Your browser is not supported. Please update it.

12 July 2018

Deutsche Bank sees continuing broadcaster malaise – advises sell off

At a recent conference we were asked to lay out the future landscape for TV in about 15 minutes, so naturally we began with a question for the audience – what the effect on advertising revenues is, of Netflix having 1 billion hours a week of viewing which have no adverts in? Is this good for the industry or bad?

As there seemed to be mass confusion in the ranks – we explained the question more clearly. “Will advertising get more revenue – because of the scarcity of ad spaces, or would it get less?” A show of hands, roughly 95% agreed that TV advertising was going to struggle.

And until now we have heard few voices raised in agreement until a piece of Deutsche Bank research was highlighted to us by Advanced Television this week which suggests that it is recommending sales of stocks such as French broadcaster TF1, Spain’s Mediaset and Atres Media, and Germany’s RTL. RTL is majority controlled by Bertelsmann but did an IPO in 2013.

At advertising events we have attended the talk seems to be of both online programmatic advertising and TV adopting addressable advertising, to defend against this.

Deutsche conducts quarterly discussions with advertising agencies who buy TV advertising, and it says that with the exception of the UK, which had a late surge, across Europe spend is down on the guidance given by broadcasters for the last quarter. As a result it has knocked off around 10% from anticipated valuations, although less from German stocks.

Most broadcasting stocks, with the exception of market leaders and companies in merger discussions, already exhibit relatively low a PE ratios, and if they begin a slide in Europe, these companies will be immediately prone to acquisition and consolidation. So expect that to start.

Right now there is whispered talk of the Google Facebook duopoly in advertising, which is increasingly video based, and most broadcasters feel powerless to respond.

The obvious answer is to change their businesses. Right now online channels tend to have their advertising “thrown in” with the broadcast, and fail to develop higher values, simply because there is not enough data collected on their audiences. Broadcasters are reluctant to invest in data mechanisms like analytics on the app on the consuming device and linking to APIs of programmatic services and are slow to adopt modern online UIs.

The bank said it was watching the shift to on-demand viewing but was basing its calls on 2017 data just complete, with more recent data harder to find except this handful of interviews. In a nutshell linear viewing decline accelerated throughout 2017. It makes a case that Germany is behind in adoption of on-demand, so not in as much trouble quite yet – although that’s not a sentiment we share – our streaming report shows Germany to be a competitive streaming marketplace growing rapidly.

Another surprising conclusion, which takes us back to the Netflix comment, is that online video advertising plus broadcast, no longer add up to the previous figures – this is likely to be because some online inventory is still given away or at least undervalued, or simply because more people watch Netflix and there is no advertising in some viewing hours. While Netflix sets the non-AVoD business model for Europe, this is always going to remain a trend and it cites YouTube, Amazon Video, Google Play, Vice News, Eurosport Player and national platforms like Daily Motion, Magine and Cofunk – few of which carry advertising, and this is not because they don’t want to, but because to compete with Netflix they cannot afford to.

The inevitable conclusion is that traditional broadcasters are failing to replicate their market share online in advertising spend and it gets irritated, as we have, with the constant whining about “TV being in rude health” which apologists trot out at every conference. There is a big difference with the large home screen still being of value and broadcasting itself being of value.

We know some technology suppliers who take the view “What’s the point in going after traditional video sources, when brand new sources such as DAZN and MLBAM and eSports channels are the future,” and these are essentially recently introduced services.

Be ready to see share prices, not only in Europe, begin a long slow slide similar to the one we are seeing in the US and for this to infect the global broadcasting players.