Your browser is not supported. Please update it.

13 October 2011

Comcast alludes to Xbox 360 TV service in denouncing FCC AllVid

Comcast has published a statement that it has just sent to the FCC, effectively condemning the AllVid Notice of Enquiry put out 18 months ago by the FCC, but in the process has opened up a little on some of its future TV Everywhere initiatives, mostly marketed under the Xfinity brand.

The FCC AllVid NOI was filed in March 2010 and is a replacement for cablecard, which goes a lot further. It doesn’t just take conditional access and abstract it from the underlying device, but adds to this the EPG or other search function, and aims to bring a single navigation design to multiple services.

There are a lot of technical details to the AllVid specification to enable this, which is a little dumb, because here the FCC is taking the role of CableLabs and designing the equipment.

Comcast’s reply talks about a device which it calls AnyPlay, but which is likely to be the Motorola Televation which was launched at The Cable Show in Chicago in June, which even then was discussed as a joint effort with Comcast, as well as Xfinity services going to the Xbox 360 where navigation will be integrated into the Kinect 3D gesture and voice controls as well as the overall Xfinity TV Online service, which go to PCs, Macs and Tablets and it plans access to the same content on Samsung Smart TVs.

Granted most of this is already known, but the thrust of it is that the cable companies are under enough commercial pressure that they are already partnering with other device makers and opening their content to new navigation paradigms and viewing formats. In effect Comcast is saying , ‘commercial pressure has already forced us to do what you want, please don’t go through with your rulemaking,’

The first mentions of Comcast Xfinity TV being available on the Xbox 360 (and this also includes traditional cable VoD) was made about a week ago when rumors broke that Microsoft was obtaining partnerships with Comcast, Verizon and AT&T. This Comcast letter was the first confirmation of the story, but then Microsoft press released it yesterday.

Microsoft is adopting a very different approach though from Google and Apple, who both wish to gain access to content so that their own services, whether linear and channel based or purely VoD based, come from these two companies, and are not part and parcel of a cable subscription effort.

At Faultline we are always in favor of content finding a new expression through a new medium, because that’s how change happens. We should not confuse this with TV Everywhere systems which are about retaining the status quo. Comcast currently charges a huge premium on TV channels and services, because it contributes to the upkeep of its expensive cable network. Other pure internet rivals such as Sezmi demonstrate just how cheap this might go in future, offering a combination of over the air TV and Over the Top broadband TV for as little as $5 a month.

This type of unbundling of services from the infrastructure which carries these services, is never going to happen if we all continue to pay $135 a month to Comcast for an Xfinity TV service which effectively acts as a gatekeeper for any Tablet TV efforts by making it clear that you must be an existing Comcast subscriber to access Xfinity. In our view tying one to the other should be illegal, which would force Comcast to unbundle too.

The FCC would get a good deal more for its effort if it went down that route, rather than trying to redesign cable

Comcast added, ‘We are working with TiVo on a solution to deliver Xfinity On Demand to TiVo CableCARD devices. We are aiming to start trialing the service later this year and we demonstrated a device called AnyPlay at the 2011 Cable Show that will enable subscribers to access our cable services on IP devices connected to the home network without the need for additional set-top boxes. AnyPlay will be launched in certain markets this Fall. It will work initially with the iPad and Motorola’s Xoom tablet.’

This AnyPlay device was marketed as the Motorola Televation at the same show. Essentially what it does it translate a tuned cable program into WiFi, protected by DTCP-IP stream protection for consumption on tablets which was designed in partnership with the Comcast Innovation Labs.

Motorola at the same show also showed work for Time Warner Cable for a home video gateway, the DCX3600M, which delivers video to and around a cable home in IP format in much the same way.

Comcast said that it would introduce further IP devices into the home network over time. All of which it says means that there is rapid and accelerating change in the home TV market, which makes raising the specter of AllVid mandates something that it says will chill investment and derail the innovation.

Of course what the FCC is trying to do is effectively state just how cable can unbundle service from infrastructure. But in AllVid and the AllVid Alliance there is probably a step too far, where a specific architecture has been proposed.

This consists of the capability to decode up to six video streams into IP and feed them into the home network; connect them using 100BaseT Ethernet, use of DTCP-IP for stream protection and using Universal Plug and Play for service discovery. The AllVid Alliance suggesting this has founding members including Google, Sony Electronics, TiVo, Best Buy, Mitsubishi Digital Electronics, Nagravision and SageTV

Instead it should simply push for unbundled pricing on IP and QAM connectivity, and content, and that way new services would automatically appear. CableCard took forever for the FCC to push through, so AllVid is no imminent threat to cable.