Your browser is not supported. Please update it.

1 March 2006

Coral adds Cisco, Motorola, MPAA to DRM unity effort

The Coral Consortium has picked up more weight behind its efforts to introduce interoperable DRM, with the addition this week of new members including Cisco, Motorola and LG Electronics, along with the Motion Picture Association of America, whose membership will be seen by many as a major endorsement.

Other new members include conditional access firms Irdeto, Secure Media and Verimatrix. Widevine and NDS are already members, and if we include Scientific Atlanta under the Cisco membership and Motorola’s conditional access business under Motorola’s membership, this represents a clean sweep of all the significant global TV DRMs except Nagravision.

The other new members are AOL, Enikos Pty and Gibson Guitar, and Comcast, which we have already announced as a member in an earlier issue.

Coral gets much of its technology from Intertrust, now a jointly owned company by Philips and Sony, and earlier members include Sony, Philips, Hewlett-Packard, Panasonic, Samsung, Twentieth Century Fox, NBC Universal, the Universal Music Group, IFPI and Sun Microsystems.

Its approach is built around the Intertrust designed NEMO architecture which stands for Networked Environment for Media Orchestration, which is a way of using software agents and online connections to verify content transactions, as a basis for interoperable DRM.

In Nemo there are defined a set of roles such as client, authorizer, gateway and orchestrator, and the approach assumes that they talk to each other over an IP network. Work is allocated to each of them such as authorization, peer discovery, notification, services discovery, provisioning, licensing and membership creation.

The client simply uses the services of the other three peers, the authorizer decides if the requesting client should have access to a particular piece of content; the gateway takes on the role of a helper that will provide more processing power to negotiate a bridge to another architecture and the orchestrator is a special form of gateway that handles non-trivial co-ordination such as committing a transaction.

Intertrust has always said that it will take about 18 months until its members begin to offer systems that are Nemo compliant. That period will come to an end this Summer, when the first Nemo systems should begin to hit the market.

Coral has also introduced a new round of specifications, which are available under an evaluation agreement from www.coral-interop.org. The new spec includes an updated version of Coral’s core interoperability framework expanded to support a model for interoperable content usage across a domain of consumers’ devices.

Coral says this release will allow device makers and service providers to give consumers the power to locate and play content on all their devices. Coral expects to deliver a public release of a complete interoperability framework later this year.

The only other DRM interoperability standards effort that has any legs is that being pushed by MPEG pioneer Leonardo Chiariglione called Digital Media Project. This is run along the lines of a free floating standards body, aligned with the semi-defunct MPEG 21 DRM effort and supported by British Telecom, Telecom Italia, the BBC, and a few Universities. However both DivX and Panasonic are in this group and it really just fragments the effort towards DRM interoperability.

Regardless of the technical issues of which is the better approach, these two efforts really need to merge, which would leave only Intel and Microsoft and the Open Mobile Alliance, which has the de facto DRM standard for mobile phones, outside of Coral. A merger of the two interoperability efforts would create pressure for Microsoft to join. It would be a relatively trivial task for Microsoft to built a Nemo extension on its Windows Media DRM, and since OMA DRM is a standard, a version using Nemo can easily be produced by one or more of the OMA compliant DRMs. In other words the OMA doesn’t have to join, as long as one of the companies supplying OMA DRM joins (NDS is one such company).