This week’s discussion of the Dolby Vision system will look primarily at the pros and cons of the technology and how this will affect its market penetration. To swiftly recap; Dolby Vision HDR promises a greatly improved picture quality that may provide a much better picture than a non-HDR 4K panel on an LED back-lit LCD screen. This makes it disruptive compared to the more expensive 4K and OLED TVs, as it could be possible to get a better picture on a significantly cheaper TV. But content will be key for both HDR and 4K, and that’s largely what we’ll be looking at below.
Dolby Vision could benefit in the market thanks to the many requirements that align it with the Rec 2020 specification set by the ITU-R. That standard governs Ultra HD, which specifies 4K and 8K resolutions, 16:9 aspect ratio, 10 or 12 bit color, and a much larger color gamut encoded in H.264 and HEVC.
Rec 2020 allows RGB and YCbCr formats with 4:4:4 color, and 4:2:2 and 4:2:0 which use chroma subsampling to save on file and signal sizes. These numbers are occasionally confusing, but refer to the data that is both recorded and converted by editors and codecs. More detail on the subsampling can be found in the February 6th edition of Faultline.
As the requirements of Dolby Vision overlap with Rec 2020, it would make sense for Dolby to pursue the ITU-R to augment Rec 2020 so that manufacturers who adhere to the standard will also be inherently Dolby Vision compatible. To bring Rec 2020 up to the Dolby Vision spec would require the ITU-R to increase the brightness of the standard.
As an end-to-end service that needs to embed itself into every sector of the distribution platform, Dolby Vision would require an end-to-end overhaul and upgrade of the distribution systems that the studios, the TV operators, the OTT providers, the CDNs and the OEMs all use. It is a rather large requirement that we suspect will take several years, if Dolby can persuade key players to convert.
Dolby claims to have already won over Hollywood directors and studios, but it will need to ensure that the studio’s output is in its Dolby Vision codec and that the consumer equipment is compatible. Persuading the ITU-R to make Rec 2020 compatible with the format will achieve the latter requirement, but there’s no guarantee that the ITU-R would act in Dolby’s favor or that Dolby can successfully acquire or generate content in Dolby Vision format.
However, the creeping advance of OLED threatens HDR over the anticipated multi-year timeframe. The Dolby solution only really benefits LCD screens, bringing them up to the same standard that plasma and OLED are able to achieve currently. OLED has been criticized for its lack of brightness, but that will no doubt be addressed over time.
Consequently, OLED panels will display non-HDR signals better than edge-lit LCD. However, as full array LED back-lit panels become more common in the market, the combination of LCD and HDR content will damage OLED sales.
OLED is massively more expensive than an LCD panel and will of course admirably display HDR content on screen. But for the vast majority of consumers, the price difference will not merit the extra cost. The picture quality of LCD screens stands to increase significantly thanks to HDR, and that increase in quality will come at the expense of OLED sales as OLED’s clear lead in picture quality will not be as obvious and significant.
There’s no clear answer yet as to whether Dolby can successfully insert itself into the video ecosystem. There’s been no confirmation from the studios that they have adopted HDR, nor word from the TV manufacturers that they are on board.
However, the problems that 4K faces, which we mentioned last week, may prove a benefit to Dolby’s HDR plans. To put it simply, HDR will provide a picture quality that rivals 4K on all but the very large TVs, while only using around 20-25% more bandwidth than a 1080p stream. That puts a lot less strain on the last-mile connection than a 4K stream.
As US ISPs have introduced data caps in the past few years and the speed of the last-mile connection is not typically fast enough, 4K streaming is a long way off for most US consumers. They could buy the TV, but won’t be able to watch anything in 4K on it. Physical media won’t be sold with 4K content and that leaves OTT streaming to supply 4K to those consumers, which for the vast majority of customers is not currently up to standard. DTH services using it may emerge first.
Comcast currently imposes a 300GB soft cap on its broadband customers, while AT&T imposes a limit of 150GB per month on DSL lines, and 250GB per month on its U-Verse broadband. Charter’s data caps vary between 100 – 500GB and Time Warner said in 2011 that imposing data caps on their customers was ‘inevitable,’ but never detailed what it imposed. There were no data caps at all before 2008 on US broadband networks.
Viewing 8 hours of HEVC encoded 4K per week would consume around 42GB of data, for a monthly usage of about 160GB. This is certainly in data cap territory for many consumers, and that is just for the average Netflix user. A heavy user could quite easily watch double that amount of content in a month (320GB), and families could easily increase their rates of consumption if family members watch Netflix independently of one another.
