This week IHS Technology put out a report that suggested that conditional access was about to go through a decline, as global pay TV markets begin to saturate.
That conclusion will have surprised a few individuals within companies as different as Cisco, Nagravision, Verimatrix, Irdeto, ViaAccess Orca and parts of Google, partly because their revenue growth, for the most part, don’t yet show any sign of abating, and partly because this is ‘sort of’ obvious.
Right now the problems involved in keeping video content secure are tougher than ever they were before, and revenues from exploiting video delivery, be it through broadcasting, OTT or on mobile services, are going through the roof.
Almost every pay TV operator, mostly through content price hikes, has increased their ARPU in the US and Europe especially, while new OTT entrants are growing like crazy, and every pay TV player is attempting to protect video content delivery to multiple screens, whether that is through a centralized OTT TV Everywhere approach or through adding transcoding processing in-home. There are moves into rights lockers, that need protection and there are continued concerns about 4K and Sports content, and how to keep more of the revenues locked down from piracy, and finally a dramatic technology shift to enable download and store options through the Secure Content Storage Association (SCSA) and rival technologies.
Put simply, people want more video on more things and these revenues opportunities for content suppliers, makes the provision of a comprehensive set of video protections harder to do than ever, and therefore the market is worth far more.
But as a result, since the revenue that needs protecting in all forms of broadcasting, including pay TV broadcasts on satellite and cable, is more or less established, the winners that can sustain new growth are those pushing technologies that allow content providers to do new things ‘ like Multiscreen.
And this is not a surprise. The first PC version of conditional access we saw was in about 2005 and visionary companies have been going after these new markets ever since.
So to say that the conventional conditional access market will decline is a bit of a no-brainer. IHS forecasts that the worldwide revenue for conventional pay TV set top conditional access technology will decline to $1.9 billion in 2018, down from a peak of $2.2 billion in 2015 and we cannot disagree with a conclusion put that precisely. What might be more interesting is a report that discussed the likely profitable transitions that many of these companies might attempt, to replace revenue from that technology.
Wajahat Abbassi, senior analyst for Connected Home at HIS said, ‘Shipments of set top CA clients have grown strongly during the past 10 years, from 44 million units in 2003 to 246 million in 2013, driven by a decade of rampant pay TV growth. However, this dependence will make further growth for CA challenging as the pay TV market begins to slow.’
But what the report does NOT say is what will happen to revenues used to protect content delivered via LTE broadcast, or to portable devices via WiFi or other internet connections (but mostly WiFi), and on revenues for flash stored and cloud stored content protection.
Also the fact that most operators are in an early stage of replacing HD DVRs with HD to UHD multi-room DVRs, means that many more devices will have to carry components offered by the conditional access suppliers. Take a multi-room DVR that distributes to 3 or 4 other zapper boxes around the home attached to other TVs. The CA only lives on the first box, but some form of DTCP-IP connection, with hardware implemented key security on the cheaper device, is required, for each TV. Now this revenue is collected by the set top designer for the most part, and it is far less per box than the CA protection, but that means the revenue is shifting from one supplier to another, rather than evaporating.
IHS says the that content-protection contracted to $2.1 billion in 2013, down 4.5% from $2.2 billion in 2012. The decline came despite a rise in shipments of set top CA clients, to 246 million units. We know how much price pressure older established technologies are under, in each successive generation, but it’s almost impossible, in an age where companies are charging for an ‘overall end to end protection’ including monitoring and revoking unauthorized clients etc’ as well as enabling multi-screen content, to break out which part of which revenue belongs to pure CA. So we are inclined to think this is more about a mild market perception than a set of accurate figures.
The report points out that India and China still has lots of growing to do, and so the CA market will expand in 2014 and 2015 in units terms, especially given that India is going through cable digitization. IHS puts CA client shipments at 279 million units in 2015, but says price competition and a shift toward software-based solutions will limit revenue expansion with the industry growing to just $2.2 billion by 2015.
Software only solutions are a real problem, and this includes where a core processing chip has a crypto-firewall and executes all decryption processes behind a silicon shield. These are all seen as having less costs by operators, and so they are prepared to pay less for these services. There are versions of this in set tops, on handsets and on smart TVs. We estimate that each software only solution takes just 25% to 35% of previous hardware based systems
The report also says that globally 53% of households subscribe to pay TV and this is close to saturation. That may be true, but a new generation of OTT video services will be targeted at those homes without pay TV, and that will drive up the number of homes using protection.
The report shows has Cisco as the market leader with a 32% share of revenue after buying NDS, and Nagravision in second place at 27% including revenues from Conax.