Your browser is not supported. Please update it.

1 October 2015

comScore buys Rentrak, as disappointment grows in Nielsen

comScore and Rentrak have agreed to merge to create a viable TV audience measurement business rival to Nielsen. Interestingly this happens in a week when Viacom announced the findings of a first-ever Attention Study, aimed at trying to work out what programming US consumers are focused on (see worth noting).

But why do we link the two? Well our industry is midway through a shift from watching video exclusively on a large box in the living room, to watching video at any time, and any place on any device. And it’s tough these days to have any idea of which screen a given individual is actually focused on. This is what creates the potential for a new ownership of the TV audience measurement market.

At home this week we tried an experiment – we told a 19 year old visitor that after this TV program there would be a test on what happened in a complex drama that he was “ostensibly” viewing. Forty minutes later said test was put into action and the program was paused. During that time he had communicated on social media freely and watched a handful of videos on his phone, all the time saying “yes I’m watching it,” but he completely lost track and had no idea who was who in the plot and what had happened. Interestingly the only way he can watch a film and remember it is to go into a cinema were people get upset if you make too much use of your smartphone.

This is only one incident, and you will have your own examples, but the question of which screen millennials are watching (we mean really watching) is fundamental to what will happen to Nielsen. And what happens to Nielsen is fundamental to what will happen to the TV industry.

Today Nielsen upsets everyone by not paying enough attention to what is being watched on a phone and including it in some form of multi-viewing audience platform. Back in April it tried to address this when it changed the name and upgraded its Digital Ad Ratings to provide campaign’s audience details across computers, tablets and smartphones.

Nielsen Digital Ad Ratings has also been merged with demographics from Experian, something its rivals had already done including estimates of household income, race/ethnicity, family size and education level and some data visualization tools.

We can see that Nielsen is part of an industry that can never admit that the marketplace is changing. Nielsen for years has been in denial over OTT video, but now finally admits that many ratings for popular TV channels are falling off.

The reaction has been twofold, for those whose channels are losing customers, they refuse to believe Nielsen and have gone looking for another source of audience data, and for those who have strong online audiences, they argue that they are not being included and again have searched for a better way to bridge the divide between broadcast and broadband viewing.

In a prepared statement comScore and Rentrak said that as consumers’ viewing habits increasingly shift across time and platform, it’s no wonder we see traditional ratings in decline even though people are watching more content than ever. And this is the crux of the point – more people watch more video in less time. How can people do that? By only ever watching something they actually want to see and by watching more than one thing at once. But there needs to be an audience measurement process that does more than prove that a particular screen is on, it has to prove that it is also being watched.

Earlier this year Viacom said it would use Rentrak to merge its audience analytics into Viacom Media Networks, the Viacom unit that controls most of its TV content. Rentrak will be providing its Advanced Demographics measurement system and Nielsen lost out. Viacom creates content shown in more than 165 countries, reaching a cumulative 3.2 billion viewers worldwide with brands like Paramount, Nickelodeon, MTV and Comedy Central and also owns TV channels across Europe.

Rentrak provides a ratings service for 31 million TVs in 210 local US markets, covering cable, satellite and telco packages. Its Advanced Demographics package takes the viewing information and pairs it with third-party consumer behavior data from the likes of Experian and Epsilon – to work out what sort of impact that advertising actually has on viewers. Nielsen is in catch up mode, only deploying this kind of move since that deal was struck.

If it can be proven that some consumers, for instance 18 to 34 year olds, are paying more attention to the smaller screen adverts, then real advertising dollars will shift, and mobile video advertising will grow in value. It is already taking off, but if this type of service creates a change in perception at advertisers, then advertising agency dollars will switch in their billions overnight.

Rentrak said at the time that it can accurately target and analyze the combined viewing and purchasing habits using very specific demographics.

The announcement follows a report which says Time Warner and Viacom were both talking directly to advertisers and bypassing Nielsen. The merger of Rentrak and comScore may even have been triggered by these two heavyweight broadcasters promising more business if the two companies came together.

The boards of the two companies have agreed the terms of the merger and Rentrak will become a wholly-owned subsidiary of comScore, with each share of Rentrak being converted into the right to receive 1.15 shares of comScore with comScore shareholders ending up with about 66.5% of the pie and a new combined management team put in place lead by comScore’s CEO Serge Matta.

The deal will combine comScore’s digital audience and advertising systems with Rentrak’s census-based movie and VoD measurement as well as its TV measurement.

Matta said of the deal, “This merger recognizes the critical importance of combining digital and TV assets for next generation media measurement, which requires a higher degree of precision at both a national and local market level.”

Nielsen is a $6 billion revenue business, and this is because it has a much more global grip on TV audience measurement than its rivals, and had a market capitalization of $16.7 billion prior to this deal (it has slid a bit since). By comparison ComScore’s revenue is just $329 million and Rentrak’s around $103 million, although both are growing rapidly. But deals like the one Rentrak signed with Viacom could rapidly swing revenue in the US, because once one major operator subscribes, all the advertising agencies that do business with it, have to follow suit.

But with Nielsen more than 12 times the size of the combined merged business, it will be a long hard slog to build internationally, and more mergers may well be needed to provide a Nielsen alternative globally.

The deal values Rentrak at $732 million while ComScore had a market capitalization of $1.7 billion prior to the deal. Both have gone up slightly since the deal was announced. Apparently WPP, one of the largest advertising players in the world took an active role in the deal, and bought significant minority stakes in both comScore and Rentrak during the past year and after the deal WPP will have a 16% stake in the combined company, with an option to go up to 20%.