Cisco used the Consumer Electronics Show in Las Vegas this week to stake two huge claims in set top design wins, but for the most part they were paraded as installations where the set top will either stay the same or disappear – at Charter Communications in the US and Kabel Deutschland Group (KDG) in Germany – between them adding up to a captive audience of over 10 million homes.
The first out of the bag was KDG, where Cisco says that it will be market ready with a cloud based delivery system towards the end of 2016 and install it through 2017, where it will combine search, recommendation and personalization to multiple screen types from a cloud-powered platform.
It didn’t say much about the technical detail behind such a platform, but it is well known that in Germany Deutsche Telekom is leading a move towards set top free pay TV, and KDG, now part of Vodafone, will need to respond. By the same token the other two pay TV rivals in Germany are Sky, which already has a working OTT system – Sky Go for existing customers and Sky Online to attract new customers, and Liberty Global’s Unity Media, which with its Horizon program was one of the early European innovators first in UIs, and later in Cloud TV.
So slowly Germany is becoming a hotbed for pay TV and quad play innovation, where once it was a backwater. KDG says it will unveil technical details at IFA 2015 in September.
And the key technology driving cloud TV right now belongs to ActiveVideo, which is known to have licensed it to Cisco shortly after successfully defending its intellectual property against Verizon in a patent court in the US in 2012, where it won a $260 million settlement.
The KDG system will take in broadcast, on-demand, catch-up, and time-shift TV across the Internet, to all types of devices, but we imagine that part and parcel of this will be the cloud rendering capabilities of ActiveVideo, also in play with the strategies of both Deutsche Telekom and Liberty Global and Germany.
Cisco says it will create a comprehensive video-hub for each home and subscribers will be able to access all video through a single UI which will work across all their TVs and personal devices. It is unclear which companies will be used to provide personalization, but Cisco has worked with numerous technologies in the past, most often with UK player ThinkAnalytics (on Liberty Global’s Horizon). It is unlikely that Cisco would make that decision anyway but we would bet on ThinkAnalytics getting the deal. The other two candidates would be TiVo’s Digitalsmiths which has been particularly successful in the US, and Rovi’s Veveo, which has yet to be successful anywhere. Increasingly we see Cisco working outside the US with ThinkAnalytics and perhaps may even use the relationship to take ownership of the technology at some point.
The idea is to solve the problem of personalizing content from multiple sources on the internet plus a broadcast and catch up as well as locally stored content and cloud SVoD content, but right now everyone has that problem.
The new system will be based on a new cloud-powered TV platform which KDG will develop together with Cisco. The platform moves control and functionality into the cloud, making it quick and easy for KDG to update features and offer new services.
But the real clue to where the money is, is the fact that this will also use connected devices from Cisco, selected to deliver as an open, integrated home-hub. That seems to imply that transcoding might happen in this home hub rather than in the cloud, although at Faultline we are fairly sure that this is a close decision right now and it could go either way.
To us this all seems to be about a tie in with conditional access once again, or perhaps with a downloadable DRM, but we’ll explain this in a minute, after dipping into the oh so similar Charter deal. Kabel Deutschland was traditionally a Nagra conditional access customer, but around five years ago it changed to the old Cisco Videoguard service initially running simulcrypt and has since switched off Nagra. It won a deal in 2011 to provide set tops using its MediaHighway middleware, Videoguard and its EPG server.
In the US Cisco and Charter have entered what they call a strategic agreement whereby Cisco supplies key products to Charter’s own designed next-generation video system.
At Charter however it is explicit that the deal involves some element of conditional access, specifically Cisco’s cloud-based security suite, including downloadable security solution (DCAS) for set-top boxes as well as a DRM system for a wider range of IP devices. This is a DRM tie in by another name, and it works like this. For the past 2.5 years Charter has been installing, with permission from the FCC, set tops that have a smart card in them, but which also have set top processors which themselves have not one, but multiple encryption processors.
The idea was to copy what Cablevision has done in the US, and get out of being forced to use CableCARD systems in set tops and the way that works is that you have a downloadable DRM, and must also be able to switch to at least one other downloadable DRM at any point in time. That way cable operators are not physically long term tied in to a particular supplier. From the consumer point of view, it also means they can have some say in their hardware.
But during the early days of downloadable DRMs, it is wisest to work with a sole supplier for set tops, to make sure that there are as few download problems as possible. The way this is facilitated is that either inside the processor chip or on a separate chip in the set top, different security cores with separate key ladders exist, which can be used to manage entirely different encryption regimes.
For instance many Broadcom set top chips have an NDS key ladder built in, one for rival Nagra and another open one from Cryptography Research Inc (CRI), which can be used by other rivals, such as Verimatrix. This means they can all give hardware support to encryption.
