Media phone retailer turned VoIP and broadband operator, Carphone Warehouse, lost around 14% of its market capitalization when last week Vodafone pulled most of its business from the group. It can only sell pre-paid contracts for Vodafone now not monthly contract customers.
The UK company is valued at a touch under $5 billion, and has seen its share price rise and rise throughout the past year, as it introduced its VoIP fixed line phone service and its free DSL broadband package into UK homes.
But with the purchase of AOL UK’s ISP business, completed last week, Vodafone has begun to see Carphone Warehouse as too competitive and too powerful, and has switched its loyalties to Phones4U, a start up targeting the original Carphone Warehouse space.
Broker Merrill Lynch reduced its target price for the group but maintained a buy rating saying even without the Vodafone business the company will grow by around 30%.
The decision by Vodafone is understandable, what operator wants to let a single retailer take up too much of its handset business, but is it wise? Carphone Warehouse will almost certainly sell no less phones, just less Vodafone business and that will result in an inevitable swing in favor of Vodafone competitors in its home market.
Phones4U has been acquired by the private equity group Providence Equity Partners, and it will now be the only third-party store chain to sell contract subscriptions for the Vodafone network in its home UK market. Phones4U has strong appeal in the youth side of the market.