As Amazon and Microsoft reported their third quarter results, they must have wondered whether either of them ever should have got into devices. Microsoft was pulled down by its Nokia acquisition, even though Surface was showing better performance, while Amazon posted its biggest quarterly net loss for at least 11 years, with huge inventory adjustments on its Fire Phone, reminiscent of Microsoft’s on the original Surface RT.
Amazon could lose $40.5m for the full year, which would be its largest annual loss for 12 years, according to analysts, and only its second in that period (it also made a full-year loss in 2012).
For the third quarter, Amazon posted a net loss of $437m, more than 10 times bigger than a $41m loss a year earlier. Sales were up 20% to $20.6bn. Analysts had projected a loss of $331.4m on sales of $20.9bn. The results included a $170m inventory charge, largely attributable to the Fire smartphone, which has seen disappointing sales since it shipped in July in the US. At the end of the third quarter, Amazon had $83m worth of unsold Fire phones in its inventory.
Amid such figures, investors are questioning Bezos’s strategy of investing heavily in devices and infrastructure which should drive sales growth, but accepting minimal profits in return for that expansion. Among the CEO’s big spending items have been the Fire range of tablets and handsets, original TV programming, cloud platforms and even drones.
Amazon spent $21.1bn on operations in the quarter, up 23% year-on-year, a rate which was higher than its revenue growth (although some costs are to prepare the delivery network for the holiday quarter, so the balance should shift in Q4).
“The biggest component is the expense side of the equation,” Scott Tilghman, an analyst at B. Riley told Bloomberg. “They’ve got a big checkbook they keep writing upon, which all results in a top line that is less robust than we thought.”
CFO Thomas Szkutak gave signs of listening to such comments. “We have been in investment mode because of the opportunities we have in front of us,” he said. “There are still lots of opportunities in front of us, but we know we have to be cautious about which opportunities we pursue.” He added: “With anything we do there’s certainly a wide range of outcome,” said Szkutak.
He did give justifications for the expenditure in areas such as TV programming, which has created better uptick and retention for the Amazon Prime service. Prime is key to the Amazon model – for $99 a year, customers are lured by video-on-demand programming or next-day free delivery, and then generally end up shopping more with Amazon as well as consuming more content. The Kindle family of devices – ereaders, tablets and the Fire Phone – follow the same principles, making little margin in their own right, but creating an optimized experience which encourages more content usage, and Prime is often bundled with the products to add to the snowball effect.
Amazon projected fourth quarter sales of between $27.3bn and $30.3bn, and income excluding some items ranging from a loss of $570m to a gain of $430m. That fell short of analysts’ estimates of sales of $30.9bn and profit of $460.5m. It said it had reduced its forecasts because of the strong US dollar and some stock-based compensation costs.
Meanwhile, Microsoft is no longer taking huge inventory-related charges on its Surface tablets, but new CEO Satya Nadella has far less enthusiasm for hardware than his predecessor Steve Ballmer, and has dropped heavy hints that he regards the Nokia devices business, acquired just before he took the reins, as a white elephant. In fact, the former Finnish business did better than analysts had expected, but integration costs dragged down its new parent’s profits.
Microsoft’s revenue leaped 25% in the first quarter of its fiscal year, to reach $23.2bn, but its program of layoffs, and the Nokia costs, pulled net income down by 13% year-on-year, to $4.54bn or $0.54 per share. Profits were hit by $1.14bn of integration and restructuring expenses, which took 11 cents off earnings per share.
The cloud business, which Nadella has placed at the heart of the growth strategy, is delivering strong results, but there was also “meaningful progress” in the more controversial devices business, according to CFO Amy Hood.
Of the two main business segments, Microsoft’s Devices and Consumer division grew its revenue by 47% year-on-year to almost $11bn, while the Commercial unit rose by 10% to $12.3bn. In the former, Office 365 growth of 25% in the past three months was a highlight, and Xbox sales doubled, but there was also more surprising progress by the Surface Pro 3, which made sales of $900m, and the Nokia business, which generated over $2.6bn, above Wall Street expectations.
Microsoft sold 9.3m Lumia smartphones in the quarter and almost 43m featurephones. However, in the licensing business, there was a 9% drop in revenue, with Windows Phone falling by 46% because Microsoft has axed fees for many models.
In Commercial, the star performers were cloud computing and services, such as Office 365, Azure and Dynamics CRM Online, which collectively increased their revenues by 128% year-on-year.
Surface and Lumia may be pulling their weight better than they did in the past, but they are still a distraction for Microsoft, from its core successful businesses such as Azure and Office. The huge costs of buying and integrating Nokia, and of the huge round of layoffs – many at the former Nokia unit – are scarcely justified by around $2bn per quarter in phone revenues.
“We have work to do on phones but we are seeing Lumia share growth in key markets,” Hood said. “That being said, we know this is a long road.” It is a road we suspect Nadella will cut very short, just hanging on to the former Nokia ranges while there is still some revenue to be had for limited extra investment, and then concentrating entirely on his mantra of ‘cloud first, mobility first’.