Your browser is not supported. Please update it.

23 November 2005

Cellcos gang up over ‘excessive’ royalties, call for ETSI rule change

The UK’s Financial Time reported this week that the big European cellcos, led by Vodafone, T-Mobile and Telef’nica have demanded that the European Commission acts to protect them and consumers from huge royalty bills.

They demand an overhaul of how ETSI, the European standards maker, agrees standards, to avoid intellectual property traps where companies contribute technology to a standard and then later reveal patents and claw back huge royalties.

The criticism might be aimed at a number of warring groups in the mobile scene right now, with Nokia, Ericsson and others pushing for limitation on royalties charged on core mobile technologies, which has irked Qualcomm and forced it into recent legal actions. But they may also be just as likely to have been pushed into action by the recent debacle of OMA’s DRM standard which produced an unexpectedly large license fee.

Mobile handset makers get hit with patent payments for processor technology, radio modulation schemes, codecs, storage designs, interfaces, development kits, Java, DRM and many others, all in a device that is made for between $100 and $400. This gets passed on to operators that have to subsidize these phones.

The group wants to see ETSI rules on intellectual property rights tightened up or they say Europe risks losing the benefits of standardization. They suggest that Intellectual Property Terms must be agreed before a standard is set, rather than after it, and want to see caps on maximum royalties, something that Nokia has made a lot of noise about, and has been rebuffed by Qualcomm. The proposal is also apparently being backed by Alcatel, Hutchison Europe, Orange, Portugal Telecom, Research in Motion, SFR, Swisscom, TDC, Telecom Italia, Telenor and TeliaSonera.