It all seemed so picture perfect back in late 2007. Android had arrived, promising an open and royalty-free mobile platform at last. Unlike previous mobile open source attempts, it would have serious R&D investment and market weight courtesy of Google; but unlike Symbian on handsets and Linux on set tops, supporters would not have to bend to the will of their largest competitor. Most alluringly, it would not carry the hefty licensing fees of Windows Mobile ‘ or indeed, any fees at all.
That promise was the signal for a mass defection from other multivendor OSs to Google’s, and for many new players to leap the lowered barriers to entry into the handset market and on the back of that Android and Chrome after it were seen as saviors in the Tablet wars and a distinct possibility in set tops.
But the spearhead of Android was in the handset community where disturbingly, it was also the signal for many of the most creative players in the sector to put a full stop on innovation, chasing the low cost base of a platform where the R&D is effectively outsourced to Google and the open source community. There were exceptions, like the HTC Sense overlay, but generally Android has created a market of clones. Affordable, usable, apps-rich, but still clones ‘ and amazingly, it has been left to Microsoft to show there are other approaches to the mobile experience than the norms of Apple/Android.
But it won’t be the differentiated UI that draws new licensees to join Nokia in the Windows Phone 7 corral ‘ it will be the end of the myth that the trade-offs of Android were worthwhile because it was FREE. HTC, the most innovative of the Android majors, has also been the company that has revealed the true nature of the beast ‘ first, by signing a licensing deal for Microsoft patents in Android, which reportedly costs it at least $5 per handset; second, by losing a judgment in its IPR battle with Apple, which if upheld could potentially give Apple claims over every Android device. The HTC defeat at the US ITC (International Trade Commission) may still be reversed, but Android is now involved in almost 50 separate patent lawsuits. The most fundamental of those is Oracle’s attack, claiming that Android infringes Java IPR and copyright ‘ and that is the only dispute so far to involve Google directly. The fact that Google has not struck back and cannot strike back, with its own countersuit that Apple and Microsoft are using their market weight to live off its efforts. Absent some form of defensive suit, Android lovers are being forced to look elsewhere.
The storm of lawsuits is destabilizing Android by creating fear about further litigation; and to make it less attractive by demonstrating that it will not be free after all. Apple’s objective is clearly to weaken the main rival to iOS, forcing other OEMs to cancel product lines or waste time seeking workarounds ‘ so it is unlikely to settle for licensing deals too quickly, since revenue is not the real point at issue. However, as its defeat by Nokia showed, Apple is not strong in all areas of device technology and so far it has scored few wins ‘ even the ruling that HTC infringes two of its patents is subject to review by the full panel of the ITC. Microsoft is the firm with the unquestionable patents power, but it has different aims. It wants to enhance WP7’s reputation as being protected from litigation and damage that of Android, in order to lure defectors from the Google OS. On the side, it will also welcome the extra income (it is rumored to be seeking as much as $15 per handset from Samsung) while it struggles to build mobile licensing revenues of its own via WP7 fees.
Adopting an alternative operating system is clearly one recourse for Android supporters, should they see a string of legal judgments going against them (and one HTC swallow does not, we must remember, make a summer for Apple, especially with appeals looming). Few OEMs would drop the Google OS, with its massive developer support and growing cross-device appeal, but they might move other platforms to center stage. That would also serve the purpose of making them less reliant on Google, whose power many hold in suspicion.
The other line of defense is to build a powerful patent arsenal for Android itself, and so have power to fight back against the Apple and Microsoft machines. This is an option which clearly interests Google, given its stalking horse bid for Nortel’s huge IPR assets ‘ though it was not so interested as to keep bidding and trump the winning offer of $4.5 billion, which put the patents into the hands of a group including key rivals such as Apple itself. As the legal processes play out their tortuous game, Google and its OEM partners will hope that Apple loses enough rounds to make the threat to Android trivial. In the meantime, though, we will see the players working on their fallback plans ‘ flirting with other OSs, and acquiring patents ‘ in a dance that will help shape the OS landscape of 2012.
The event, then, that brought the issues into sharp relief was the preliminary ITC ruling that HTC infringed on two of the 10 patents cited by Apple in its lawsuit of a year ago (the iPhone maker recently followed up with a second complaint, while its rival has filed countersuits too). After a string of recent setbacks, Apple finally scored the kind of win it needs to unsettle the Android community with the fear of rising costs and further legal liability ‘ since the two patents in question are probably used in all Android devices, and are also included in Apple’s lawsuits against Motorola Mobility. They are US patent number 5,946,647 – a ‘system and method for performing an action on a structure in computer-generated data’; and US patent number 6,343,263, a ‘real time signal processing system for serially transmitted data.’
For HTC, whose fortunes have been rising steadily on its Android success, the ruling is serious. At best it will involve the Taiwanese firm in a large amount of additional cost and uncertainty as it goes through appeals and comes to a compromise deal; at worst, the ITC has the power to ban imports of its products to the US, and Apple could refuse a license and go after big damages. The company’s shares dropped to their lowest level in six months in Taipei after news of the ruling, and have fallen by 11% in total since Apple stepped up its legal pressure on HTC last week with a second ITC complaint, about a year after its initial attack.
