The head of the Consumer Electronics Association, Gary Shapiro, made his position fairly clear to the Senate Commerce Committee that is looking at bringing in a new draft law to re-introduce in the US the idea of a Broadcast flag.
It would diminish innovation and undermine the right of Americans to enjoy products for noncommercial purposes within their private homes, something currently sanctioned under personal user rights in existing US law, he said.
The Broadcast flag is simply a code placed in each TV program that is broadcast, which instructs consumer electronic (CE) devices on whether they have permission to record or make copies of a particular program.
The FCC tried mandating the flag last year but a US court told the FCC it was extending beyond its legitimate reach, and that it could not make what are, in effect, new laws. That’s the role of the US Senate and Congress, so that’s where responsibility for re-invoking the broadcast flag has landed.
The concern among the public is that the power to prevent recordings would lie in the hands of broadcasters and content owners, not in the hands of private individuals, once CE devices were brought in that obeyed the flagging process.
The MPAA is thought to have wanted the new law to go way beyond the flagging system originally set by the FCC, halting the spread of home networks in their tracks. Also the senate committee is being encouraged by the Recording Industry Association of America to allow audio flagging under this or a separate piece of legislation, for high definition audio and satellite radio. This idea is pretty stupid given that XM and Sirius satellite both offer devices that record music for later listening.
The CEA called for exceptions to the flag to include news and public affairs programming and should include wording that allows consumers to decrypt copy protection for non-infringing purposes. This is currently illegal under the Digital Millenium Copyright Act, and being looked at under a separate piece of legislation.
Any kind of flag will prevent equipment being sold in the US that can copy flagged broadcast video onto an iPod or other portable device and would cause uproar among US iPod owners. It would also never be taken up outside of the US, and could cause a major schism between US copyright law and the rest of the world. So I guess it won’t happen. We’ll have to see.