Your browser is not supported. Please update it.

15 October 2015

Comcast first to denounce Virtual Head end as AllVid in disguise

In a tight negotiation, it is often said that he who speaks first loses. But in comments to a public body like the US FCC, it tends to be “he who speaks first sets the agenda.” Comcast this week has tried to set the agenda, to kill off one of the two proposals that will change US cable, and likely the rest of the world’s cable – but it has had to “change the facts” to put its ideas across.

DSTAC (downloadable security technology advisory committee) was a committee which Comcast was involved with and its conclusions will almost certainly define a technology which would change the entire financial basis of the cable TV industry, or rather the MVPD (multichannel video programming distributor) so there are a lot of vested interests at stake. If a downloadable security can be agreed upon in the US, it will end up being used worldwide, and DSTAC has offered us two scenarios, either of which might mean that set tops can become a retail proposition, rather than being subsidized and provided by cable operators.

Put simply Comcast has tried to sabotage one of DSTAC’s two proposals and effectively “jury-rig” the outcome of the FCC deliberations, by associating it with past failures, and suggesting it is the same.

The US Congress had asked the FCC to put the group together to recommend how to take the “lock-in” out of cable set tops. This is the third time such a committee has sat, on the first occasion it came up with the relatively successful, but limited CableCARD – successful because it did get a specification out and it was widely implemented – though it made no-one happy.

The second was in 2010 when the ill-fated AllVid committee sat and made a recommendation to replace CableCARD – which never got off the ground because it started as an FCC initiative, and did not come at the behest of Congress, but also because it went down a very specific hardware route which tried to create a standard replacement for all conditional access.

The commercial interests represented this time in DSTAC came from AT&T, Sony, EchoStar, Amazon, Cablevision, Public Knowledge, Comcast, Hauppauge, Vizio, MPAA, Arris, Google, Samsung, Charter, TiVo and Nagra and you would have thought they truly represented the industry interests, with virtually no-one (apart from Public knowledge) representing the man in the street.

Interestingly CableCARD is discussed these days in disparaging terms, despite it providing considerable relief to the US cable companies, who, at the time of its introduction, were being heavily punished financially by the CA lock-in conducted by General Instruments, since acquired by first Motorola, then eventually, via Google, ended up with Arris.

The things wrong with CableCARD was that although it separated set top and TV function from the conditional access, by putting decryption into a tiny card plug-in, it introduced 3rd party UIs into cable, it did not allow for interactivity and so was seen as impeding innovation (although the use of Apps and CableCARD have got past most of these weaknesses). CableCARD was widely avoided by TV makers, and it is of no use for connecting phones to the TV networks. It was installed in just 617,000 homes in the US. Interestingly Europe adopted the very similar CI+ modules (Common Interface) which has been highly successful.

Cablecos only hated CableCARD because they couldn’t control it, saying their UI was all important to them (which we accept), and it defined their services, and without control over it, they could not support CableCARD. In the end that was its downfall with the public too, as manufacturers did not like to be seen to support it, and so the UIs provided were poor.

And that’s exactly where Comcast is coming from again. In the late August report of DSTAC, two proposals were maintained – one called the Competitive Navigation system, which effectively said that the answer is Apps – now what was the question. The idea is for each conditional access maker to support a second set of encryption processes which are standardized upon using HTML5 and Encrypted Media Extensions, Media Source Extensions and Web Cryptography Extensions to allow multiple DRMs to be used with them. That means that web browsers which now only support proprietary security extensions from Microsoft and Google, can use PlayReady and Widevine, and Apps can use third party DRMs. This is seen by Comcast as being a slam dunk, as this has already been widely embraced by the market.

It is the other proposal referred to as the “Virtual Head End” which Comcast has objected to and which it insists on calling the “Device” or AllVid” proposal. This puts forward the idea that current conditional access systems resolve in either a real cloud or a local cloud, and security is then converted to advanced “stream protection” using, for instance DTCP-IP, so that, in-effect, all streams that either reach into the home, or travel around the home, use a standard protection process using Common Encryption and MPEG DASH. This is also pretty much what has been happening in some parts of the world.