There is a massive problem running a downloadable DRM, unless there is an initial secret encryption key placed into each of these secure areas of the set top chips. Increasingly it is becoming obvious to cable MSOs that the only way of doing that is to place them there themselves, at the point of chip manufacture, and we covered back in September how both CRI (in handsets) and Irdeto (in set tops) are now offering services to manage keys for major MNOs and MSOs.
If you have three separate key ladders to manage, then you are going to have a bad outcome if these are managed by three different entities, one in particular is the incumbent in a supply contract and the other two are not financially rewarded for their efforts. Hence the need for a separate key management process from the DRM.
Charter has complained time and again to the FCC that CableCARD would cost it too much and that downloadable DRM is so much cheaper, and will now retrofit it to those devices which are capable and to new devices while leaving older devices with their existing smart cards.
All of that, to us looks like a set top DRM tie in just like the old days which will mean Cisco getting account control. The natural question to ask is why do companies like Charter continue to work with the two companies which first engineered the US cable DRM lock in (Scientific Atlanta and Motorola had 75% of cable set tops traditionally between them and became Cisco and Arris latterly), instead of working with brand new companies that were never part of that fiasco. The answer of course is all about scale, and companies like Cisco, no longer using the old Scientific Atlanta CA, but instead resorting to the NDS technology it acquired in 2012, can afford to be expert at downloadable DRM and take the financial hit implied by it, in return for getting paid for revolutionizing the TV experience. And anyway if much of the UI is in the cloud, then the operator savings achieved by leaving set tops installed for many more years, facilitated by the ActiveVideo tools, more than pays for any tendency to buy more set top volume from fewer, or even a sole supplier.
Of course NDS in its turn was never as strong in downloadable DRM as, say Verimatrix or Irdeto or Widevine, because it never believed in the concept, but it is technically expert enough to manage it, and anyway in a multi-device world, you have no choice but to move towards downloadable and multiple DRMs. And anyway NDS within Cisco now has more and more economies of scale.
So Cisco as a result will supply a “substantial share” of Charter’s next-generation Worldbox devices and will continue to supply CableCARD boxes until Charter migrates all current and acquired systems to the downloadable security system.
Charter CEO Tom Rutledge in announcing the deal at CES showed three different set-top boxes the new Cisco designed Worldbox, one designed six years earlier, but with a DOCSIS modem in it, and another Scientific-Atlanta box which was 11 years old.
“Our new user interface, using technology provided by ActiveVideo, allows us to place our guide on every set-top box. It uses the VOD infrastructure to deliver a state-of-the-art, IP-based guide, streamed as video using MPEG.
“So while the old box doesn’t have a DOCSIS modem in it, it can look at streamed MPEG signals using ActiveVideo’s technology. This lets us take advantage of every box we have deployed.
“We’re taking the intelligence out of the box and putting it into the network and making the box a thin client box so that the processing power of the box is no longer a relevant issue. That’s a breakthrough.”
Rutledge’s points have been made ably by ActiveVideo in the past, that this gives an MSO the instantaneous capability to deploy a state-of-the-art UI everywhere, without a new box purchase. This is cocking a snook at Comcast and its X1 Xfinity box and similar Time Warner Cable approaches, which were a far more expensive way to go.
We cannot guess at the number of Worldboxes that Charter will have to deploy, but it will be far less than it has been deploying on a month by month basis, in the recent past. Charter says that it is currently working with other vendors aiming at making compatible boxes for the retail market as well, so that consumers can simply go out and buy them.
Charter will offer an HD only version, one with a DVR and these will have dual IP/QAM capabilities, 16 tuners, a DOCSIS 3.0 modem, 1 Gig of RAM, a USB port and a terabyte of storage. Charter is clearly not quite ready to shift to a nPVR or Cloud storage approach, given the peculiar US rules on keeping separate copies of each broadcast program for every customer.
Interestingly we know that Charter chose TiVo’s Digitalsmiths for its recommendation server to personalize its TV Everywhere platforms, so we would expect this to make an appearance in the Worldbox set tops too, but with searches coming down from the cloud.
Presumably the Worldbox will include that ability to retrofit HEVC encoding and cope with 4K content at some point, at least in processing terms and the ability to run HTML 5.0 natively. When Charter actually says its cable network is ready to cope with 4K is another matter.
But all of this is genuinely a huge reduction in running costs for Charter, and should, in coming quarters, offer it the churn reduction which Xfinity has brought Comcast, alongside the capex reductions which Comcast has entirely failed to avoid. One finance analyst, Craig Moffett of Moffett research has publicly stated he thinks the cost of building a cloud-based system with the World Box will come in at around $600 million, mostly in network infrastructure costs, while he says that the complete deployment of an IP-based set-top system might exceed $3 billion.
So while Cisco may have laid a claim to a much larger chunk of the Charter business, it may be that each sale is at a lower sale price, and there is not a genuine DRM lock in, which means that if Cisco does not behave as a supplier, it could, theoretically at least, be kicked out in favor of a rival supplier at any point in the future. That too must be reflected in the price.