Your browser is not supported. Please update it.

18 October 2006

Convergence, not conflict, with LTE heads WiMAX agenda

As the WiMAX standard’s remit became increasingly mobile and large carrier-oriented, the technology inevitably expanded outside its laptop-based and WISP roots to nip at the heels of the next generation cellular platforms, HSxPA and its successor LTE, and CDMA EV-DO Revs A and beyond.

But while this has often been presented as a titanic battle of conflicting interests to control ‘4G’ when it emerges around 2010 – with the major 3G vendors and operators pitched against those, such as Motorola and the wireline carriers, that did not gain from 3G – in fact last week’s WiMAX World event in Boston highlighted the major drive towards a convergence of the wireless standards in future.

Increasingly pressurized in the wireless market, operators and vendors are desperate to upgrade rapidly the capabilities they can offer a market hungry for broadband and multimedia services, while keeping their development costs low.

What could be more attractive, then, than the prospect of a 4G platform to which any current technology roadmap could migrate, reducing risk and accelerating R&D?

Certainly many of the key players represented at WiMAX World were talking in these terms – keeping their options open, reusing their R&D investments and simplifying future migrations and opex, by converging towards one umbrella set of technologies.

In this situation, differentiation would come from services, extra-standard enhancements and software rather than core technology. All this revived speculation that the WiMAX Forum would manage to come to terms with the 3GPP to have 802.16e accepted under that organization’s auspices as a component of LTE, the next generation of the UMTS standard, also known as 3.9G, which should start to be commercially available in 2008.

Motorola and Nortel are two of the vendors that believe 802.16e and LTE will be very similar – based as both are on the same fundamentals such as OFDMA, smart beamforming and MIMO smart antennas, plus mobile IP. Therefore, while both have stepped back from UMTS – Nortel by selling these activities to Alcatel, Motorola in a joint venture with Huawei – both also plan to re-enter the race at the LTE stage in readiness for 4G, claiming they will have a headstart gained from their current experience in developing 802.16e.

Motorola Networks’ big guns – general manager Fred Wright and CTO Dan Coombes – were emphasizing this message at WiMAX World, pointing out that the investment they commit to developing 802.16e now will stand them in good stead for LTE, and it will be a far simpler step to create a robust LTE platform with the experiences gained in WiMAX and with reuse of some of the technologies and R&D.

Nortel claimed, at WiMAX World, to have one of the first Wi- MAX products implementing the smart antenna technology MIMO, which will be an essential element of 802.16e when it enters its second wave of certification (probably not until mid- 2007 or later. In the first wave, which should start at the turn of the year, MIMO is optional, and it has not yet been implemented by the vendors. Motorola, for instance, is promising it in its next generation of Wi4 base stations.)

Nortel said its MIMO-powered product can deliver broadband content for 10% of the cost per bit of 3G networks. It also announced a field trial with Golden Telecom in Moscow, though actual commercial shipment dates are vague beyond mid-2007 – the target date for most of the tier one vendors in this field. Much of Nortel’s WiMAX work is being done as part of its joint venture with LG of Korea and the company is sourcing its MIMO-enabled chips from Runcom of Israel. During 2006, the company has more than doubled its investment in WiMAX, said Peter MacKinnon, Nortel’s general manager of WiMAX and chairman of LG-Nortel.

“Earlier this year, we started looking at the wireless roadmap and it became clear that we needed to start investing heavily. We’ve redirected resources from across the company.”

Like other vendors – and Sprint – Nortel insists, misleadingly, on equating current 802.16e with 4G. ‘WiMAX is a profoundly disruptive technology,’ said MacKinnon. ‘It will change the way content is delivered, the way users access information and entertainment as well as the economics of wireless operators. As the first 4G technology available, WiMAX will transition the consumer experience from today’s wireless connectivity to tomorrow’s true mobility’users will be able to replicate their PC capabilities, such as blogging, video and VoIP, anywhere.’

The company’s new portfolio includes MIMO base station transceivers, access service network gateways, mobile subscriber stations and network management systems.

Such examples of the WiMAX community looking to come closer to the LTE roadmap could be taken as the defensiveness of the newcomer technology, but this time WiMAX is not making all the running. The companies that had clearly hoped 802.16e would fail to get off the starting blocks, leaving the 4G market open for the established wireless technologies, are now realizing that the new platform is likely to have a significant impact, and are adjusting their thinking accordingly.

Qualcomm CEO Paul Jacobs recently said the company was likely to make WiMAX chips – no doubt with an eye on Sprint’s need for a dual-mode WiMAX/CDMA handset, which could only realistically be created in a single-chip format by Qualcomm – and in Boston Nokia made its most definitive statements to date on WiMAX, and even the usually hostile Ericsson mellowed.

Nokia has been hesitant about WiMAX, from being a founder member of the Forum when it was more focused on backhaul, to distancing itself from 802.16 as the standard took a more mobile turn, to announcing a breakthrough joint development with Intel last year, concentrated on a handset.

Since then, however, the giant has remained ambivalent about WiMAX’ commercial prospects, but last week said definitively that it would be selling WiMAX phones in 2008, even as it also unveiled base stations. The Finnish giant is also likely to be a frontrunner in incorporating WiMAX into multimedia and enterprise devices that will help with its objectives of spreading its wings beyond the cellco market, using IP systems to win new customers.

