There is a disturbing trend among operating companies to buy spectrum that it has no intention of building out, and hope they can use it to barter a privileged position among cellular operators. We are witnessing the warning bankruptcy in the US this week of Nextwave, which had intended to build out its spectrum, but which couldn’t raise the money, and at the other extreme we also have Dish Network which now has 40 MHz of S-Band spectrum in the US, with no intention of building it out, using it purely for deal leverage going forwards.
And in the Netherlands this was always going to be the case when the two leading pay TV providers Ziggo and UPC jointly bought national spectrum for building out LTE. Since that deal last May the two companies have promised two things ‘ firstly that they would have a quad play within two years, so by Spring 2012, and secondly that they would not spend all their money building it out. So what did they buy it for?
This week, as local news service Telecom Paper revealed that both Ziggo and UPC had each chosen a different cellular partner, they also stupidly asked the question, what happened to the idea that Ziggo and UPC would merge? Could they have perhaps stumbled over price and now find they must go their separate ways? We say ‘stupidly’ for a multitude of reasons, since the deal could never have passed muster at the competition authorities in the Netherlands, though it might at some distant point in the future. It would have meant handing a 64% market share for pay TV by number of homes to the merged entity, and something closer to 90% by subscription value and would have squashed rivals such as Canal Digitaal, the satellite TV operation owned by M7and the incumbent telco KPN’s IPTV and Digitenne pay DVB-T services. It would also represent 97% of the cable industry in one company and make them favorites to mop up the remaining leading lights CAIW and Delta KabelComfort and other minnows over the next few years and take 100% between them. Which is perhaps why KPN recently bought up content rights to deliver to CAIW, to prevent such a deal or at least to act as an irritant to it.
There is also the small fact that Liberty Global, the parent of UPC, doesn’t have enough cash set aside to buy a company as large as Ziggo. So because we are sure that no-one ever thought that a merger was ever possible, the cellular spectrum they bought jointly was always going to be something of a mess and after this deal, where UPC has decided to partner with Vodafone and where Ziggo has gone with an MVNO on the KPN network, enabled with tools from local company Aspider, it is even more of a mess. The spectrum will have to be remarketed or gifted to one or another or both of their new partners.
So we’re not sure that buying the spectrum first at auction, and worrying about what you do with it later, is really such a smart option, unless you are a gambler of consummate skill. And although we are pretty sure that the two cable companies would not get permission to merge today from the Netherland regulators, the rising tide of KPN in the Netherlands perhaps has to be challenged by a rival.
Our thoughts were that this could be provided by UPC and Ziggo separately, but using the same cellular partner. The truth is that UPC and Ziggo have separate territories and so don’t compete with one another. At the right point in the future, as KPN gets stronger in TV service, it may be a good idea for the Dutch authorities to let them merge and go head to head nationwide against KPN and Telecom Paper, which happens to be Dutch, suggests that what they are actually doing is highly clandestine, with Ziggo gaining experience on the KPN network to see what they will be up against later, while UPC begins a relationship with Vodafone and prepares the way for when they merge. Ziggo will then switch to Vodafone too, but armed with the knowledge of the strengths and weaknesses of the KPN network.
So either the paper knows something which it isn’t saying or more likely it can’t accept that the two cable operators just can’t merge right now. Both cable operators are losing about 2% to 3% of their TV customers a year, while KPN doubled its IPTV customers base last year, so if that trend continues, then eventually the cable companies will have a basis for merging without harming the market for pay TV.
Ziggo has now launched first mobile services, mostly 3G connections for tablets and laptop users to start with, offered only to existing customers. Eventually Ziggo sees the addition of both mobile video and voice services. It has just kicked off data tariff plans with a free modem at ’20 (500 MB) , ’30 (2GB) and ’45 (5GB) a month, and a promotional ’10 a month off for the first four months and lower SIM only tariffs.
UPC has chosen Vodafone because it has a more compatible footprint for UPC in other countries, particularly Germany, but Vodafone has subsidiaries in a number of the countries where UPC operates, including the Czech Republic, Hungary, Ireland, Romania and Switzerland, and minority positions or partner networks in Austria (through MobilKom), Belgium (through Proximus) and Poland. In fact the only territory where UPC could not work with Vodafone in Europe is Slovakia.
So what happens to that 40 MHz of cellular 2.6 GHz spectrum, which the two said would be put to work inside two years? We imagine that half might go to Vodafone and half to KPN in the fullness of time, and the price will be some form of discount to broadband LTE services.
Ziggo was supposed to be going public, something that it has pulled away from since the Spring, when it said the financial market was not in the right condition to give it the value it required.
Ziggo is dominant and has a network which is 66% digital and is converting customers from analog at a rate of around 16% to 17% of its network a year, which means that in two years it will have a 100% digital network. It already offers triple play and if it sticks to existing customers. can implement a quadruple play fairly easily using existing billing mechanisms.
Ziggo was formed at the beginning of 2008 by the merging of existing cable companies Casema, @home, Essent Kabelcom and Multikabel, initially into an entity called Zesko, which subsequently changed its name to Ziggo, and initially these companies merged under private equity control. It has been valued at ‘7 billion.
We said at the time that the real reason for UPC to be talking about a bid for Ziggo was to drive up investor anticipation of the price of an exit from Ziggo and that this was really to kill off its IPO. Well it looks like that worked.
Dutch anti-trust authorities are not well known for interfering with deals of this type and have never done much more than smack the knuckles of high technology companies and have endorsed moves to consolidate the broadband market. However the European Commission would never have allowed the local regulator to put through this deal ‘ not yet.