Your browser is not supported. Please update it.

31 May 2006

Can Time Warner get the rabbit out before the hat disappears?

“We are committed to completing the transformation of AOL,” Time Warner CEO Richard Parsons told Reuters at the close of his company’s annual shareholder meeting in Atlanta this week. He was referring to the attempt to transform what was once the world’s largest Internet access service into an ad-supported Internet portal for entertainment, information and services – everything from music videos and reruns of old TV shows to free phone service.

Unfortunately, the loss of AOL’s dial-up customers is happening faster than many had forecast.

Competition from “old” rivals such as Google, Yahoo and MSN is fierce, and new competitors such as MySpace.com, Craigslist, iTunes and CinemaNow are getting stronger.

The cable TV and phone companies are pushing broadband as part of a bundle with pay TV and mobile and residential phone service. The phone companies, specifically AT&T and Verizon, have dropped their entry-level broadband rates to below what AOL charges for dial-up. Assuming it’s available in an area, a consumer would be foolish to go with any dial-up service that costs more than $15 a month.

For the quarter ending March 31, AOL lost 835,000 dial-up subscribers. At $18 a month, that’s $180 million a year – from just one quarter’s loss. Annualized, it a loss of three quarters of a billion dollars a year in revenue. In the first quarter of 2006, AOL revenues dropped 7% to $2 billion. Its operating profits declined 17%, to $442 million.

Time Warner shareholders continue to ask whether the company should keep AOL. They are fearful that uncertainty about AOL depresses the Time Warner share price, which has not been above $20 a share for the past four years. AOL accounts for about 20% of Time Warner’s revenue.

Parsons has recently been forced to implement several programs to get the share price up. Following public criticism by financer Carl Icahn, Time Warner increased a share buyback program to $20 billion, eliminated about 2,400 jobs, reduced some expenses such as corporate jets and sold assets including a book publisher.
Time Warner shareholders and executives are still paying the price for what this publication warned about when the AOL acquisition of Time Warner was announced: “AOL did not have a broadband strategy.”

AOL has yet to become the sort of distribution dynamo that was promised when it acquired Time Warner – something equivalent to a cable TV operation but one that could operate globally, not just in a few states. After the two were joined, executive arrogance kept the pair from any significant convergence.

For a long time, little effort was made by the company to sell Time Warner content through AOL, which was one of the major reasons for combining the two companies. The stock price plummeted, AOL managers started leaving, the government started looking into AOL’s books, AOL CEO Steve Case was drummed out of the company and vice-chairman Ted Turner, poorer by billions, quit in disgust. The company has since been trying to build a business that can prosper in the broadband era.

After the meeting, Parsons told Reuters, “AOL is in a space that the marketplace thinks is contracting (dial-up access) and needs to migrate its business to another part of the Internet landscape where the market is growing (entertainment and service portals). Our plans are to see that journey through, I think that if we do that, the market and the stock will react very positively.”

The single most significant thing AOL has done in the transformation is to make all its content and services available to non-dial-up subscribers. Its single greatest achievement occurred last summer when millions watched the Webcast of the Live 8 music concert on AOL.com. AOL made a profit by selling ads.

One of AOL’s unrecognized strengths has been its instant messaging service. That makes the company an early pioneer in social networking, even though that’s not what it was called. That could make AOL’s move into Internet telephony (VoIP) an event to be reckoned with if the company can convert its instant messaging users into telephone users. Additionally, the company’s Buddy List feature could be the basis for a social networking success, helping it to compete with News Corp’s MySpace.com and with Facebook.

However, AOL still depends heavily on its dial-up customers for traffic. The company estimates that just over half of its unique monthly visitors are dial-up subscribers. And each AOL dial-up subscriber generates about six times as many page views as non-subscribers, according to Henry Blodget, president of Cherry Hill Research. The more subscribers that leave, the fewer pages AOL serves up.

There has been some convergence between AOL and other Time Warner operations: Time Warner Cable agreed to let AOL manage the search and advertising for its Road Runner broadband customers; Warner Bros is making episodes from “classic” TV series available on the AOL portal, free but with a few ads.

Time Warner sees advertising as the key for AOL’s future revenue growth. Parsons told the Cox News Service, “AOL historically has been almost exclusively dependent on subscriber revenues, and the ad revenue has been building, but slowly. You’re going to see ad revenues, over time, become the fat kid in the boat, if you will. It seems pretty clear to us now that the ad-supported business model that for so many years under-girded the entire television business is going to be the primary model under-girding Internet businesses.”