Your browser is not supported. Please update it.

1 December 2011

Cord erosion identified in latest round of pay TV surveys

Globally pay TV subscriptions are still rising, with a small US decline countered by a 5% increase in Europe and 15% in the Far East. At the same time while the threat of cord cutting has been greatly exaggerated, there is growing if patchy evidence of cord erosion as younger viewers persist with OTT when they start having families rather than forking out for pay TV. If the latter trend continues then over time, pay TV subs will decline through natural wastage as existing customers age.

These are the inevitable conclusions from various surveys, starting with one by Credit Suisse reporting that out of 250 US Netflix subscribers, 37% of those aged 25 to 34 use the service instead of pay TV. Given the small size of the sample and the recent dramatic decline in Netflix subs themselves, this is not a significant figure and perhaps should be treated just as a mild warning by pay TV operators.

The US market is the most interesting in the sense that being closest to saturation it is where the operators have been watching the data most closely and with greatest anxiety. Credit Suisse itself reports total US subs almost totally unchanged at 100.8 million for the year ending September 2011 compared with 2010, but representing a slight decline in penetration from 84.1% in the third quarter of 2010 to 83.2% in Q4 2011, on account of the number of households increasing by just over 1 million. The authors attribute this slight fall in penetration to the aforementioned cord erosion, and another survey, from SNL Kagan, reports a 32,000 drop in US subs for Q4 2011.

In this case the pips are more revealing, for while SNL Kagan attributed the fall chiefly to loss of subs by smaller local operators, mostly cable, a closer look at the figures indicates that they were highly skewed by DirecTV, which was in fact the only major cable or satellite operator to gain subs. This appears to have been almost entirely on account of DirecTV’s promotion of free NFL (National Football League) Sunday Ticket, which helped achieve a record breaking gain of 327,000 subs in the quarter. By contrast rival satellite operator Dish Network lost 111,000 subs, while cable operators Time Warner and Comcast shed 126,000 and 275,000 net respectively.

Taking the sectors as a whole, satellite was up by 216,000 in the quarter (entirely because of DirecTV), while cable was down 584,000, but IPTV was perhaps the only real gainer with subs up 337,000. By contrast satellite subs were down 109,000 in Q2, cable subs down 771,000, and IPTV up 416,000. The respective figures a year ago for Q3 2010 were +145,000 for satellite, -741,000 for cable, and +477,000 for IPTV. Those came just one quarter after overall US pay TV subs had declined for the first time in their history, triggering the first serious bout of cord cutting paranoia. Against that background subsequent data from all sources has served to calm nerves, with the decline flattening, culminating in the Netflix debacle this autumn. If not in rude health the US pay TV industry is at least stable and for now resisting the OTT invasion into its territory.