The basic rationale for Vodafone buying Liberty Global cannot be in question. It is good for the company and its shareholders, what we have to ask is whether or not it is good for Europe and its consumers, and that will tell us whether or not this will be looked upon benevolently by the two regulators which matter, the European Commission and the German Bundeskartellamt, usually referred to in English as the Cartel or Kartel Office.
Right now you would be excused for thinking that Europe loves big company mergers and positively wants to create some players with a real European-wide power base to attack the global market. The deal that it allowed for Liberty Global to purchase Ziggo in the Netherlands, seems to set new rules and a new tone for operator consolidation in Europe, triggering a free-for-all.
But this deal, if it is ever agreed and brought in front of regulators, is another case where the mighty German economy will make the final decision on behalf of the 503 million inhabitants of the European Union, a little bit like the German Chancellor forcing smaller nation states to “tidy up” their debt act, following the Eurozone crisis.
But if Germany is a shining example of national debt regulation, it is the very opposite in keeping competition healthy. While it was not the Kartel Office which was responsible for Deutsche Telekom divesting itself of all the six regions of cable in Germany in 2001, it has since prevented anyone from bringing them back together again, and that is mostly seen as protectionism for its prized Deutsche Telekom.
Since then 3 of these units have been re-merged under Liberty Global, now called Unitymedia KabelBW (6.5 million homes), and the Vodafone held Kabel Deutschland (8 million homes) is the fourth and largest by number of homes, but with many of the less well-heeled parts of Germany. The last few million (2.4 million or so) cable lines live in Primacom and Telecolumbus, although there are also over 500 campus or housing association based cable operators, but these all get their content from one of the other players, and are effectively controlled by them, if not fully owned.
But it was fears for these very housing association customers that led to the German authorities pushing back on the acquisition of Kabel BW by Liberty Global and since it has rattled around the German court system, with a possibility that the deal will have to be unraveled. That decision was last visited in August 2013, and is likely to go to appeal through one of two routes. First off it must go back to the Kartel Office, to look at its own decision, and finally if the decision is to “no longer” allow the merger, it can be referred by Liberty Global to Germany’s Federal Court of Justice to request the power to appeal the decision.
The issue is that free TV only gets to these associations via cable, so if an operator comes in and charges more than just a nominal €10 a month as part of an overall housing association service charge, it means they cannot get what is effectively free to air TV.
The other recent move in this market came in February 2013 when the Kartel Office denied Kabel Deutschland permission to acquire Tele Columbus.
So in a way, in Germany at least, Vodafone does not know what it would be getting from Liberty Global and that’s a problem. There is no modern precedent to unravelling a merger of this nature – Liberty Global money in the form of capex, has already been spent at Kabel BW, and Liberty Global cannot simply rip up the ground and take out the wires. This is because initially the merger got Kartel Office approval and only since has a court over-ruled it, more than a year later.
What has to happen is that the court must impose or agree conditions that make the deal transparent for housing associations, and that in itself will offer Vodafone either less or more benefit in Germany. Until it knows those terms, it will be reluctant to conclude a price for the German portion.
But then it will be asking whether or not it can merge Unity Media, either with or without Kabel BW, with Kabel Deutschland. On past performance the Kartel Office will not even consider this. It would not even let Kabel Deutschland add the 1.6 million homes of Tele Columbus to its 8.5 million homes, so we cannot see it allowing a new agglomeration which would amount to a national cable network of at least 15 million homes. The only way to force its arm would be by getting the European Commission involved to outrank the Kartel Office.
And that is the focus in most news media this week, because it’s the only place where this merger breaks down. In the UK, where Vodafone has no fixed lines, Virgin has just a few million mobile subscribers, but they are only MVNO customers anyway; in France neither has any holdings and in Italy there is no cable. In Spain, where Vodafone has bought the dominant cable operator Ono, Liberty Global does not operate.
Everywhere else this deal is of little consequence to a regulator – Vodafone does not have a direct subsidiary in Belgium, in Switzerland where Liberty Global holds Cablecom, Vodafone has a partnership deal with Swisscom, and no direct ownership in cellular or fixed lines. In Romania Vodafone is not into fixed lines yet, and so can easily merge with a slightly dominant Liberty Global there, as it can in Hungary, as is true in the Czech Republic.
