Who said that Europe has no coax? Europe has tons of coax ‘ but it’s built into existing multi-dwelling units (MDUs) which house more than 50% of the EU population.
One of Entropic’s European partners InCoax dropped us a brief story at IBC and has put out a release for the Broadband World Forum in Paris this week, which talks about using it to drive broadband to all the MDUs in Europe, using Ethernet over Coax (EoC) chip sets, built around the MoCA standard.
The trick is to take existing cable TV cabling (in most cases) and run MoCA over the top of it, in separate spectrum so that it doesn’t interfere with the cable TV signal. Cable TV is anywhere from 5 MHz to 862 MHz and MoCA then has around 1 to 1.5 GHz to play with. InCoax says that it can offer 100 Mbps to each home today and could reach up to 1 Gbps in the future, presumably talking about it incorporating MoCA 2.0 at some point in 2012. As far as we understand it MoCA operates in 100 MHz bands, but can support multiple bands at once.
The cost of building something like this into MDUs comes at around €60 to €80 per home, depending on the guaranteed capacity required, InCoax says, and that includes the price of a modem.
InCoax said, ‘In many European countries the MDU building size is 20 to 30 apartments, but the technology can be used in any building size because the cable-TV structure does not allow too many subscribers behind each amplifier.’
In somewhere like Germany there are 1,000 cable TV companies which are just incumbent suppliers to an MDU, many of these cannot afford the plant to upgrade to a digital network nor have the capex to put in DOCSIS 3.0 modems which would bring broadband offerings up to 300 Mbps per home.
In MDUs that are denied cable upgrades, that leaves the burden on VDSL, because the twisted pair is also installed when the building is first put up, just like the coax.
InCoax is saying that the price per home of bringing broadband in using MoCA is more cost effective than VDSL. Also using the MoCA technology InCoax says it can connect different nodes around the same home, so for instance connecting computers, games consoles, DVR’s and other home appliances together and the company is selling this as distribution for fiber to the building, using a point to multi-point network architecture.
InCoax offers a backbone fiber connection with Gigabit capacity, connected to a central Coax Link Controller (CLC) installed behind the last Cable-TV TV amplifier.
The CLC communicates over the passive coaxial cable with a modem in each apartment. It can operate over any type of coaxial network since the CLC establishes an individual encrypted data stream with each modem. The system has less crosstalk interference, the company claims, than DSL. InCoax calls it Gigabit over Coax Access and says it is scalable and can support up to 124 clients for each CLC.
The company says that DOCSIS costs a lot more to install and requires a higher up-front investment (Cable Modem Termination System) and has a lower uplink speed, and in Europe even cable companies are looking at the InCoax ideas with a view to installing a cheaper system than DOCSIS.
There have been many special MDU attempts in Europe, and UK set top maker Pace had a system which used the DOCSIS protocols specifically in the way InCoax describes, with a single line coming from fiber being broken into multiple networks. That has mostly been installed by satellite operators who often cannot get a signal into the home any other way. Of course that wouldn’t work if all the TV channels travelled up and down the building, so Pace designed a special box which only sends those channels being watched, like a multicast, and offers the rest of the capacity as DOCSIS? Actually given that it’s in different spectrum you could do DOCSIS and MoCA side by side, so it doesn’t really compete head on.
InCoax told us, ‘When broadband operators want to deploy fiber to MDU the big challenge is who is going to pay for the in-building network. By EU law the in-building network is a part of the building and owned by the building owner. Building owners can’t see any reason to pay for CAT5/6 cables or fiber installation at anything between €200 to €700 per home. VDSL technology is too sensitive to crosstalk. So using free capacity in existing coax makes most sense.’