The idea of making a High Definition DVD player that combines both the Sony inspired Blu-ray design and the Toshiba backed HD DVD technology was in the news again this week, with NEC Electronics saying it could build a controller that would support both, and go to market next year as a single chip for $84.
That’s all very well, but the remaining costs of the two separate devices still make it prohibitive to attempt, and two of the new blue lasers need to be acquired, each supporting different power requirements and different performance criteria.
Engadget reports that the NEC chip would be ready for shipments of 300,000 a year during 2007 starting in April.
It’s just not going to happen. The first company to say it would offer a dual device was Samsung, which has gone very quiet since, followed by Pioneeer and LG Electronics, who are also less vocal now than they once were about the idea. NEC, it must be remembered, supported HD DVD technology from the outset and was Toshiba’s loyal partner until Sony came along and bought its DVD division last year, while Pioneer and LG were some of the first to drop HD DVD and opt for Blu-ray as soon as Sony broke away.
Sony has maintained that the initial market is a low volume high priced market for high definition DVD players and Toshiba has come to market with a device which costs less than the components in it, in an attempt to hijack early sales. Toshiba is probably doing okay right now, but the weight of content and manufacturing power behind Blu-ray with content deals with all but one of the major US studios and with what amounts to 90% of the global consumer electronics manufacturing power (Samsung, Matshushita, Philips, Apple, HP, Dell and of course Sony, to name a few) Blu-ray should drive down in price in the second half of 2007 to create a $500 device, and flood the market with High Definition content.
That time frame is likely to be the turning point in this market and it will be the first time that component volumes are sufficient for a cheap combo drive. Our take is that the volumes will go to Blu-ray at that point and no sooner, and there will be no point in a combo with HD, which will then wither.