As far as we can see, there is no conflict between Comcast and Charter agreeing to swap cable homes as part of the a tidying up after the Comcast ‘Time Warner Cable merger, and Charter being fully opposed to that same merger.
Business must go on, and until someone, probably the Justice Department, says no to this deal, Charter must assume that it will go ahead and position itself accordingly. This deal involves far less market distortion than the cable merger in the Netherlands between Liberty Global’s UPC and Ziggo, but we still think it is enough of a problem for someone to step in.
But we do not see the agreement between Comcast and Charter announced this week, as Charter giving up on its ambition to buy Time warner Cable for itself. In fact once Comcast moved to outbid Charter, this course of events was more or less bound to happen.
So while Comcast is now saying that it has 22.6 million TV homes in its numbers out last week, about a million more than it had been previously quoting, and TWC has 11.16 million, that totals some 33.8 million homes, and Comcast reckons that getting rid of 3.9 million of these would allow the Justice Department to let the deal go through, bringing its numbers down to 29.9 million TV homes, although just how many of these will have broadband is hard to work out, probably close to all of them.
There are roughly 80 million fixed broadband lines in the US, so this would represent a broadband concentration of some 37.5% AFTER it has sold off these lines. It’s nearest rival would be AT&T with under 21%. And that is enough to kill the merger right there.
Pay TV penetration of the new merged company with these lines sold off would be around 27% or 28% depending on just how you calculate it ‘ Comcast says under 30% and we agree. Erroneously Comcast said that this brings it to the same number of lines that it had achieved when it acquired AT&T Broadband in 2001, when it grew to 22 million pay TV homes, but then it very few broadband lines, if any. What Comcast might have meant was that it had a similar market share of pay TV in the US at that point, but of course it did not have much in the way of broadband, which is considered the more essential and more profitable of the two services today ‘ and for cable the faster growing.
These lines, all TWC lines at present, will be partly sold off to Charter (1.4 million) bringing Charter up to 5.7 million video customers making Charter the out and out second placed cable company in the US. It had planned to get there through merger with TWC itself, before Comcast outbid it and it was neck and neck with Cox, so this gives it a leg up over the Cox numbers.
Charter and Comcast will also each transfer around 1.6 million customers respectively to make their territories slightly more sensible and to improve the number of homes Charter passes, so that it has geography on its side
But the creation of a new entity, which has 2.5 million homes as pay TV customers, will become a tasty morsel that Charter will almost certainly eventually bid for, which could make the US market a little more competitive.
It has to be asked (by the FCC and the Justice Department) whether or not Charter, Cox and Cablevision remain viable in content provision, if Comcast is almost 30 million TV subscribers, each with broadband , and has the economies of content negotiation on its side. None of the other cable operators have close to the broadband penetration Comcast will have.
Lined up against the two incumbent Telcos AT&T and Verizon, powered by cellular profits, such a deal forces Dish and DirecTV to merge, making not one, but two 30 million home pay TV monsters, plus two incumbent telcos, making the newly created cable operation and the tier 2 cable players in serious trouble in terms of operating economies.
It is far more attractive to block the Comcast deal, let Charter buy TWC, whereupon it will match Comcast in content purchasing power, and also to block the similar sized Dish DirecTV merger that may not emerge anyway if this one is blocked. That would leave the giants in pay TV provision not really any larger, and offering more competition coast to coast.
Charter is supposed to acquire a 33% stake in the new spin off (‘SpinCo’) by issuing new shares and the remaining 67% will be held by existing Comcast and TWC shareholders post spin-off, so this is a way of getting investors onside, since they will be able to sell this stock for cash at a later date and still keep their holdings in Comcast.
SpinCo’s nine-member Board of Directors will include six independent directors and three directors designated by Charter. Comcast will hold no ownership interest in SpinCo (or Charter) and will have no role in managing SpinCo. Well that much is essential to even get close to placating the Justice Department, but we don’t think it is enough.
The transfer of systems, asset purchase and SpinCo acquisition will be valued at a 7.125 times 2014’s EBITDA, and Charter will make additional payments to Comcast over time as tax benefits from the asset sale are realized. Comcast says it expects its merger with Time Warner Cable to generate approximately $1.5 billion in operating efficiencies.
While Charter CEO Tom Rutledge was full of praise for this course of action in a prepared statement, saying it will, ‘provide Charter with greater scale, growth opportunities and improved geographical rationalization,’ it is distinctly second prize compared to owning TWC.
In a way we feel this is a paper exercise unlikely to come to fruition, but one that was necessary to go through.