the same price.”  That is an argument that cable and DTH operators have already pushed, but we suspect that the FCC is not going to interfere with that aspect of the deal. Its ruling would mean that broadcasters could not refuse carriage based on the technology, but only based on the price for retransmission consent.

So how about Comcast and cable and AT&T and the telcos? They should gain nothing from this in terms of lowering the price for content and they are already a long way down the path of taking a lot of content over the internet, and some of it out of home.

In particular AT&T and Verizon want to take a lot of content and make it available using LTE broadcast – now there may be a real benefit for AT&T to take this negotiation off the table and simply refer to this as just another IP form of delivery, which arguably it is, as is unicast to a phone. Traditionally however content owners have distinguished by the type of device, and the location as well as the network the content travels over, and as we said, we cannot see the FCC directly interfering with broadcasters on what their retransmission consents allow.

There may be some natural flattening out across the different technologies anyway, with one not costing any more than another, based purely on what the end user device is, but more likely on the screen size, the amount of advertising opportunity it opens up and the number of new people watching the new screen type.

Another constituency that the FCC may have in mind are companies that make Televisions, specifically Vizio, Samsung and LG in the US. If they can show linear TV over the internet, mixed in with internet held content, surely that is the beginning of a Netflix class service? Well yes, but that already exists in that the TV maker does not have to pay for transmission consent because his is the device that TV content was originally designed to reach, and the internet content that is additional is minimal compared to the real content on the TV channels. Why would Samsung pay transmission consent for content that it can currently carry for nothing. It has enough problems.

So that leaves us with a single constituency that we have not yet spoken about, the Googles and Apples of this world and anyone who approaches this industry from the point of view of carrying content OTT to what we often call a net top box or Chromecast device, so people like Roku.

What is interesting is that Google TV is still prohibited from accessing many of the studio programs from studio web sites. Its browser is banned, as we would assume would be the case with Android TV. But these financially powerful companies are the ones that could easily get the cash together for transmission consent payments on a par with cable, and at the same time make the upgrade from VoD subscription or pay per view services to fill linear channels. But these companies have been in negotiation for years to obtain online viewing rights as a starting point to challenge pay TV in the US, but have more or less given up, because of the content costs. Intel was the same, selling the handful of content licenses that it had won to Veirzon, which has still yet to launch using them.

Finally there are the broadcasters themselves, but surely they don’t need the FCC to tell them what they can and cannot do with their own content. And anyway the TV Everywhere discussions with pay TV companies has made it clear that if Broadcasters go straight to the internet with content, then the cable operators will withdraw their support.

All of this points to a content stalemate in the US that this FCC us unlikely to unblock with this move. All it has done is give its blessing to anyone that can come up with retransmission consent payments for broadcasters, so if a new company comes along, like Aereo, but one which wanted to pay for a license. The FCC has taken out some of the grief that cable and other MVPDs would level at such a signing, but we don’t think for a moment that if it passes unscathed this rule making will make it any more likely.

Most sources remind us that back in 2012, the FCC originally began looking into OTT video regulation after online subscription service provider Sky Angel accused Discovery of violating regulations by pulling out of a distribution deal it had with the company. Sky Angel argued for MVPD status to be treated like any other TV provider. It looks like this single small case may have triggered the rule-making. Now we await the unintended consequences of such a ruling and just how welcomed or otherwise it is by each of the major pay TV constituencies.