The only other bone of contention is in the Netherlands where Liberty Global’s dominant position in broadband will mean that Vodafone should not be allowed to add its own fiber lines to the mix, but it could easily offload those to Orange or KPN, with little effect on the merger.
If in Germany Vodafone is told by the regulator to offload “Kabel Deutschland” or “Unity Media” then that puts a considerable obstacle in the way. Vodafone would have to ascertain that it could manage that without incurring too much of a loss on the buying and selling transactions of Kabel Deutschland (because we think it would prefer to keep UnityMedia BW).
That may represent a problem, particularly in nailing down an accurate valuation, but we cannot see it being an insurmountable one. Liberty would suggest to Vodafone that it challenges this through the courts, while Vodafone might simply shrug and take the long term view, and swap Unity Media for Kabel Deutschland, and do the deal with a promise to offload Kabel Deutschland to a friendly party.
Telefonica in Germany has a serious problem, in that it has just a few million ADSL lines which are in retreat, and as such it has closed its pay TV operation there. It just acquired E-Plus, taking the German cellular market down to just 3 operators. But this Telefonica weak fixed line position means it needs some leverage for small cell and WiFi deployments. Our feel is that pretty much every cellular operator will need access to fixed lines going forward.
Telefonica so far appears to have decided to throw in its broadband lot with Deutsche Telekom, as Vodafone appeared to do last year when it signed for a VULA license (virtual unbundled local access) giving it access to DT next gen broadband lines. This is because vectoring needs to be managed by a single operator per DSLAM, so Deutsche will do it for everyone and offer partial bitstream access, a bit like renting part of a fiber. Telefonica earlier this year got permission from the German Kartel Office to use Deutsche Telekom broadband lines in the same way.
Now here is where Germany is weak on regulation. It loves Deutsche Telekom and tends to end up making decisions in its favor, like it is a national asset. The European Commission has had to remind it on more than one occasion that it must eliminate protectionism, where DT is concerned. Telefonica would much rather have cable across half the country than rely on Deutsche Telekom for all backhaul and all WiFi offload, and what might come out of an objection by the Kartel Office, is a triopoly (an oligopoly with three sellers) as cable home go to Telefonica.
While this is the focus this week in most of the newspapers, we can see a little further. We have already had one bad decision by the European Commission, allowing UPC in the Netherlands to merge with Ziggo. And if we see another, even more major merger pushed through, with just a few concessions in Germany and the Netherlands, it will become open season on fixed line players across Europe. Our view has been that would have a huge deleterious effect on existing pay TV for the consumer, but the European Commission may be taking the longer view of focusing on TV as if it was already a purely OTT market, and be preparing competition for services in next generation TV.
In Italy the cellular market is already more or less a duopoly between the Telefonica controlled Telecom Italia and Vodafone, but with a dominant fixed line share held by Telecom Italia. In Spain Telefonica is dominant with Vodafone and Orange investing heavily in fiber to use as a springboard to match Telefonica. In Germany T-Mobile and Vodafone did tower above Telefonica, but have now both being overtaken by Telefonica with its purchase of E-Plus. In France there are four operators each with fixed lines and there is every chance that the two smallest will merge to make up ground on the market leaders.
Everywhere we look we see the fixed line as the kingmaker to mobile, and as Vodafone looks hard at this market this week, it has focused the mind of many an operator. What does T-Mobile do in markets where it had no fixed lines? Well it merges its operations or put them on the market. Same for Telefonica, as it has already done in the Czech republic, or these giants build out fiber like there is no tomorrow as Orange and Vodafone are doing in Spain.
If this deal is approved it will signal not so much the starting gun in a race, as the shot that animates a terrified crowd into a riot. It will lead to frantic fixed line consolidation, with cellular operators leading the charge. We calculate there are over 30 independent cable operators up and down the length and breadth of Europe which could be large enough to attract a bid, at a significantly increased rate per household than at any other time in the past decade, and incumbent telcos are also not safe.
The result could be a triopoly in many countries, not just of cellular players, but of fixed line players, as suddenly debt free cable aligns into a single, fixed line operator in each country, which goes head to head with the technically disadvantaged telcos. And in many cases this could rapidly lead to a duopoly in both fixed and cellular lines, and a headache for the European Commission of its own making, and one that will not serve competition or the consumer well.
Vodafone is already as we write this, attempting to quell pressure on its share price, by saying that it really is early days on this deal and there is only a very small chance of it actually happening.