Netflix announced at CES 2014 that it would be streaming its House of Cards in 4K via HEVC compression that required a 15.6Mbs connection. Netflix’s figures for average peak usage speeds of its current H.264 SD and HD streams had Google Fiber in first place with 3.69 Mbps and Clearwire in last place (17th) with 0.96Mbps. These numbers are measures of speeds at primetime usage, and are ‘well below the peak performance due to many factors.’
Netflix recommends 3Mbps for DVD quality, 5Mbps for 720p, 7Mbps for 1080p and 12Mbps for 3D. It will no doubt soon be adding the 15.6Mbps required for 4K. Its average speeds show that many users are not viewing its content at HD quality at peak times, but if 4K is the future of TV then its users will want to use the full potential of their TVs and not be hampered by the capacity of their broadband connection, so perhaps Netflix had better start offering downloads.
So it’s plain to see that the line speed is a huge barrier to 4K. Using Netflix’s figures, it can be estimated that a Dolby Vision HDR 1080p stream would require 8.75 Mbps to stream if Dolby’s claim of 25% extra data is true. 8.75Mbps is drastically lower than the 15.6 Mbps needed for HEVC compressed 4K.
What’s more, if Netflix were to stream its HD content in HEVC, it would roughly halve the bandwidth needed as HEVC is about 50% more efficient than H.264. This would bring the HD Dolby Vision stream down to around 4.5Mbps ‘ drastically lower than the 15.6Mbps 4K (which would increase by 25% too if HDR were added to it).
It is also likely that the arrival of HEVC and Dolby Vision compatibility in the market will coincide. This would be very beneficial to Dolby Vision’s adoption, as HEVC compression would negate the extra streaming bandwidth requirement and increased file size of HDR content.
Dolby has said that it is already working with silicon vendors to incorporate the required hardware into TV and set top chips. This is the other end of its end-to-end strategy, which will take a longer time to implement than the production or distribution side of things.
This is because Dolby can simply provide a plug-in and set of reference monitors for the studios to use for the coloring and post production. Once the content is finalized, the publisher passes it through the distribution network on CDNs that have become predominantly content agnostic.
It will take a few years until the SoCs that Dolby says will support Dolby Vision are found in enough consumer devices that the technology could be used as a selling point by an operator or OTT supplier.
As the Vizio, TCL and Sharp TVs are due at the end of this year after their prototype debut at CES, we can assume that they will be the first products to market that will advertise Dolby Vision as a feature.
From there, other products will be introduced that support Dolby Vision as the compatible SoCs begin to appear in set tops, Blu-ray players and TVs. The same process must happen with the content itself.
Pre-existing content could be re-encoded to be Dolby Vision, but it will take several years until Dolby Vision becomes a common feature of new movies and TV content.
That is assuming that Dolby is successful in selling the product to the studios in the first place. It does claim that several directors are on board to use Dolby Vision in their next films, and if this claim rings true then it looks like the timeframes for Dolby Vision in content and Dolby Vision in consumer equipment will be complimentary in the years to come.
This is important for the consumers who don’t have access to the 15.6Mbps connection needed to stream 4K. Dolby Vision on Full HD could provide them with a visually impressive solution at a bandwidth that will fit over their last mile ‘ something that ISPs have historically been slow to upgrade. OTT 4K is hamstrung by the last mile in a way that a 1080p HDR signal is not. It’s all a matter of IP packets.
If ISPs do not upgrade their capacity, HEVC 4K streaming will simply not be an option for many consumers. Dolby Vision will pin its hopes on customers choosing to view HDR content instead of 4K thanks to its lower bandwidth requirement and the likelihood of the consumer having HDR ready equipment in the home already.
It will be interesting to see how the issue of data caps and line speed unfolds amidst the standoff between ISPs and the FCC in the US ‘ although the issue is certainly not unique to the USA.
So Dolby may have an edge in the TV showroom thanks to pricing and it may also have the edge in OTT delivery thanks to its much smaller minimum necessary bandwidths.
But we still haven’t fully fleshed out the magnitude of the task at hand if Dolby wants to become an end-to-end delivery system ‘ which it must be if it wants to make it into the home.
Next week we’ll look at the obstacles in the path of Dolby, including a rival HDR technology from Technicolor, and an alternative method of creating a HDR picture after it arrives at the TV from Sony called X-tended Dynamic Range.