It appears that even the European Commission has learned to ‘choose its battles’ and has decided not to take on the entrenched might of the 100 year old collections societies that are scattered all over Europe, in a bid to lower copyright levies.
Newspapers in France carried details of intense lobbying coming from politicians there to abandon the move. There has been little explanation of why the Commission has dropped its plans, only the suggestion that ‘it needs a little more thought.’
Copyright levies, like publishing royalties, are collected by a patchwork of collections societies, and then paid out in an opaque formula that only seems to benefit the very large monopolistic music companies. Also the levies vary wildly across member states with some levies charged on MP3 players being more than the price of the player itself. In Spain and German it is known that there are particularly heavy charges, and often this is due to a levy being charged for every minute of content a particular device can hold. As digital technologies have increased storage sizes, the levies have gone sky high.
Last June the European Commission put down proposed rules and began asking member states what they thought about them. Companies which sell players with storage devices, say that by incorporating Digital Rights Management, they are ensuring that all the copies of content on their devices are paid for in full, so that no device levy should be charged. But this flies in the face of a couple of facts, firstly that iPods have about 80% of their content ripped from unprotected CDs despite having an effective DRM on it, and secondly that levies aren’t supposed to be compensation for piracy, but compensation for fair use copying around the home. Many DRMs allow content copying to tethered devices, so DRM doesn’t offset the levies.
That having been said many Europeans find they have to buy their MP3 devices outside the country, from a less strict regime and import them, for something like half the price.
Levies are charged on blank disks, photocopiers, and PCs as well as mobile phones, MP3 players and DVRs, in some cases making them economically non-viable and only the UK, Ireland, and Luxembourg do not impose any such levies, because they do not allow personal use copying under their laws.
The climb down by the Commission has immediately angered many agencies that have been campaigning for a change in levy laws and payment transparency.