The consolidation of the conditional access business is one of those forecasts that it is easy to be right about, but hard to get the timing on. If someone had asked us this week, which conditional access company will be sold next, sure we would have said Conax. But since we had already said that was obvious, as far back as September 2012, knowing exactly when has proved tougher.
The fact that in October last year Reuters said that financial advisers had been appointed, made it even more likely that a deal would happen about now, but even so, there was definitely a margin for error. The Conax website has been impossible to raise all day, we presume because so many of its customers were surprised, and are searching it, but it is just as likely that the site is being re-directed to the web site of its new CA sister business, Nagra.
Anyway the deal is now done, with Conax being sold by its Telenor Norwegian telco and pay TV operator parent, to Kudelski, the owner of Nagravision, for a little over 2 times its revenues, around $226 million (200 million Swiss Francs), compared with its last reported turnover of $94 million, which amounts to around 6 times EBITDA, a pretty middle of the road price, for a company going nowhere.
But conditional access as a business has transformed, and with the exception of Verimatrix, which seems to have an answer for everything in content security, and a multitude of product options, everyone’s business has become more or less static.
NDS is now part of Cisco and not obliged to break out its figures, but it seems clear that at NDS the addition of another batch of conditional access wins, is counted less important than the Cisco routers that business can drag along with it. NDS itself recognized this a long way ahead of its sale and built a business around middleware, device integration, UI experiences and even systems integration.
Nagra can be seen to have gone down the same route, but it was always favorite to find the cash required to bolster its total number of CA installations with a straight forward acquisition. This should make it the undisputed global number one by homes. Merging the two product sets and customer bases will take time, but the one thing that is always true in conditional access is that staying with your current supplier is cheaper than any other option an operator has. Irdeto too has brought into middleware and billing and associated services and has brought its CEO back from China, where it was trying to steal a march in content protection on smaller devices, to run things at home in the Netherlands where its margins too have grown tight.
So just as Motorola (now owned by Arris) long ago ceased to be a force in conditional access, purely because it had been forced in its homeland cable market to open up the security business to others, so too had Cisco via its Scientific Atlanta acquisition, also let that business slide for much the same reasons ‘ margins on new deals are seen as being too low to run that business separate from set tops and the set top operations in those business had always been paramount.
As Pace and Technicolor carved out great chunks of the set top business, over the years Pace has been attracted to a ‘cheap’ CA option, using a minor Latens purchase to sweeten set top deals and even more move cash out of the CA business.
So with China inventing its own CA and other Asia Pacific markets each having a local incumbent to take some of the local business, despite pay TV growing, most of the CA vendors were stagnant or close to stagnant, as we said with the exception to the rule being Verimatrix.
There have been two clear developments in content revenue protection, as it is euphemistically called, during the past 15 years ‘ taking content to two way IPTV networks, and taking content multiscreen, through general purpose portable devices. And each of these waves has thrown up a new leader. Verimatix and Widevine fought it out with Secure Media for the IPTV crown, and Widevine went to Google, which uses it strategically rather than running it as a profit center, and Motorola bought Secure Media and uses it primarily for its DTCP-IP implementation, to support an IPTV zapper architecture and sell more set tops.
Conditional access and set tops have been inextricably linked ever since General Instrument carved up the US cable market with free CA, on expensive, high margins set tops. This was then acquired by Motorola in 2000.
When we met the new CEO of Conax Morten Sobakken at IBC in 2012, we told him, in front of multiple reporters, that we could not see why Telenor would continue to want ownership of Conax. His company had overseen a partnership with TiVo that could have conquered both its parent Telenor and the rest of Northern Europe, until that relationship fell apart, accompanied by in a slanging match ‘ TiVo told us that it was de-emphasizing its relationship with Conax, while Conax went and delivered a trial at DNA Oy in Finland, the largest cable operator there, without TiVo, and instead with software from little known (at the time) Polish Multiscreen player Cubiware.
Telenor itself turned to NDS, increasingly a rival with TiVo in TV experiences, and especially UIs, and it was a strategic point in conditional access history ‘ for the first time the UI tail was wagging the conditional access dog. Nagra had to put up with a similar situation at Liberty Global, where NDS made tons of money form the Horizon project, while the incumbent conditional access player, Nagra remained in place, but did not share much of a place at the Horizon trough.
Sobakken replied to our comments about his company being sold that we should watch this space. Well we have watched it, and we have been proved right, but not before he put up a spirited defense with wins in the vibrant Indian DTH market and in Latin America, which has no doubt forced up the price, for his shareholders.
Even the DNA Oy deal, launched as a trial back in 2012 is seen on the Cubiware web site, not as a Conax deal, but one carried out directly with Cubiware, perhaps leaving the nascent leap out of conditional access to a multiscreen business, through partnerships, in tatters.