In view of its recent announcement that it would co-develop, with Intel, an embedded HSDPA device for laptops, it is highly likely that a similar deal for a WiMAX/cellular laptop system will ensue. Though the HSDPA agreement seemed to fly in the face of Intel’s huge commitment to WiMAX as the key laptop technology of the future – especially since it quit the cellphone processor sector itself earlier this year – it probably reflects an increasing closeness between the two companies, with Nokia insisting on HSDPA support from the chip giant in return for a stronger commitment to WiMAX.

Both companies are clearly recognizing that the next generation of enterprise users will be all about multimode cellphones and PCs, not technological religion. Nokia said its WiMAX base stations will be commercially available for broadband operators in the 2.5GHz band at the end of 2007 and for 3.5GHz in the first quarter of 2008.

Meanwhile, Ericsson remains more hesitant about potentially cannibalizing its dominant presence in UMTS, but it is showing more public interest in certain aspects of WiMAX – notably, providing broadband operators with a fill-in technology where there is no DSL or cable, especially as it shifts towards fixed/mobile convergence; offering a route to broadband data services for GSM operators; and offering services.

The last two are particularly interesting. Ericsson and Nokia, in particular, continue to snap up huge GSM expansion deals, especially in countries where 3G rules have not yet been decided – they are likely, for instance, to win a massive contract with BSNL in India worth $6bn. In many countries, GSM operators are looking for a way to anticipate or circumvent 3G and move quickly to multimedia and data services, and WiMAX vendors like Motorola believe this is one of the largest opportunities for 802.16. And Ericsson is looking to offset falling prices of cellular gear by increasing its revenues from services such as managed networks.

In that spirit, it plans to offer testing and integration services for WiMAX, a move that could be seen as an attempt to take control of processes currently run by the WiMAX Forum, but also a welcome move, since it will bring the vendor’s vast experience of large carrier-class system to this fledgling sector.

For smaller vendors, the prospect of being cast into the broad cellular market at an early stage could be too daunting, requiring R&D and political clout beyond their means, but for some of the WiMAX chipmakers, the attraction of using their 802.16 knowledge to take a short cut into a wider sector is clear.

Companies such as PicoChip – which spans WiMAX and HSxPA with its designs, focusing on emerging trends such as miniature femtocells and software defined radio – would benefit heavily from any coming together of two wireless roadmaps.

And on the operator side, UMTS backers such as T-Mobile and even the mighty Vodafone are considering other alternatives for certain markets and services, and many of the leading lights of the CDMA community are looking to a roadmap that keeps all their options open in future. Sprint Nextel is the poster child, but its strategy echoes that of fellow CDMA giants such as KDDI. It will roll out its parallel networks – EV-DO Rev A and WiMAX – to offer a wider range of services in the short term and boost its total bandwidth, but is clearly looking, eventually, to converge these systems in a single 4G platform.

As Sprint’s CTO, Barry West, explained in an address at WiMAX World, it is vital to keep choices wide open when standards are so unproven – one reason why the operator is such an enthusiastic member of the recently formed Next Generation Mobile Networks (MGMN) service provider forum. This was set up to ensure that carriers took the driving seat for the 4G agenda, in terms of technology, services, timescales and intellectual property.

“Nothing magic is coming from the 3GPP – in fact the reverse,” he said. “The NGMN was formed to think from an operator and customer viewpoint not a manufacturer’s.” An advantage of this, he claims, is that most technologies are considered, and this will almost certainly mean Sprint looks at LTE seriously as it emerges, perhaps as a successor in the EV-DO spectrum, or if WiMAX does not work out in 2.5GHz. However, Sprint’s presence in the NGMN also ensures 802.16e will get a fair hearing there.

“I would love to see colleagues in Europe adopt mobile WiMAX,” West said, pointing out that TDD WiMAX has a two-year headstart on LTE or even the FDD version of 802.16, neither of which he expects to have full commercial systems until 2010. But he cannot afford to be religious.

“There are three possibilities,” he said. “WiMAX bums and LTE is successful; LTE bums and WiMAX is successful; or both work and interoperability will be important.”

The increasingly strongly held view of many majors, including, one suspects, Sprint itself, is that the third option is most likely, and platform convergence – though not necessarily full unification – will be the order of the day by 2010.

The final word rests with Siemens, whose senior vice president for government and industry relations, Klaus-D Kohrt – who is vice chairman of the UMTS Forum and Siemens’ key representative on the WiMAX Forum – said in his keynote speech that the idea of direct 3G-WiMAX conflict “grossly oversimplifies the situation and largely ignores technical realities and even sometimes the laws of physics.”

Keeping the two roadmaps apart would only lead to fragmentation in precious spectrum resources in regions like Europe, he argued, and called for harmonized spectrum conditions for both UMTS and WiMAX round the world. His aim is that the activities of both camps should be aligned to make best use of available bandwidth and encourage interoperability and roaming, thereby accelerating services roll-out and reducing vendor and operator costs. “I hope to convince the audience that there is value in aligning the activities of both sides on a common, interoperable approach to next generation mobile networks,” he concluded.