Your browser is not supported. Please update it.

10 November 2011

Dish tantalizes with visions of mergers and mobile video ‘ as subs fall

One of our hobbies is reading through transcripts of the comments made by Dish Chairman Charlie Ergen and his new CEO Joe Clayton, and trying to make sense of it once a quarter. So wading through the Seeking Alpha transcript once again we can see the basis of many potential headlines ‘ but are any of them on the right track?

One publication chose to suggest that Dish may get into mobile video, which of course this transcript suggests more strongly than ever, and another tack may have been that if AT&T manages to land its merger with T-Mobile USA, then Dish and DirecTV will have another go at merging.

The statement about DirecTV is an echo coming back to us from May, when Joe Clayton teased investors by revisiting the idea that first got off the ground in 2002 when the FCC pushed it back, saying that it would be anticompetitive. We see Ergen’s logic ‘ an AT&T T-Mobile USA merger would give it perhaps 129 million mobile subscribers in a market of 323 million, so some 40% of market control. If Dish was to merge with DirecTV it would have 33.7 million subscribers, out of a total pay TV audience in the US of 101 million homes, so just over 33%. It doesn’t take too much genius to work out if the AT&T deal is allowable, then there is a good chance that the other deal is also allowable.

But as Ergen notes, there are at least two things that get in the way of deals like that ‘ the other side actually wanting to do it, and do it under the right terms, and the fact that AT&T deal may get approved, but with divestments which make the comparison of the two deals less favorable. The real reason for Charlie mentioning that deal is because that’s NOT what is going to happen. Or at least he has other plans in mind.

The answer to all his Q&A questions are designed to do two things ‘ one, raise the share price of Dish, by continuing to plant ideas in the heads of the analysts, ideas that place a higher value on his position, and two, lead all of us away from where he is actually going so that no-one can put up obstacles.

But let’s for a moment suggest that both of these items raised in discussion with US financial analysts were at least partially true, that he wants to move away from purely fixed video delivery and that he wants to end up merging with DirecTV. How would he go about it, and is there a way that he can get there, or get close.

Since Cablevision first started marketing a $99 triple play in 2004, the US satellite DTH companies Dish and DirecTV have looked weaker. They can only get more customers by pushing HD sooner, and buying better quality content, including sports ‘ and that squeezes margins; they cannot get a return path for voice and broadband, or interactivity or for any VoD where they control the network directly. All the broadband partners which have nationwide broadband networks are competing with them on TV service ‘ so won’t allow a reseller agreement (they tried to get one with Clearwire). All the MSOs have slowly, but eventually, offered a very clear, 3 for the price of 2 triple play and are moving on now to a 4 for the price of 3 quad play. They can discount TV service without harming their overall profitability and they can go through life improving profits without increasing their TV customers, something we saw in detail last week as the top cable operators all had what they would call good results and between them lost some 357,000 pay TV homes.

So if the two DTH suppliers could get closer to one another, find a return path and offer broadband service and better still, cellular service, while at the same time continuing to grow TV homes at cable’s expense, they would look far more impressive financially and their underlying value would rocket. How can they do that?

Dish now has 40 MHz of 2 GHz S-Band spectrum which would form the basis of a quality cellular service, especially using the hyper-efficient LTE Advanced that is anticipated in four or five years, next generation LTE, which Ergen has said is his target. This of course will rely heavily on dynamic interference management, with base stations intelligently strengthening and weakening signals based on how much data they need to send at any point in time and who else is trying to use the same spectrum. This is analogous to the techniques used by Assia in fixed line DSL services to optimize crosstalk in telco wire bundles.

Dynamic interference management will require there being lots and lots of smaller base stations ‘ femtocells if you like, and the potential for a network being made up of two major device types, major multi-spectrum macro base stations and tiny home based femtocells, and this may well suit a company like Dish, and even more a combined network of Dish and DirecTV, working alongside an existing cellular operator or someone who had the funding to become one (like LightSquared) or one or more of the second tier cellular operators.

The network operator could build fewer, very powerful Macro base stations, and backhaul them conventionally, and the two DTH suppliers might either send user-installed femtocells for in-home use or have their installation contractors, who have to put up a satellite dish anyway, put a femtocell (or other device) up on the roof, alongside the dish. In-house devices sound better and can be backhauled by wireless to the nearby base station or can use wired DSL for backhaul ‘ again better to use the powerful spectral efficiency of LTE Advanced to backhaul them.

The critical thing is that Dish is applying for its spectrum to have an Ancillary Terrestrial Component, this is fundamental to combing these two ideas of having a mobile video signal and having a cellular signal.

The FCC has pretty much been argued to a standstill over the use of ATC’s and the idea is fairly simple, with much of the lobbying work having been done by LightSquared when it was MSV, and by TerreStar which Dish now owns, and both have full rights to all the patents involved.

The key to all of this is to have radio beams which can be perceived in a directional fashion. That way those coming from a satellite do not interfere with those coming from the ground, because antennas can be adjusted automatically to pick up either signal. This had to be proved, patented and licensed before this industry could take off and now it is largely ready to do that.

The ATC can be thought of as a separate network almost. It requires transmitters, which in S-band are likely to have a range very similar to those of 3G, perhaps 6 or 7 Km, depending on power limits, plus additional gap fillers to deliver into urban canyons (between skyscrapers for instance). Alternatively they might be set up with lots and lots of smaller rooftop transmitters working over smaller distances.