The other deal that turned sour for Conax was at Com Hem in Sweden, where Verimatrix picked up the bulk of the conditional access business, carried over the IP part of the cable architecture as it was, and this too was a tipping point. The legendary sales guy who won that deal was understood to be Geir Bj’rndal, EVP Products & Markets at Conax, who later turned up as a consultant at Verimatrix.
At TV Connect last week Verimatrix launched a dual mode single system that can offer conditional access over both the IP and QAM portions of a cable network, learning for this deal and expecting more of the same.
Had Conax managed to make its partnership deal with TiVo work, we might have seen Conax as the lead consultant in the Com Hem deal, TiVo further ensconced in Northern Europe, with an installation at DNA Oy, and Telenor glad to keep the Conax business, and itself being a happy TiVo customer. Instead Telenor’s head was turned by promises from NDS that, as far as we can see, has led to no revolution at all its UI business as yet, and little change in the fortunes of its Canal Digital pay TV business as a whole ‘ something that is a big contrast with Virgin Media, the first cable company that took TiVo in Europe.
In summary Verimatrix will be rubbing its hands as the prospect of chasing down all those Conax customers with their ex-head of sales in tow, at two critical points if they are cable companies ‘ firstly as they shift to CCAP based fully IP architectures, and secondly as Nagra tries to convert them over to its own CA architecture.
Already DNA Oy in Finland is a customer of US disruptive innovator Casa Systems with its CCAP equivalent, and could be going down the Com Hem path of shifting its conditional access to the two way DOCSIS IP path, rather than use it as a broadcast version over QAM. Verimatrix is head and shoulders ahead in that market.
If you add to the fact that the European Cable industry in going through a series of mergers, which will either mean unification of two competing CA systems, or more likely, richer parents needing to spend capex to bring new acquisitions up to speed, this may well accelerate a move to IP based CA as well, making older systems irrelevant.
This leaves most of the CA vendors out of the race ‘ either supporting the aims of their parents to ship more set tops or more routers, or chasing another game in UI, design, recommendation and middleware, with a handful of exceptions. These include Verimatrix (as David) and Nagravision (as Goliath), which can be seen as the hope for the more traditional CA vendors (although it has its fair share of IP and software only DRM products if customers want them). Technically Irdeto is still a force, as is Viaccess-Orca, but both are owned by pay TV operators in South Africa’s Multichoice, itself part of the Naspers conglomerate empire, and France Telecom. Therefore some would argue they are both subject to the same kind of pressures that Conax was under.
Interestingly both of these have their own versions of the new generation of protection ‘ either software only or flash memory based technologies that keep them in the next race, that of multiscreen, where upstart Inside Secure is making all the running.
New pure App based video services are going lock stock and barrel to Inside secure, underpinning PlayReady from Microsoft, although Inside Secure counts these all as wins for its DRM Fusion product, although confusingly it suggests that this is its own DRM. There are multiple versions of DRM Fusion ‘ a hardened architecture that supports PlayReady, one with its own DRM and even one which relies on a hardware root of trust. We suspect that nearly all of its installations come from PlayReady hardening, but this is unclear.
Viaccess-Orca has just acquired the secure player part of Israeli firm Discretix, to augment its offerings in this area, which supplies players that work from a hardware root of trust inside a phone’s flash memory, while Irdeto has its own Cloakware branded hardening process, which has come distinctly second best to Inside Secure (once part of AuthenTec) in terms of the number of design wins it claims, although where it has wins they tend to be with serious players who already use other Irdeto products.
The market change that threatens all of this is the emergence of Trustonic that will bring a hardware root of trust, in the form of a trusted execution environment to the ARM architecture along with ready-made secure middleware, which will eventually lead to the ability to download a DRM to a portable device inside an App, which is more or less secure enough for premium content (software only protection is understood not to be secure enough).
One other player to mention is Intertrust with its Marlin DRM and its ExpressPlay cloud based Software as a Service version of it. It too has had some significant pure play OTT wins and it is deemed to be the inventor and patent holder of many of the core DRM ideas, many of which are expressed in PlayReady, and it must be remembered that this was at one point a licensing business, which licensed its IPR to Microsoft, Nokia and others. But now it has a few significant wins, none of which are in pay TV, but more often with broadcasters, so at this stage, it is not a conditional access threat ‘ not yet.
But for today we can note the passing of one such name in Conax, as this market both consolidates while at the same times it remains wide open with opportunity for any mid-range company which can afford to focus solely on the slow build of DRM systems, that bring paid video content to the world. This is especially important as the cellular industry finally begins to take seriously the idea that it may want to fight back against OTT video threat, with in-house video services, such as proposed by Verizon and Korea Telecom.