Your browser is not supported. Please update it.

17 July 2014

Dish free ride on TV Anywhere at heart of broadcaster annoyance

There is some inequality in the various TV Anywhere strategies among US pay TV players, and it is that inequality that we suspect will force the case between Dish Networks and Fox Broadcasting to end up going before the Supreme Court.

This week Dish won another round in the US Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit when it agreed with a lower court decision which rejects the Fox idea that some aspects of place-shifting are, after almost a decade of being accepted, illegal after all.

The problem, as we see it, is that if content is sent to a TV through one broadcasting route, that is one fee for Fox, but when a pay TV company says can I also send it entirely over the internet, that’s another opportunity to raise that fee.

In the case of Dish, it doesn’t get to charge this additional fee, because it takes the broadcast version, takes it out of its encoding wrapper, plays it, and then re-encodes it and sends it across the internet, not even asking permission to do this. We call this place-shifting and have since it was first introduced around 2005, when both Sling Media and Orb both launched place-shifted TV services.

Since then Orb has disappeared and Sling got itself acquired by Dish’s cousin EchoStar (which shares some shareholders and board members) and the only major pay TV company in the US that uses this approach is Dish itself. The only reason for this is because broadcast networks have warned other companies off the approach, because it is fundamentally cheaper for Dish.

What they might have said behind closed doors is ‘if you go down this route, after we get Dish, we will come after you,’ and such is the cautious nature of US pay TV, rivals do not want to get caught up in another ‘TiVo’ debacle, and are sat on the sidelines waiting. But they will almost be applying pressure to broadcasters like Fox, saying ‘why are we paying for this privilege if Dish is getting it for free?’

And when there is even a reasonable number of $ millions behind a decision, the broadcasters generally want things to go all the way to the supreme Court before they are satisfied, even though until Aereo they had an almost 100% failure record in getting any Supreme Court rulings in their favor.

We have already given our opinion of how the Aereo decision is likely to impinge upon existing law ‘ suggesting that if a consumer makes a copy of content or uses the internet to send it to another device, then because it is the consumer doing it for his or herself, it would be analogous to the Betamax decision. After all a Betamax battery operated device (if they ever existed) can take a permanent copy and could allow you to take it anywhere, so there is almost no difference from the original case.

The two particular issues that Fox has been concerned about Autohop and PrimeTime Anytime, are just specific cases of this. Autohop allows the consumer to set up the recording to jump past adverts, something which is already common usage in most DVRs, and PrimeTime Anytime is simplifying the command to record all the national broadcast channels all the time, again, something that an individual could do with any prior DVR.

So if Fox goes ahead and asks for permission to put this to the Supreme Court, we suspect that the Court would refuse to hear it, pointing out that the case is already dealt with by previous decisions.

If you apply the other invisible rule, ‘Does this change the status quo financially’ the answer is clear enough. Place-shifting has been going on for almost ten years and no-one has gone bust ‘ so it does not have the power to upset this market, even if Dish is getting too good a deal.

Dish executives naturally crowed about the decision saying it was pleased that the Court had sided with consumer choice over the AutoHop and PrimeTime Anytime features. We will continue to vigorously defend consumers’ right to choice and control over their viewing experience.”

But once it is clear whether or not the broadcasters wish to take this to the Supreme Court, then rapidly other pay TV players will either consider implementing their own place-shifting system or simply ask broadcasters in negotiations, why they are paying extra to do what Dish can already do for free.