Your browser is not supported. Please update it.

21 August 2014

Cord cutting in Europe? Really? ‘ Not just local growing pains?

A new report out from IHS this week says that 12 European countries experienced a decline in pay TV uptake, and it goes on to put this down to cord cutting. It says that 6 of these markets are seeing their second quarter in a row of decline including Benelux and Scandinavia along with some of the smaller Central and Eastern European markets.

The 12 markets showing a decline in Q1 2014 are Belgium, Denmark, Italy, Malta, Netherlands, Norway, Sweden, Czech Republic, Latvia, Lithuania, Moldova, and Poland.

Now we’re not going to check every one of those markets, but Belgium has 75% of its pay TV market supplied by Belgacom and UPC Telenet, and collectively those are up about 24,000 homes this quarter (Belgacom up 30,000 and UPC down 5,800). So we’re having trouble believing that TV Vlanderen and Voo lost more than that, as this would have to be about a 2% fall of total subs in one quarter. So we think that at least some doubt has to be placed on the IHS figures.

Italy certainly has suffered in pay TV during the Eurozone crisis and IHS conveniently forgets that both Spain and Greece had, at some point, lost pay TV numbers. But Italy is the only really large economy where pay TV has been off, with France, Germany, Spain and the UK now continuing to grow, even though Spain did have rough times.

Now IHS claims that these economies too may soon be shrinking and are willing to put it down to OTT services.

Until now cord-cutting could only really be measured in the US because it has such a high pay TV penetration, and has had ten years or more of ARPU rises, so it happens more. And while we wouldn’t disagree entirely that some cord cutting is going on in Europe, we can confirm that it has not reached and will not reach US levels for some time. The other thing to note is that the same companies, the pay TV providers, are the very same companies in Europe doing most OTT delivery. Everyone has a multiscreen, TV Everywhere strategy and they have begun, as in Sky’s case, to offer that to non-customers as a method of acquiring subscribers, something that is not really happening yet in the US.

So if someone downgrades from Sky to Sky Now in the UK, it is not a subscriber loss, although the revenue will definitely be lower per household. But the real function of this, just as Snap TV in Germany, which has just dropped its price to €3.99 a month, is to attract new customers to the core platform. What will be reported, for some time yet, are a new raft of pay TV subscribers, paying a far smaller ARPU, but additive to revenues for the most part.

Other localized disruptions may be responsible for what IHS is witnessing, such as the Czech subsidiary of Telefonica changing hands and changing its middleware in a single year. IHS says that the Czech Republic has lost subscribers, but the combination of a new incumbent offering and the merging of the M7 satellite owned offerings, into a single system, and dropping the idea that the smart cards are free, using a pay as you go model, is really likely to be behind the changes affecting that market. There are similar changes happening in a number of markets IHS says have experienced shrinkage.

But it is right that growth has softened on a pan-regional basis, and IHS reports this as down 30% on the same quarter a year earlier at just 0.66% in the quarter. We do believe that. But this figure is not a fall in revenue growth, it is purely in unit subscribers. Also the previous fantastic growth of IPTV is finally slowing down, which was holding up subscriber growth before.

Netflix continues to remain additive to pay TV in Europe, as well as in the US, as far as we can see.

Sky Deutschland is one approach where it has reduced the monthly subscription price of its video-on-demand (VOD) service Snap from €9.90 to just €3.99 just to fight Netflix. While in the UK Virgin is being positive in bringing Netflix to its customers via its set top.