Your browser is not supported. Please update it.

13 March 2014

Comcast ‘FreeWheeling’ towards YouTube killer

The strongest indication yet that Comcast will launch an alternative to YouTube and start a bidding war for online content came early this month with its $350 million purchase of online video ad technology and services firm FreeWheel. This is small beer alongside the $45 billion Comcast will pay for rival MSO TimeWarnerCable if, and that is a big if, the regulators allow it through.

But it is highly significant given that it would dovetail perfectly with a YouTube like service highly reliant on advertising revenue, even if there is a subscription or pay element. It is true that the FreeWheel platform would work with Comcast’s existing TV Anywhere service, Xfinity TV Go app, which lets subscribers remotely watch up to 35 channels of live cable programming via iOS and Android devices over any Wi-Fi network inside or outside the subscriber’s home. After all FreeWheel’s flagship product called Monetization Rights Management (MRM) is designed to manage ad sales in the US ecosystem comprising syndicated video and fits well with existing pay TV operators. In fact Comcast’s arch DTH rival and US number two pay TV operator DirecTV is one of the principle customers, as is Dish Network, which adds spice to the deal.

But Xfinity TV Go is confined to existing subscribers and it is unlikely that Comcast would invest in a new online ad platform purely for that. YouTube incidentally itself is a FreeWheel partner, so that relationship too is likely to end if Comcast decides to compete directly. Comcast has already been accused by some of its customers of throttling back You Tube channels causing frequent buffering, stoking the net neutrality debate. Comcast also appeared to do the same to Netflix, until the two signed a deal to connect the latter’s CDN direct to the former’s HFC infrastructure. As a result streaming speed and quality of Netflix traffic over Comcast’s network increased, adding yet more fuel for net neutrality zealots. Some people think that giving priority to one operator is just as much against the spirit of net neutrality as slowing down another’s service.

Meanwhile there have been signs of Comcast’s DTH rivals, DirecTV and Dish Network, ramping up for launch of a ‘pay TV Lite’ OTT-only service along the lines of Sky’s Now TV in the UK and this is now about to happen. Dish has just signed a deal with Disney for rights to carry the Disney Channel, ABC and ESPN online, in return for agreeing to limit use of its infamous ad-skipping technology. The only reason for doing this would be for an Internet TV service, with Dish’s chief commercial officer Dave Shull admitting that the Disney-ESPN content deal is a key part of its OTT strategy. Dish hopes it will rope in new subscribers, both among those who would never consider a bloated full blown pay TV package costing a 100 bucks or more a month, as well as those unwilling or prohibited from mounting satellite dishes on their homes.

This means the race is on to deliver pay TV Lite over the Internet in the US and Comcast believes it can score heavily by displacing YouTube while grabbing additional ad revenue at a time when revenues from traditional spot commercials are ebbing.

However this does all put a spanner in the works of Comcast’s bid for TWC, for it increases pressure on regulators to block the deal. The merger has to be approved by the Federal Trade Commission (FTC) or Justice Department on competition grounds, as well as by the Federal Communications Commission (FCC) on the question of whether it is in the public interest.

There are good reasons for the deal failing on both counts. Comcast might have judged it would go through in the light of a 2009 FCC ruling, after its own lobbying, to allow individual service providers to have up to 30% of the US pay TV market without provoking anti-trust action. For this reason Comcast has offered to divest 3 million subscribers from the proposed combined operation with TWC since this would bring the total number of subs just below 30% of the US pay TV market. Even so at 30 million the cable giant would leave DirecTV way behind at 20 million, instead of being almost neck and neck with Comcast as at present.

A factor prompting closer regulatory scrutiny than previous deals is the fact that Comcast owns the NBC network and therefore has a considerable stake in content as well. This means that at the very least Comcast would have to guarantee fair access to NBC programming to its competitors in return for getting the TWC deal approved.

But there is also the public interest factor, which relates again to the power the combined company would have over content, but also to the impact on choice in the broadband market. To some extent it would not make a huge difference to the latter, given that there is little overlap between the footprints of Comcast and TWC, which is one reason the deal makes good sense for them. But it does mean that Comcast would have about 40% of the US broadband market, which is an unprecedentedly high share for that market, unlike some European countries such as Spain where telecoms deregulation has been more recent and less complete, leaving the incumbent still quite dominant. Given the US history of anti-trust action in telecoms, which started with the breakup of the then totally dominant long distance carrier AT&T in the 1980s, it would be unacceptable for a single operator to even approach having a majority share today.

This nerve was tweaked recently by Chase Carey, Fox president and chief operating officer, who insisted that the “broadband issue” will loom largest when the US regulators review the proposed Comcast/TWC merger. Carey warned that approval would lead towards many homes having no real choice of broadband provider, which would actually only be true in a fairly small minority of cases. After all a lot of the homes that cannot obtain high speed broadband from one of the major Telcos, often AT&T or Verizon, are also outside the footprint of either Comcast or TWC.

Carey’s comments do reflect nervousness on the part of the US Networks about the negotiating power an enlarged Comcast would have over content deals. Yet the likes of Fox, Disney and Viacom ought to be big enough to hold their own and it is the smaller networks that have real cause for concern. The fear for them is that it will become harder in general to win subscribers and keep carriage fees up with the big distributors. This has led to speculation that smaller networks like Discovery, Scripps Networks and AMC Networks could merge with other programming outlets or even with each other to gain more leverage in license fee negotiations with a Comcast-Time Warner Cable conglomerate. Discovery and Scripps have already discussed a potential merger. Such deals if they do happen, could make it harder in turn for remaining smaller independent networks to survive in an increasingly consolidated cable TV environment.

Concerns have also been expressed by some content providers, but particularly consumer groups and media watchdogs, over Netflix’s pact with Comcast for improved internet service. The difference is that this is a done deal and does not itself flout any regulations, given that Comcast has promised that it will respect net neutrality and not give Netflix traffic preferential treatment. Comcast did admit that Netflix would benefit from a ‘more direct connection’.

This sounds like splitting hairs, but means that Comcast is doing nothing to accelerate Netflix traffic once it hits its own HFC infrastructure. But it does not need to because then effectively there is unicast delivery to households and the only issue is contention between Netflix traffic and other Internet services being consumed by other users in that home. Comcast is merely saying then that it is not prioritizing Netflix over other Internet traffic to and from a given home. The point is that it is Netflix’ own investment in building out its CDN that is delivering the QoS and providing the resulting competitive advantage. In practice few other OTT service providers could afford to build similar CDN capacity on their own and so would be reliant on third party CDN services. At this stage such third party services do not have the same intimate connections to major broadband access providers such as Comcast.

Understandably consumer groups are concerned about the implications. Craig Aaron, president of internet rights lobby group Free Press, said he had ‘grave concerns’ about the deal. ‘As a customer you are in the dark here,’ he said. ‘Was Comcast degrading Netflix’s service to people as a negotiating tactic? To people, I’d add, who were paying month after month for Netflix’s service.’ And for that matter for Comcast broadband.

That is a fair point and according to John Bergmayer, senior staff attorney at the consumer rights group Public Knowledge, this comes back to the proposed Comcast/TWC merger. He argued that ISPs should be prevented by regulators from being able to hold networks and content providers hostage and that a Comcast-Time Warner Cable merger would militate against this. As a result Public Knowledge has lodged an objection to the merger. There is a decent chance such objections will be sustained or at the very least that substantial concessions will be wrung from Comcast and TWC in order to get the deal through.