Comcast has been targeted by a US family in a class action law suit, which aims to prevent Comcast using home gateway devices to offer WiFi using a second SSID. They want it to switch off all the Homespots.
The suit is clearly opportunistic and ill-informed, but that doesn’t mean it can be simply dismissed. A Californian resident and his daughter have both filed suit, claiming that the DOCSIS routers will use more of their home’s electricity if it is used for both providing broadband power to residents and also to passersby.
As in all class action law suits this is not about simply pacifying these individuals, if that was the case Comcast would just cut the couple out of the homespot opt-in program. Instead it is brought on behalf of all the people that may suffer, who do not complain, and the aim is to get a nice payout in court, for coming up with the suit.
In our view is it purely a nuisance suit – for a start a home router’s electrical draw is unlikely to change supporting a device which is constrained in output by an FCC imposed power definition – WiFi can only use a specific amount of EIRP – effectively the equivalent to transmitted power, but also the largest electrical draw is the formation of that signal. Even if it could be proved that the devices which offer a second SSID use more electrical power, then it would amount to pennies per month and that would mean a tiny settlement payout.
Also devices such as home gateways and set tops are specified by regulators to operate in a declining power curve for each successive year, and all Comcast would need to show is that this new device uses less power than its predecessor to win around any court, and it can do that.
It would be just as productive suing because your laptop runs more cycles when it download Microsoft updates – it does and that means more electrical power being used – and while Microsoft may argue that this is for the benefit of the customer, there is clearly also a cost benefit for Microsoft in reduction of time and energy to fix devices. But such a suit would be pointless.
This concept of a homespot had to reach the highly litigious US before anyone thought to try to make money out of a simple sharing agreement between one home and many others for use of WiFi broadband. FON has been doing this for years across Europe, and by operating both opt in and opt out programs through its terms and conditions, it has avoided anyone being unaware of what was going on. We are pretty certain Comcast used an opt out, but it will be stated in its Ts and Cs so that anyone can opt out if they so wish, and with that, it may be that this case is over before it begins.
The suit was filed in the US District Court in San Francisco claiming that Comcast is “exploiting them for profit” by using their leased gateway to support the MSO’s rollout of its Homespot WiFi network. Comcast is homing in on 8 million installations of the software that make this possible, as we write this.
The suit seems to suggest that electrical power usage rises by 40% which we think is nonsense. The complainants believe that Comcast is pushing “tens of millions of dollars per month,” onto the electric bills of its customers.
We think this case will die in discovery and we may never hear about it again except for the fear factor. Despite the fact that all traffic is encrypted and that the two streams are accounted for separately, the suit raises the idea that there is an increased security risk. That’s a bit like saying that because your phone traffic goes through the same phone exchange, other people may be able to hear your conversations – that’s just not how it works.
But Comcast will not want to simply crush this complaint, it will want to publicize how safe its network is, and how little electrical power is used. If there is publicity which highlights its opt out program and how to go about opting out, millions of its Homespots customers may opt out through fear and hobble its critical and expensive roll-out and it won’t want that.
It emerged last week that Comcast has users opted in as a default setting, so every time it pushes out a software update the device is supposed to be set back to sharing mode, as it reverts to its defaults and doesn’t remember the opt out the user has exerted. That is just dumb design and can be fixed in a heartbeat, if true.
But all of this is really about a long overdue public relations exercise for Comcast. The company is exceptionally unpopular with its customers, despite them acknowledging that they need the broadband and TV service. Customer care polls also make out Comcast as exceptionally unresponsive and this has all fed into the public anger that says that merging with Time Warner Cable should not be allowed and would only lead to a worsening of its service.
In this respect Comcast has only itself to blame, for never addressing these problems, and now might be a time to at least begin, by delaying its Homespot roll-out and making some public promises and make its practices more transparent. But that would be a bit like a Leopard changing its spots.