A remote user interface is maintained, so the services keep their UI differentiation, something which never happened with CableCARD or AllVid.

Interestingly we have mentioned the same kind of service as we look at the future – a cloud based video delivery system with a generalized downloadable software based DRM format, where the server in the home is the home gateway. We came up with this idea when Vidipath, a DLNA idea was proposed, and when Comcast and Time Warner Cable came together to provide the underlying technology.

In other words the ideas which Comcast is publicly lambasting are its own. Vidipath is just one method of providing a “cloud” based service, which then serves general purpose clients. Comcast is fine with this being the basis of a method for its own home gateways being enabled to make connections to smartphones and tablets. It is not fine about it being mandated by Congress as a way to get everyone off Conditional Access reliance.

Comcast made a number of arguments inside the DSTAC report, which fairly ridiculed the author of this suggestion – in this case Adam Goldberg, representing Public Knowledge. Those comments suggested that Goldberg was unaware of how each US cableco is different and how certification for this would work, saying that all cablecos in the US would have to radically re-architect their networks. Part of the remit of the DSTAC group was NOT to make US cablecos change their networks dframatically.

The report left questions lingering on how Instant channel change would be re-architected, how Electronic Sell Through and Pay-Per-View could work and how would such a system could support regional blackouts or zone based ad insertion, or interactive shopping or interactive advertising, And Comcast concluded that it would represent a significant, burdensome, and time-consuming development effort to standardize these protocols.

Goldberg’s suggestion that many existing home gateway devices could be converted into an interim Vidipath gateway using a software download showed how he lacked experience with cable systems, the criticisms went.

Finally in its submission to the FCC Comcast said that it would cost $1.6 billion in extra electricity for consumers, and use nine million metric tons of additional greenhouse gas emissions each year if US cable operators adopted it. Which is interesting considering that Vidipath is likely to be a key architecture step for US cable, and particular Comcast at some stage. But it will want this to come in at its own rate, at its own time of choosing and over an 8 or 9 year period, introduced regionally, rather than when an individual customer requests it.

Vidipath first came to light in March 2014 and it will extend pay TV content sharing in the home. It will natively support DTCP-IP security and an HTML5 UI and it can extend to digital TVs, mobile devices, Blu-ray players and games consoles. It will need the introduction of remote diagnostics for CE devices, to reduce help desk calls due to complex hardware or services, as well as UPnP Energy Management and a Networked Device Power Saver feature, to ensure devices conform to new energy regulations regarding sleep-state power consumption. So Comcast’s suggestion that it will use more electricity is extremely wide of the mark, and stinks of desperation.

The critical point about Vidipath is that content comes from the cloud and can go to either existing cable set tops, or TVs, and also to phones and CE devices using the same mechanisms. We’re not sure that Cable is ready for such a sudden change of its economics, and this is something that companies like Comcast want to introduce slowly.

DLNA told us last year that 15 member companies were preparing devices for Vidipath certification and products are now available to buy from retail to plug into the cables of major MSOs. In some ways it is similar to RVU which DirecTV and now AT&T use in volume, which enable a Remote User Interface to be displayed on connected consumer electronics devices in the home, which is the same as it would be on the original set top.

At Faultline we accept that the idea of building Apps and using them to implement Adaptive Bit Rate services is widely accepted, which is Comcast’s point, but that doesn’t mean that it is the right way to go in this debate. The aim is to let consumers choose the device they use to watch pay TV, and in the process take the burden from the pay TV supplier of providing that device – subsidized. Comcast not only sees the difficulty of that being mandated, but also the ease with which consumers would switch pay TV providers, and it would rather retain the job of supplying the set top as long as it gives it control of the TV experience.

Instead using moves like RDK and attracting the large CE manufacturers into set tops, it gets its cake and eats it, by keeping control of the pay TV experience, but by dramatically bringing down the cost of the devices it has to buy.