Your browser is not supported. Please update it.

25 August 2011

Dish leaps one wireless generation, straight to LTE Advanced

Dish Networks has uncovered a little about the plans it has for its 40 MHz of MSS spectrum in a filing it has made with the FCC this week. It has said openly that it wants to build a 4G network, delivering both branded and wholesale services, using the spectrally efficient LTE Advanced, targeting a 2014 launch time frame. This level of detail was revealed in its request to the FCC to transfer the spectrum authorizations to its new subsidiary Gamma, potentially the brand name under which Dish will operate these services.

Before we go into detail about what was said, it is worth talking about what wasn’t said and the big thing missing is money. The whole tone of the request was exceptionally logically argued and it is worth a read (on the FCC site) to anyone who wants a say in the future of US broadband, triple play and cellular services. But Dish is making it look like it will go to the stock market for funds and build this out itself, based on the ‘cuteness’ of its plan. Our feeling is that there are partners waiting in the wings ‘ one of these, most people are guessing, includes DTH rival DirecTV, now owned by John Malone’s Liberty Media, and every bit in need of a broadband capability as Dish. John Malone could finance a US cellular network out of his back pocket, and is one of the richest men in the US.

The biggest question here, is that Dish Chairman Charlie Ergen has fought tooth and claw against Malone for the past few years, and against DirecTV since it was launched, and the only thing they have in common is a lack of a broadband return path which they control. If Ergen could finance this and specifically exclude DirecTV, it might serve him better than partnering with DirecTV. As for raising the money through the US stock market ‘ the efforts of ClearWire and then LightSquared, neither of which have had a trouble free existence, may have made investors tired of partially funded network builds, only to lose confidence and virtually wreck the network through lack of continued investment. Ergen will almost certainly want to avoid that fate and would prefer a partner which has been an arch-rival, but who it can combine with in a common cause.

But while Dish may not have anything like enough money on its own to build out such a network and while it is still not letting anyone have a whiff of who its partners may be, it has virtually everything else in place, as long as it gets the waivers it is seeking to use the spectrum both from a satellite and also from ground stations in separate services. There are some statements that Dish has made in the past that are hard to reconcile with this plan, but they are not impossible to reconcile, such as its main business remaining video, and not planning to waste its money building cellular networks.

The choice of LTE Advanced, with technology for base stations and devices available by 2014 at the earliest, is the biggest surprise and reading between the lines of its request Dish seems to be saying that this decision will make it very easy to build out the network. The idea is to use the two 20 MHz segments as paired spectrum.

LTE Advanced will eventually use many small base stations, and with the additional of active interference management, will offer huge improvements in wireless bandwidth. Effectively the spectrum is used in smaller cells, so can be used more often and more of it for each individual connection. The prospect of Dish posting self-installed femtocells or of including them, pre-built inside Dish set tops, could make all deployments, including rural deployments, cheaper than it has been for any previous cellular technology. It would need some form of backhaul, but fixed line through a home broadband signal, satellite or even self-backhaul, using a portion of the spectrum for femtocells to reach far off base-stations, would all be possible. The peak rate anticipated in a 20 MHz signal for LTE Advanced is said to be as high as 1 Gbps, so that much data would be shared over the users of any given base station and some percentage of that could be used for self-backhaul.

Dish even acquired 6MHz of 700 MHz spectrum in the auctions in the E Block analog switch off spectrum, and although this is not nationwide, it could easily create a rural long distance backhaul option. It holds this spectrum across most of the US rural areas, although the same spectrum went to Qualcomm in New York, Philadelphia, Boston, Los Angeles and San Francisco, for its MediaFLO broadcast, which is now being sold off to AT&T, a move that Dish has complained about, because it would dearly love to own that spectrum too.

The other major waiver that Dish is asking for is that it does not have to have a spare satellite on the ground, ready to launch in under 12 month’s for each service. Two spare satellites of that caliber would set it back $500 million, and Dish argues that it has 11 satellites in the air, plus the DBSD and TerreStar satellites can be used to back one another up, and anyway the terrestrial network can back it up. Making Dish set aside $500 million which could be used in build out may well prove unnecessary, and it makes the point that most satellites fail on their way up or in the first year, and it is past that with both satellites.

Just to be clear, the ATC or Ancillary Terrestrial Component can be thought of as a separate network almost, because although you need the same radio to listen to both components, the signal orientation prevents one signal in the same spectrum from interfering with the other. So having 40 MHz of S-Band is like having 40 MHz of satellite spectrum and another 40 MHz of cellular spectrum, once Dish gets its waivers to completely separate them.

The arguments in favor of giving both waivers ‘ that on the integrated
service rules and on the spare satellite ‘ are both likely to go through in our view and this must be seen very much part and parcel of any deal under which the FCC gives assent to the AT&T purchase of T-Mobile USA. Investment by suppliers in handsets and base stations for this network depend on knowing that the network can grow. Without doing what it can for that investment, the FCC could be seen to be favoring making the US a cellular duopoly with 80% of customers and 90% of revenues in the cellular market. It needs to be generous towards such waivers if it plans to accede to the AT&T T-Mob merger.

Given that both Clearwire and LightSquared have question marks over their long term future, the FCC needs to be seen to be doing everything it can to a) deliver universal broadband across the US, and b) keeping competition going within wireless broadband.

Ergen and co seem to know this, and their arguments are to the general public as much as the FCC. Once Gamma has these waivers, it will find money easy to find and it will have the stores, in Blockbuster, to compete with AT&T and Verizon stores, right across the US, and a 14 million TV customer base to hit with a triple, if not Quad, play offer.

Add to that the notion that Gamma would have a healthy homeland security, public safety and disaster preparedness business using a small amount of the satellite portion of the spectrum, a business already inherited from TerreStar, and that some of that satellite capacity could also be used to deliver broadcast video and music services to both LTE Advanced and non-LTE Advanced devices (the satellite can mimic virtually any protocol that is used in the same spectrum) and you see the full functioning wireless triple play at the heart of Ergen’s spectrum vision.

However we continue to believe that once all of this is in position for Dish, Ergen will make a pass at LightSquared, dropping the LightSquared funds into paying for a vastly cheaper network than anyone currently realizes is possible, using the Dish spectrum and LTE Advanced, retail proposition femtocells and a bare bones macro cell infrastructure. But if that is its plan it had better hurry, before LightSquared goes irrevocably down the LTE route.