We have to admit to being a little confused by the claims this week that Norwegian student turned US hacking specialist Jon Johansen aka DVD Jon, has ‘cracked’ Apple’s Fairplay to the extent that his company Doubletwist is offering code that will allow music and video to be dropped onto iTunes in a way that will retain the protection of the Fairplay DRM system.
Modern DRM uses PKI (Private Key Infrastructure) encryption, almost in reverse. In PKI there is a public key that everyone has for reading messages which are encoded with a private key, which only a central authority has. This was invented for operations like Banks so that communications could not be forged. By reverse we mean that a DRM supplier acknowledges that the dangerous person in entertainment services is the consumer and so consumers are issued with a DRM decryption key that has to be kept secret from even themselves so they cannot indulge in piracy.
To ‘break’ a system you need to work out not only the key for decoding the entertainment (actually the entertainment is sent with a decryption key, and it is this key which the device key decodes), but also the algorithm which relates the two keys, the one used for encoding and the one used for decoding, and finally get a copy of the encryption key.
This has almost never been done. When DVD Jon broke Fairplay on a previous occasion he simply opened an iPod environment using software, looked around at all the components and guessed that the local key would be made up from various component serial numbers. It’s hard, but not to someone like him. What he now claims to have done is close to impossible on a serious PKI system as he needs to encode content so that it can be decoded by every iPod out there, and that means that he really HAS to have cracked the basic algorithm.
While we won’t doubt him, it is likely that Apple will have had to have been a little sloppy, and left a door or two open that he has prized away at. The result is supposed to be licensable to companies wanting to put music on an iPod.
Can Apple do anything about it? Well of course any change that Apple introduces cannot make it impossible for an iPod to play its existing music or video, so perhaps not. It can issue a new release of software, but our imperfect understanding of these things is that if this uses a totally different algorithm for encrypting content, then it wouldn’t work with existing content, and the ‘infiltrated’ content will look just like existing content.
Our only concern is that this is all hypothetical because we don’t see other legitimate music services taking a risk that what DVD Jon has done is actually illegal (under the Digital Millenium Copyright Act you cannot interfere with copy protection, but he hasn’t, he’s just copied it). Also it would be rather upsetting if Apple techies did find a way around the problem and shut out all the content that had been copied. Apple’s move next.