When we first spoke to DigitalSmiths CEO Ben Weinberger back in 2012, we discussed what TiVo offered and whether this really counted as a recommendation system and decided that it was distinctly ‘last generation’ and needed upgrading.
We noted that in May last year TiVo did an upgrade to its recommendation system which we had assumed was home grown and which we said should have used someone like DigitalSmiths. Perhaps it did after all.
When Faultline talked with TiVo at IBC last year we were not shy in mentioning the 4 or 5 viable technology players that might help TiVo upgrade its recommendation system ‘ discussing DigitalSmiths, ThinkAnalytics and Jinni.
Now we think about it neither party looked like they were hiding a dirty secret, so perhaps it was Faultline that pointed the two sides at one another, either way, TiVo has now acquired DigitalSmiths in a $135 million transaction ‘ not bad for a company that raised little more than $30 million in its three rounds of funding.
The question will immediately be asked about whether or not it makes sense for one of other of the TV infrastructure and innovation groups (NDS-CISCO for instance or Ericsson) to acquire their own in-house recommendation company, and ThinkAnalytics is bound to be the next name on the list, claiming as its does the lion’s share of the global recommendation market.
But numbers are not everything in this game and while ThinkAnalytics claims to have over 130 million TV homes, having screens driven by its recommendations, it was only perhaps at Liberty Global on its NDS designed Horizon box, that ThinkAnalytics recommendations come to life and drive the entire UI. And it is because of this that the more imaginative customers of DigitalSmiths, who mostly so far use the system for TV Everywhere systems, running on laptops and tablets, have shown just how essential such a system is.
There are other players in this market, Viaccess Orca, definitely not for sale, which has just about unbundled its DEEP discovery engine from the UI of its parent company France Telecom, and players like Veveo with a distinctly different approach relating to semantic knowledge graphs. There are also a handful of web-only players that have never been adapted to the TV and another we came across at IBC called Spideo, the power behind Canal+ recommendations. And after this move by TiVo everyone one in the business will ask ‘ should we buy one?.
That’s because we think this is a real win-win kind of acquisition. It points to a more dynamic UI for TiVo, with some innovation on the Horizon and the potential to create a My TV Screen which is entirely trustworthy, and doesn’t only feature recommendations on the periphery of the function or one or two clicks further down.
One of the key things about modern recommendations is that increasingly they either create a viewing or an exploration of the content, almost every time a suggestion is loaded. This is because they come to be trusted by the viewer, far more than the early collaborative filtering systems of the mid 2000s, which kicked off this whole recommendation direction.
If you embed that into the existing TiVo UI and bring it slightly to the fore, it creates an even better rapid selection environment than the TiVo interface today. And because recommendation is always in the cloud and many of the TiVo features such as search are also fed from there, this makes integration easy to do. If you add to that the idea that TiVo is looking at a cloud DVR, independent of the UI, then it makes for a great operator offering.
TiVo has said that more and more US cable operators are showing interest in using TiVo, especially in the cloud and this can only bring in more of them, more quickly.
Digitalsmiths’ software has already been used with iOS, Android, Roku, Xbox, PlayStation, Kindle and multiple set-top boxes and it say it is experiencing rapid growth in transaction volumes coming from 90 million transactions in July 2013, to almost 150 million in December 2013. Cross fertilization from TiVo to DigitalSmiths and vice versa is likely to drive sales for both of them.
TiVo says that it anticipates a positive EBITDA contribution in the year starting February 2014) and a material contribution to TiVo’s financials from DigitalSmiths from 2016.
DigitalSmiths is now claiming that it is being used by 7 out of the top 10 pay TV providers ‘ we know that Comcast built its own, that Cox uses ThinkAnalytics and we think that AT&T has not yet chosen a recommendation partner, while DigitalSmiths has had announcements at Time Warner Cable and Bright House networks, and so we have to assume it also has Verizon, Charter and Cablevision, as well as DirecTV and Dish. None of those last 5 has ever publicly announced a recommendation partner either. DigitalSmiths also partners Foxtel, Sharp, Univision, zeebox and i.TV.
This is the second time that these assertions have been made, so this represents a real disappointment for all the rivals, but especially ThinkAnalytics which bills itself as the global leader in TV recommendation, claiming to be installed at 130 million homes. This includes the UK’s ITV and BSkyB, as well as Liberty Global in Europe. Digitalsmiths says its Seamless Discovery platform is licensed to go to more than 100 million households worldwide.
‘The Digitalsmiths acquisition opens new opportunities to commercialize and deploy TiVo’s cloud based services and technologies to operators, in an extremely cost effective way that can be offered either independently or in conjunction with TiVo’s renowned user interface,’ said Tom Rogers, CEO and President of TiVo.