Your browser is not supported. Please update it.

17 July 2014

Channel 4 head calls for encrypted iPlayer from BBC

Channel 4’s chairman Lord Burns has declared that the BBC should enforce license fee payments by encrypting the iPlayer catch up service. Burns said that it should be the first step towards a subscription model, as the license fee is unsustainable in the long term.

Such a move would put all BBC video content behind a pay wall. This is the latest in mounting pressure on the BBC to move away from the license fee and towards a commercial business model. Currently, the iPlayer is free to use for catch up content.

In response to the new BBC director general Tony Hall’s vision for the future, Burns criticized the BBC for being tied to the license fee, speaking at the Future of the License Fee event in London. He said the organization had ignored alternative funding possibilities such as subscription because ‘it could get away with it’ and fall back on its guaranteed revenues from the UK government.

However, Hall has ‘real confidence in the license fee. Whatever reform people come up with, they need to answer the question ‘is there a better way of funding it than 40p a day?’ I don’t think there is.’ But Burns is just one of many detractors who believe that the license fee model is unsustainable ‘ and notes that it is unpopular with many UK residents and a number of politicians.

Burns said ‘you can either say you can only watch the iPlayer if you have a license or you can watch the iPlayer without a license if you pay some money. This is the first big opportunity to move towards conditional access ‘ no pay, no play ‘ but they won’t even think about it because they think it is the first step towards subscription. They will not even think about it because they are so wedded to the license fee.’

But any move away from the current model might be seized upon by opponents who would aim to push the BBC to the inevitable conclusion of a fully commercial model ‘ and this is something that the BBC has historically been very wary of for fear of suddenly finding itself at the thin end of a government-driven wedge.

Burns previously oversaw a review of the BBC a decade ago and concluded that ‘the license fee is effectively a tax and I am very pessimistic about the ability of the BBC to fund itself long term through a tax. I think the political process is just too difficult.’

But it should be noted that in the ten years since his review, the BBC has continued to operate and launch the iPlayer service. While there are always calls to scrap the license fee, the BBC itself has pointed out that moving to a subscription model would cost £500 million to implement.

Hall has pointed in the past to the competition from ITV, BT, Sky, Virgin Media, Netflix and Amazon as proof that the license fee does not undermine competition in the video content market, adding that the BBC helps the entire sector just as it benefits in return.

He believes that it represents great value for money, as the advertisement-free services reach 96% of the UK population each week, and is used for an average of six hours per household. Hall added that the real-terms cost of the license had fallen slightly over the last twenty years, but in that time the BBC had quadrupled its TV channel numbers, doubled its national radio channels and launched its web services and the iPlayer.

With regard to alternative financing avenues, Hall said a subscription model would turn the BBC into an organization looking to maximize profits, which would end up targeting those with the highest willingness to pay. He feared that it would prioritize certain audiences over others and that the BBC’s universal access principles would be abandoned in favor of programs that got the highest ratings instead of the highest cultural worth. ‘Those paying would have to spend more to get the BBC.’

But Hall is open to expanding the license fee to cover all BBC programming and not just the live content, bringing it into line with what Burns and the like are calling for.

According to the BBC’s 2012/13 annual report, its total income was £5.1 billion ($8.73 billion). £3.6 billion came from license fees including £597 million in government concessions for pensioners, £1.1 billion from the BBC’s commercial businesses, and £270 million from government grants which includes the Foreign Office grant of £264 million for the BBC World Service. Its total expenditure for 2012/13 was £4.9 billion.

The £145 annual television license was reclassified as a tax in 2006. Many believe it to be the worst regressive tax in Britain, and note that the majority of those who evade the license are either single parents, lone tenants, pensioners and the ‘economically inactive.’

The BBC has also been widely criticized for its aggressive collection practices, including household inspections and search warrants. As the license is a tax, evasion is a criminal offence, and as the BBC is responsible for collecting payments it is one of the largest prosecuting authority in the UK ‘ responsible for around 10% of all cases in magistrate courts. The legal cost saving might turn out to be the biggest argument in favor of moving to a subscription pay-wall model.