Earlier this year at the Society for Information Display conference held in Boston, a paper was presented by Canon and Toshiba’s joint venture SED Inc, on just how it goes about building the revolutionary Surface Emitter Conduction electron-emitter display (SED) panels. Why is this so important?
Well, we are at a pivotal moment in the flat screen TV market. Right now Plasma Display Panels are the rolls Royce of this market, but if SED TVs, and the first screens came off the production line last month, and which will go on sale early next year, are as good as SED Inc says they are, they are going to usurp the PDP position of offering the biggest and best picture TV.
Depending upon what prices SED Inc bring their devices to market once they are in volume and how rapidly they can drive down their cost curve, the new SED could potentially crush the margins on both Plasma and possibly the top end of the LCD TV market and of course all forms of rear projection TV. That would create a horrible price squeeze in the TV market which catches virtually every one of the majors, from Sony to Samsung to LG Philips to Panasonic.
Their reaction is likely to be the acceleration of their own next generation of TV technologies and losses in the interim. We have already heard this week from the new Sony CEO Howard Stringer that he has begun work in earnest on organic LED screens (see separate article) but also that he needs to get TVs profitable in short order.
So when the Nikkei Electronics Asia finally released some detail about this presentation, we thought it was worth taking out the bones of it and seeing if SEDs are really all that threatening.
We have already heard that SED Inc expects the pricing per-panel shipment value to be around 67,000 Yen by 2010, something like $600, which, considering this is supposed to be the top end technology that is going to offer a quality ceiling to the TV market, is frighteningly low.
It could lead to 50 inch devices that are under 1 inch thick and which retail for $1,200. Every other technology, including top end plasma and LCD TVs will have to sit someone under this price ceiling if the SED is going to be as good as expected.
Right off, the paper SED Inc gave stressed the cost competitiveness of the technology. Volume production of panels was slated to start in August 2005, while Toshiba has made the decision to site a volume production fab at its Himeji Plant, to start operation in January 2007.
The core of the manufacturing method used for the electron emitter is the forming of an electron emitter gap, without using semiconductor processes such as photolithography.
The electron emitter releases the electrons that cause the phosphors to emit light, and is a key component in determining SED panel performance. There is one emitter per sub-pixel, making it an equivalent problem to LCD panels.
But how does SED Inc make the tiny nanometer sized gaps to release electrons from the emitter? The gap is only 4nm to 6nm because a narrow gap means a higher density of the electric field when it hits the phosphor. So less energy to make bright colors on the screen.
The method used to manufacture this gap is a combination of two processes called conductance forming and conductance activation. One of these evaporates a tiny 30 nm to 50 nm thick layer of carbon, while the other deposits Carbon to fill up the holes. By keeping both processes going at once, at the right level, the holes formed settle at just the right width all on their own.
In order to control the two processes, SED In uses a secret organic gas and the concentration of this gas, and the voltage input to the film, between them, define the exact size for the emitter hole.
Since the initial layer is put down using inkjet technology and the emitter holes are not made mechanically or using photolithography the entire process is automatic and therefore exceptionally cheap. The speaker paralleled the process to just ‘blowing a fuse.’
The presentation was greeted with a certain amount of skepticism by engineers present, mostly because they just don’t want it to be that easy, because then they, and their companies, are in deep trouble, especially as SED Inc has decided not to license the process.
The paper also revealed that even after 60,000 hours of testing, the drop in the density of emissions from one of these screens was just 10%. That means that the phosphor deteriorates before the emitters give out, and that effectively makes it as reliable as a CRT. The final SEDs should reach 500 Candelas per square meter shortly and then 50 inch panels will begin flowing off the production lines.