However, patent sagas are notoriously unpredictable and volatile, so this ruling needs to be put into perspective. In the multifaceted Android battles, Apple has suffered more setbacks than wins so far. In a research note, Chialin Lu, an analyst at Samsung Securities, cut through the hysteria, writing: ‘The two violated patents are less critical and are seemingly unrelated to the usage of multitouch and the core of the Android operating systems. By liable devices, HTC has less to lose than Apple ‘ 45 million Android phones versus more than 150 million Apple devices.’ HTC said it was close to being able to work around the two patents in question, and we can be sure that the combined weight of the Android community is working on updates that will dilute Apple’s claims. However, developments like this one achieve what Apple and Microsoft hope for, creating genuine uncertainty and the prospect of a more expensive Android.
WP7, of course, would probably not be cheaper, but it would be safe from litigation or unpredictable fees, according to the Microsoft hymnal. Although Microsoft has to be careful not to alienate its most powerful ally, Nokia, it is reported to be looking particularly keenly at China for new WP7 recruits, armed with the improvements made to its OS in the upcoming Mango release. ZTE and Huawei, according to local newspaper Business Herald, expect to give WP7 a bigger role in their handset strategies because of the legal risks associated with Android, which could remove its cost advantage. But the other OS which is already gaining support in China is Intel’s MeeGo, virtually abandoned by Nokia but the focus of serious development at ZTE as well as LG. Of course, who knows what patent claims might lurk in MeeGo’s Linux-based kernel should it become popular? It is the MeeGo OS that is also winning plaudits in our own Faultline area of TV set tops.
Another option ‘ though one, like MeeGo, more suited to next generation form factors than conventional handsets ‘ is HP’s webOS. Last week, HP reorganized the executives behind the former Palm platform to strengthen its bid to put it at the heart of the cloud ‘ and one of those execs was even hinting at a tie-up with cloud major Amazon. Under HP’s new strategy, webOS will underpin a push to be the cloud client OS in every kind of device from printers to tablets. A few flagship gadgets, like the new TouchPad, will showcase the software capabilities but smartphones like the Palm Pre will remain where handsets have always been in HP, on the sidelines. Jon Rubinstein, former CEO of Palm, gained a broader role within the new personal systems division, but was effectively removed from direct control of webOS, signaling the death of Palm or a serious smartphone strategy at HP.
But it was Rubinstein who hinted, in an interview that Amazon might be a future ally. He said: ‘So, we’d like a partner that would allow us to expand the webOS ecosystem ‘ I would say Amazon would certainly make a great partner, because they have a lot of characteristics that would help them expand the webOS ecosystem.’
So far Amazon has used Android as its main vehicle for its mobile content push, launching its own Android AppStore as an alternative to Google’s Market, and it is expected to announce tablets soon. But the company is expected to create its own user experience, which will be OS-neutral. Amazon’s aim is to dominate in sales and branding of digital content and cloud services, regardless of the OS on the client, but it knows it gains greater influence on the all-important user experience if it has some control of that OS. That has made Android its best choice for smartphone apps, despite political conflicts with Google, but it will certainly look beyond that as it seeks to wrongfoot the search giant.
Samsung is also seeking a multi-OS strategy that will not over-expose it to Android, in the light of its own Apple legal battles. It is said to be moving WP7 up the priority list for its holiday season and 2012 launches. However, its primary counterweight is likely to be its own Bada, which has proved unexpectedly popular despite its single-vendor nature, driving almost as much smartphone growth for Samsung in the key midmarket as Android.
Apple’s legal attack on Samsung is high risk, not just because the Korean firm is a huge components supplier to the iPhone and other products, but because ‘ unlike HTC, but like Nokia, which defeated Apple in a separate IPR battle ‘ Samsung is a huge patent holder in the fundamental areas of wireless technology. Apple is weaker here, and its Nokia outcome illustrated that the iPhone maker might be swimming out of its depth in the patent wars, when these are fought around wireless rather than software/UI technology. Samsung, for instance, is thought to be a top three patent holder in LTE so has plenty of weapons to fire at its assailants.
The possession of wireless specific patents ‘ not just those related to devices and user experience ‘ is vital to cross-licensing deals in handsets, to influence other standards and to the general balance of power. Here, Apple, Google and Microsoft are relative bystanders compared to the traditional heavyweights, and that has not changed significantly in LTE, except to push the balance more towards Asian majors like ZTE, Samsung and Huawei.
Of course, that raises all kinds of interesting prospects for the Microsoft-Nokia alliance. With both giants staking their mobile fortunes on WP7, Nokia has as much interest as its new best friend in weakening both Apple and Android. It has not yet celebrated its Apple victory by taking a more aggressive approach to its huge IPR collection, but with its revenue and influence failing elsewhere, this could be expected. A two-headed effort by these two, with their vast and complementary patent portfolios, would be a hugely disruptive one.
The importance of essential IPR in LTE, in particular, was seen in the price paid for Nortel’s assets, and now another treasure trove could come to the market, perhaps giving Google another chance to shore up the position of Android. InterDigital said this week that it planned to ‘explore its strategic options’, including the possibility of putting itself or some of its patents up for sale. The company has a huge IPR position in the mobile world, being one of the major patent holders in 3G and an arsenal of about 8,800 patents (even more than Nortel’s 6,000 and many in similar areas). It also has a further 10,000 patent applications in process around the world and numbers all the handset majors among its licensees. If it goes up for sale, Google might prove even more determined than in the Nortel auction to make it, its own.