Charlie Ergen’s Dish Network has spent the past two years running very fast to stand very still. It has tried many moves which had the potential to disrupt the market, but most of these have failed ‘ although just the frantic activity of Dish on the sidelines has been enough to spur more conventional operators into action, and so has been disruptive in that sense. This year will tell whether Dish manages to acquire sufficient spectrum ‘ and the network infrastructure partner it needs to make the sums add up ‘ to forge ahead with its plan to build a national LTE-Advanced network in a patchwork of spectrum, mainly repurposed mobile satellite bands. The primary purpose of this network would be to add the wireless, broadband and quad play element to its TV services, and so keep it competitive with the cablecos, but it is also widely expected to offer wholesale services to maximize revenue.
That would recreate the dream that LightSquared had (and Clearwire before it) ‘ a wholesale network to support a host of new service providers which could take very different approaches from the cellcos or even the mainstream MVNOs. They could include device makers, web services players, internet of things specialists, and so on.
But to impact the market in any way, Ergen needs more spectrum. Having acquired his initial S-band frequencies from bankrupt mobile satellite operators TerreStar and DBSD, his firm did receive FCC approval to run terrestrial-only services in this spectrum. LightSquared, of course, had gained a similar waiver for its L-band frequencies, but its plan failed because of concerns of interference with nearby GPS services, once terrestrial networks (with higher power signals than satellite) were operating.
One of Ergen’s failed (or stalled) tactics to add to his spectrum arsenal is to buy LightSquared out of bankruptcy protection, though some of the L-band spectrum would probably have to lie fallow because of the GPS issue, at least until suitable filters are developed. LightSquared, which has proposed a spectrum swap ‘ exchanging the problematic airwaves for the right to share some federal frequencies ‘ in order to restart its roll-out, has also rejected Dish’s bid in favour of one led by existing investors. However, that is contingent on the government accepting the spectrum swap idea, and if it does not, Dish may well return with a new offer.
In the meantime, it has suffered other setbacks, notably its bids for Sprint and Clearwire last year. Its bold attempt to outbid Softbank of Japan, now the majority owner of Sprint, did drive the price up for the third cellco, but was unlikely to have succeeded. Dish’s real goal was Clearwire, with its plentiful 2.5GHz TDD spectrum, and it sought to seize control of the venture from under Sprint’s nose ‘ but with Sprint’s majority stake and Softbank’s eagerness to get its hands on the 2.5GHz assets, that bid failed too and Clearwire became a full subsidiary of Sprint.
An infrastructure deal with Sprint should still be on the cards despite the acrimony between the two firms ‘ an important aspect of the mobile operator’s strategy for its technology-neutral Network Vision architecture is to host partners’ networks, as it once planned to do for LightSquared, and such a deal would reduce Dish’s costs, while it could offer the cellco access to content and video deals, something it badly lacks when competing with the quad play telcos (especially since Sprint lost its longstanding alliance with a group of large cablecos to Verizon). Dish recently partnered with its antagonist for a fixed wireless broadband trial, which could be another factor in a potential alliance, giving the cellco a rooftop, fixed play and in-home TV services.
However, it currently seems more likely that Dish will lock horns with Sprint again with a possible bidding war for T-Mobile. Ergen has reportedly had informal talks with TMo and its major shareholder Deutsche Telekom over recent months, but at the moment, the momentum is with Sprint. Softbank has initiated direct talks with DT, according to Bloomberg sources, while Sprint is said to be lining up financing with two banks.
Of course, there is a big question mark over how regulators would view the merger of the US’s third and fourth mobile operators, especially since T-Mobile has recently embarked on a highly disruptive pricing strategy, in the wake of merging with fifth cellco MetroPCS. While the justification for joining forces with Sprint might rest on creating a stronger competitor to the big two, in reality, TMo is looking far more viable than it did when AT&T tried, and failed, to snap it up. It is building out LTE, moving its 3G services out of its awkward AWS spectrum, and is prompting change in the US market with its ‘Uncarrier’ approaches, which provide lower data prices, and even remove early termination fees.
Nonetheless, the international operators behind Sprint and TMo are said to be keen to merge ‘ Softbank, Sprint’s major shareholder, to improve its spectrum and scale against AT&T and Verizon; DT because it wants to offload its 67% stake in its former US subsidiary entirely (but under the rules of the merger with MetroPCS, which took TMo public, for now it can only sell its stake as a single tranche, which suggests a strategic buyer).
The Bloomberg sources say that Softbank has secured assurances from two banks that financing will be available for a bid, and the Japanese firm is now talking to DT about unresolved issues such as how a deal would be split between cash and stock, and integration concerns. DT wants an all-cash offer for its stake in TMo and, like Vodafone, is likely to want to use the proceeds from a US exit to finance its ambitious network upgrade plans in Europe and elsewhere. Another important issue, given the regulatory uncertainty, is how big a break-up fee would be should the deal be vetoed on antitrust grounds.
Another clue that all parties are actively exploring the long-rumored deal came from DT’s CEO Tim Hoettges, who told Bloomberg that the telco had now recouped its investment in its US arm, since an increase in the unit’s value had made up for the €7.4bn writedown on the asset in 2012. He said the value of the enlarged TMo USA was now back at the same level as when AT&T was pursuing it, and DT’s 67% stake is worth about $28bn. T-Mobile has an equity value of $26bn and total debt of about $13.6bn, according to data compiled by Bloomberg. Analysts speculate that a Sprint deal could reach about $50bn in total, $31bn being paid to TMo and $20bn to refinance existing TMo debt.
Meanwhile, TMo’s vocal CEO John Legere hinted at the recent Consumer Electronics Show that a deal with Sprint was ‘not out of the question’, but insisted his firm’s brand and ‘Uncarrier’ deals were ‘here to stay’, sparking speculation that there might be conditions in the deal to preserve TMo’s identity, offerings and some measure of autonomy. While that might be difficult for Softbank’s vision of a single mass of data capacity, it might help to appease antitrust regulators by keeping a competitive brand alive.
Whether or not Dish makes a play for TMo, it is after lower hanging fruit by being the biggest name to participate in the neglected PCS H Block auction ‘ although a host of local carriers is also involved, looking to boost regional spectrum positions, especially in the big cities. These include
nTelos, Cellular South Licenses (probably a cover name for C Spire) and America Movil’s Puerto Rico arm. ‘Dish faces little competition for the H Block and should be able to buy another block of national spectrum at below-market prices,’ BTIG analyst Walter Piecyk told Bloomberg.
The H Block is a 10MHz set of paired airwaves in 1915MHz-1920MHz (uplink) and 1995MHz-2000MHz (downlink). This is adjacent to Dish’s spectrum in 2000MHz-2020MHz (uplink) and 2180MHz-2200MHz (downlink). Dish has agreed to bid the reserve price of $1.56bn ‘ guaranteeing the auction will not fail like that of the 700MHz D Block. In return, it asked the FCC to let it use the uplink block for downlink too, provided it lowered power in the 700MHz E Block. The latter condition enticed AT&T to sign its recent agreement to support interoperability in the 700MHz A Block.
The sale should conclude within a few. There are 23 candidates in all, chasing spectrum in 176 individual Economic Areas, with the proceeds helping to fund the long-awaited national public safety network. The end game for Dish is less obvious. Even if it gets most of the H Block, it will still not have enough, by its own estimates, to support the level of LTE-A capacity it needs. So it will still have to secure more airwaves, either by M&A or future auctions, or a spectrum share. Putting aside its differences with Sprint is the most logical move, but maverick Ergen does not always follow the most logical path.