Were Dish to create a TV delivery mechanism to the handset, using the satellite portion of this spectrum, it could still lease the terrestrial part of the spectrum to another cellular player. The spectrum can then be used twice. Of course this is not a new idea. Spectrum is used over and over again in cellular, by creating radio segments which die out or attenuate, before they reach another competing base station, which uses the same piece of the spectrum. It’s just that now this idea can be operated in 3 dimensions, with ‘from above’ being yet another direction.

The problem here is that you won’t get in-building penetration from a satellite without cranking up the EIRP until it does interfere with the Terrestrial component. But there are plenty of ways of getting around this and once again Ergen threw some misdirection into the Q&A session when he talked about more and more WiFi networks being available. We think he is asking us to conclude that content would be sent from the cloud to the home gateway and over WiFi to non-set top devices. But that would require that his video is at the mercy of rival broadband players.

Under this scenario, when you are out watching TV you use the satellite signal, when you are in you use WiFi. It seems logical, except he doesn’t have to pay all those peering and CDN charges, like Netflix if he does it another way. The signals from the Terrestar or DBSD satellites could be picked up by an external satellite dish as well, and can be transferred down to a home gateway and sent over WiFi, or better still sent to a set top to be tuned and then sent around the home using Sling Media’s placeshifting. Tuning is changing and the recently announced Broadcom full band capture chips would capture and tune a satellite signal for the home, and another for each tablet in the house, with ease. Broadcom even said so and demonstrated it at IBC.

So outside the house you get signals straight to an LTE chip, which is embedded in your device, and inside the home, you get the same signal over WiFi. And in 40 MHz of spectrum that might be as many as 200 QVGA TV channels or more likely 100 with better definition. And the spectrum would feel untouched as far as cellular voice and broadband use was concerned ‘ it would be DTH to all portable devices and no new-fangled chip might be required, just those which arte already being developed.

Dish could either share this capability with DirecTV without ever merging with it, or it could be a step prior to merging, which made Dish more valuable for a more equitable merger (only if the AT&T T-Mobile deal went ahead and DirecTV could be convinced). Today DirecTV is valued at $33 billion by the stock market, Dish at under $11 billion, but if Dish was to supply this for both of them, that might push its valuation up considerably.

If it was to also land one or a group of cellular players to create and sell a wholesaled cellular service and provide them with the spectrum and an up-front investment for build out, perhaps from DirecTV’s parent, the cash rich Liberty Media, then all of the things that Ergen has jokingly discussed might come true ‘ a mobile video service, which ALSO has a Blockbuster VoD offerings from the cloud, but which also carries advertising which means that the channel owners might offer both Dish and DirecTV better rates for carriage. And at the same time this collection of smaller cellular operators would have to promise to offer nationwide coverage of LTE Advanced, so that DirecTV and Dish would be able to wholesale the service and have their return path. It is all entirely feasible and it does not contradict a single thing that Clayton or Ergen have said.

We can conclude that there is no question that one of the things that Dish plans to do, either on its own, or with DirecTV or other pay TV operators, is to broadcast video channels to mobile devices and it will use VoD over the internet, from Blockbuster, to augment this. It may leave channels intact from its own existing TV services and get better terms from channel owners for the improved numbers. It will almost certainly do this by keeping the satellite portion of this 40 MHz of spectrum to itself and we should not forget that Dish also has a single channel of 700 MHz spectrum, almost nationwide, which could be used for any of these functions too or to broadcast the same TV signal terrestrially as well.

The only question is whether it partners with its rival, in DirecTV, with existing cellular operators, in Metro PCS and US Cellular, taking the cellular proposition to market. Or does it happen in spite of DirecTV and with an investor based entity like LightSquared. Ergen says that all depends on what happens with the AT&T T-Mobile USA merger, because that will change the landscape and of course he’s right.

Whatever the outcome, we are going to get a few years of this because this is how one DTH supplier, which is losing 111,000 subscribers last quarter, can appear to investors even more intriguing and interesting than another DTH supplier which has gained 327,000 subs in the quarter.

But to get any of this done, it all has to be done in the right order. First the acquisition of the spectrum needs to be approved by the FCC, then any conditions it imposes have to be met. After that the FCC also has to grant it the ATC waiver. Then Dish will need to ensure it has its equipment plan in order from the satellites themselves, right down to the price and supply chain of the components in any devices which are essential. It can then negotiate with the potential partners it has in mind one at a time, and moving on to the next if it cannot reach terms. Then it may announce something concrete. But for at least the next few quarter, expect this mild lifting of skirts, just above ankle level, to keep us all intrigued.

Already in its results it made it clear that Blockbuster is on the way to being integrated, with the arrival of the Blockbuster Movie Pass which offers a year of DVDs and video games by mail, 20 live movie channels and VoD streaming of thousands of movies to both the TV and PC, bundled into a 2-year price. It has also added its Blockbuster combo pass, which provides unlimited in-store exchanges along with its by-mail service, and this has attracted over 600,000 customers in its first few months. The company is also selling Dish service out of some Blockbuster stores. Clayton says the results are very encouraging and that these marketing promotions will be the primary catalyst for positive subscriber growth in the fourth quarter.

The company said that it has also announced a $2 a share nonrecurring dividend payable in cash, primarily because it didn’t use up the money by buying Hulu.