It was only a matter of time before Singapore based Creative Technology began to look for legal remedies to its sorry MP3 situation, and once it received a US patent on its MP3 player interface in September, a very similar patent to one Apple was refused, it was bound to end in the courtroom at some stage.
But Creative’s request for an injunction is unlikely to stand up, because it wants iPods to be dragged from the shelves straight away.
For the past year Creative has suffered, selling less and less of its MP3 players as iPods take a greater and greater market control and banning them from sale is about the only way that it was every going to get back market share.
One thing against Creative now is that Apple has tied up its Flash memory supply going forwards, creating an artificial dearth in the market, and making it more expensive for companies like Creative to source materials.
Creative filed a separate complaint with the US International Trade Commission seeking an exclusion order and cease and desist order against Apple.
Creative filed its actual lawsuit against Apple in the United States District Court for the Northern District of California that seeks an injunction and increased damages for Apple’s ‘willful infringement’ of what it calls its ‘Zen’ Patent.
Creative first introduced the patent on its Nomad Jukebox player, which was announced and presented as a functioning prototype at the Consumer Electronics Show (CES) in January 2000. There’s no response from Apple yet, and presumably the delay since the patent was awarded until this legal action was while they negotiated over royalties, and could not agree.
Any judge or jury looking at this case is going to have to decide to what extent the concept of the interface is the same as Creative’s, but also decide to what extent the iPod interface is responsible for its sales, rather than the existence of iTunes.