Your browser is not supported. Please update it.

26 June 2014

Comcast at 3 million WiFi Hotspots and counting

Since Comcast announced its plans to build a network of public access WiFi hot spots in homes and businesses a year ago, it has turned on about three million of them and plans to ‘light up’ another five million by year-end. Comcast’s top-tier subscribers can access the hot spots for free when away from home ‘ at least where it’s available.

Comcast has said it is lighting up Hotspots in Houston, Boston, Chicago, San Francisco, Minneapolis, Seattle, Philadelphia and Indianapolis. It plans to have by year-end Hotspots in 19 of the largest US cities where it offers its service. It does that by swapping subscribers’ existing modems for one from Arris that supports a second SSID to it can create a commercial Hotspot and then remotely activating the router’s Hotspot function.

US cable TV companies have banded together in the Cable WiFi Alliance to build a near-nationwide more-or-less free WiFi network for their subscribers. Bright House Networks, Cox Communications, Cablevision, Time Warner Cable and Comcast are members. It’s not clear why Charter is not a member. Chip and equipment makers are already developing products that will enhance the performance of these Hotspot networks, which will also be available from cable TV subscribers in public places and businesses.

The Cable WiFi Alliance says there are already more than 250,000 WiFi Hotspots ‘ and Comcast and Cox were in the early stages of their deployments when that statement was made and it did not count any home gateways that had been turned into Hotspots (Homespots). The major difference between a Homespot and a Hotspot is that Hotspots are planned and spaced for maximum effectiveness and tend to be outdoors, which allows the power outputs to almost double under FCC regulations.

While some think the service may only be used by babysitters and visiting guests, it appears it’s all part of the cellcos’ plans for a near-nationwide wireless broadband service that would compete for wireless broadband access against cellcos such as AT&T and Verizon. It could also be used to compete against the cellcos in mobile phone service, either with its own or a third-party’s WiFi First phone service. Some cellular-capable tablets are already WiFi First devices. They look for and connect to an available WiFi connection before they look for and connect to a cellular network.

The cablecos have not made clear their policy on WiFi First, in which a wireline service provider would offer a combination of WiFi and mobile phone services. Specially built devices would first try to connect by finding a WiFi access point and then, having failed at that, would connect to a cellular network.

Scratch Wireless currently offers a smartphone from Lenovo’s Motorola Mobility that does exactly that. By Scratch’s own selection, having failed to connect to an available WiFi network, the smartphone connects to Sprint’s network. Scratch Wireless has been trying to sell its smartphone through one or more of the cablecos but has so far not been successful, so it and other WiFi First device makers may have to go it alone. Sprint is certainly happy to have the extra business but at this point AT&T and Verizon might consider WiFi First a nuisance and competitive to the cellular service they’re selling ‘ which it definitely is. Cablecos may be reluctant to offer the WiFi First telephony service, because they would like to partner with the major MNOs and perhaps don’t want to upset them too much by offering WiFi First.

In documents that Comcast filed with the feds in connection with its planned $32 billion purchase of Time Warner Cable, Comcast said a network such as the one enabled by its residential Hotspots ‘could make a ‘WiFi-first’ service, which combines commercial mobile radio service with WiFi.’

Last year Comcast sold spectrum to Verizon and as part of that deal Comcast is allowed to access Verizon’s wireless network. That could allow Comcast’s WiFi First users to connect automatically to Verizon’s cellular network when they are out-of-range of WiFi First Hotspots. Comcast and the other cablecos aren’t talking publicly about WiFi First and the topic was noticeably absent at the recent Cable Show.

The Hotspot service is available for free to Comcast’s top-tier broadband subscribers. Subscribers of lower tiers and non-Comcast subscribers get two free one-hour sessions per month, then they pay a fee per-hour, per-day or per-week. That seems a bit unfair to Comcast’s subscribers that don’t take its top-tier service, because they’re being treated the same as subscribers to Comcast rivals such as AT&T and Verizon. We expect that provision will change, particularly if the telcos start offering a similar WiFi Hotspot service for residential accounts.

Comcast is using Arris Touchstone telephony wireless gateway modems that are capable of supporting two separate WiFi networks ‘ one for those in the home, the ‘host’ ‘ and another for ‘guests.’ Users in the home always get as much bandwidth as they need, up to what they are paying for.

Neither can access the other’s connection nor ‘see’ what the others are doing. Users of the public Hotspot cannot ‘see’ or use any of the devices in the home such as printers, tablets or PCs. Hosts will not have to share their passwords and none of the other person’s usage will be counted against the subscriber’s account.

WiFi is not intended to be a mobile service and has a limited range of between 100 feet and 300 feet depending on which chips are being used. So it’s not likely that a person driving down the street can stay online in a moving vehicle on WiFi only, but it would be fine in a stationery vehicle.

Here’s a bonus: Comcast subscribers will only have to sign in once as a guest. Once they do, they will be automatically connected to Comcast or other cablecos’ WiFi Hotspot when one is available.

Comcast said it automatically turns on the service in all subscribers’ homes that have the Arris router, but subscribers can opt out. Comcast said it has sent several emails to the subscribers whose equipment has been turned on, alerting them to the fact that they can disable the public access. Subscribers that opt out can still access other subscribers’ Hotspots. Comcast said that less than 1% of its subscribers have opted out in areas where it has turned on the service.

The public access appears as ‘xfinitywifi’ on devices that are not on the home’s network.

Comcast said the extra capacity for public Hotspot users comes from a separate channel in the modem called a ‘service flow.’ It has 15 Mbps available and up to a max of five customers can connect at once. Guests are automatically signed in using their unique subscriber information, so any illegal activities can be traced back to the user.

The Arris routers have dual band ‘ 2.4-GHz and 5-GHz ‘ 802.11n technology, not the newer 11ac version of WiFi or the MU-MIMO version of WiFi that won’t be available in devices until 2015.

A host modem or router from a maker other than Arris will not be available on the Hotspot network. It’s increasingly obvious that there’s a significant difference between the use of the words ‘homespot’ and ‘Hotspot.’