Your browser is not supported. Please update it.

5 July 2006

DVB call afresh for MHP patents, to weed out expensive ones

This week the DVB Project issued a renewed call for any company holding intellectual property rights essential to its (Multimedia Home Project (MHP) specification.

Owners of patents are asked to declare their Intellectual Property Rights directly to the DVB Project office rather than to the previous licensing authority Dolby’s Via Licensing.

The standard has been held up by what many see as financially disastrous patent terms suggested by Via Licensing. The standard is virtually identical to the CableLabs OCAP specification, and the same patents were considered necessary, and yet different terms were offered for OCAP than were offered for MHP.

The DVB said that the terms previously proposed had ‘disquieted’ many DVB members which has caused the renewed call for declarations, which are called for prior to September 8 this year.

It is almost unprecedented for a standards body to say outright that where patents are overly onerous, they will look for alternatives, but that’s exactly what the DVB Project has said. It plans to isolate each of the expensive patents and simply replace them, where possible. That approach will almost certainly lead to legal challenges down the road.

Back in March we pointed to the anger the license had evoked, with Europe upset that it was getting a raw deal, specifically over the issue of interactivity.

The full list of companies that had previously offered technology to MHP has not been published, but they are known to include Comcast and OpenTV, companies that get most of their revenue from the US cable industry, which will be charged on a different basis.

The MHP royalties proposed by Via Licensing were set at $2 per device plus a $0.25 per annum household charge for service providers, while for OCAP the license will cost $1.50 per consumer device and $0.30 per household per annum for service providers.

There have been caps put on the fees with free to air broadcasters paying $100,000 a year, and pay TV operators paying $200,000 a year once they have 7.5 million subscribers. The charges will begin on January 1, 2009.

These terms were described at the time as a ‘case of IPR hijacking that is endangering the wide adoption of MHP.’

Sun Microsystems, a leading contributor to MHP, is understood to have offered its licenses for free because all of the applications are based on Java.