News Corp founder and chairman, Rupert Murdoch has survived a vote that will probably mean that his company can keep control of DirecTV.
The all important vote means that his hastily put together poison pill provision that was enacted to make it impossible for anyone, especially John Malone’s Liberty Media, to take control of News Corp, will stay in place.
Disaffected minority shareholders, including Liberty Media, forced a vote on whether or not the controversial poison pill should be allows to stand, and shareholders have now narrowly approved the anti-takeover provision with 57% of investors in favor.
Rupert Murdoch’s family controls around 30% of News shares, while Malone has managed to acquire around 19% over the past few years.
The poison pill effectively gives the board ‘ controlled by Murdoch, that ability to dilute any hostile acquirer of shares, by issuing more shares to other shareholders.
Murdoch and Malone have fought an increasingly public battle under which Malone was seen as trying to buy DirecTV on the cheap, by applying pressure on the News Corp Board. Murdoch was reported as saying, ‘If someone wants to buy an asset from us, they can come in the front door,’ after the votes were counted.
Although shares in News Corp fell briefly after the deal, this means that Murdoch can continue to drive up the share value of DirecTV, which has had success after success, in driving up subscribers to the satellite TV service, which has over 15 million customers, second only to the Comcast cable service which has 21.5 million customers, but which has not grown its customer base for four years.
Murdoch is thought to have been distracted by this battle, from his strategy of trying to add a broadband return path to DirecTV, through a deal with Clearwire or other wireless broadband suppliers, which has been expected for some time. The idea has also been put forward that DirecTV might merge with EchoStar and they might share that return path, which would overnight create the biggest pay TV operator in the US.
Perhaps this will release Murdoch to cement those plans, but it is unlikely that Malone has finished his stake building activities yet, and may well prepare legal challenges to the poison pill instrument, which are notoriously unreliable in a genuine takeover fight.