Hard on the heels of DirecTV, EchoStar Communications, the other major US satellite TV company, has reported its first quarter, but it is a quarter which tells a very different story, with two big charges, one due to the patent infringement trial with TiVo, knocking holes in the net income figure.
In fact this could be the first time that DirecTV has made more profit in a quarter than EchoStar, at least for some years, with it recording a net income of $235 million on $3.4 billion of sales, against EchoStar’s more than halved net income of $147 million, on $2.3 billion of sales.
DirecTV’s must be considered a fabulous quarter with a new additional 255,000 subscribers and a reduced churn rate, with revenues up 8%, while EchoStar grew more at 13%, but a $23 million charge relating to early redemption of debt, plus the $74 million charge relating to the Tivo litigation, taking $97 million off its income which fell from $318 million this time last year. However last year was also inflated with a $134 million gain relatong to settlement of an insurance claim against a failed satellite. EchoStar no longer carries insurance on its satellite fleet.
But the Disk network satellite TV service grew by almost the same as DirecTV with 225,000 net new subscribers against 255,000, and it ended the year on 12.3 million subscribers.
Dish is adding less subscribers net because like DirecTV, as its absolute number of subscribers goes up, the absolute number of churning customers is higher each year even if the percentage stays the same, so this number of additions is 31% lower than those added a year ago.
But also there has been a fall away in the new subscribers that DirecTV has been picking up from AT&T, not an increase as many analysts have predicted, suggesting that AT&T would push its existing TV options harder even than its new IPTV services.
Also AT&T no longer pays for equipment and installation costs, so each new AT&T subscriber costs Dish more and it tries to keep its customer acquisition costs under control. As compensation it gets to keep more of the money each month from the customer.
EchoStar said its monthly ARPU was $60, which compares with $69 at DirecTV but was a rise of $3 over this time last year, mostly due to price increases.
Easy pickings for Liberty Global in European cable-based triple play
By comparison with the US, Europe and other parts of the world seem to show rich pickings for cable, broadband internet and VoIP customers, and that’s reflected in the figures announced this week by Liberty Global.
While in the US the two fastest growing pay TV companies DirecTV and EchoStar are picking up roughly 1 million subscribers each year, Liberty Global is picking up new accounts at roughly twice the speed.
Commenting on the results, Liberty Global’s President and CEO Mike Fries said, ‘By any measure, we had an outstanding first quarter. We added 437,000 new video, telephony and broadband Internet subscribers (or RGUs) on an organic basis. This was a record for the period and gives us an excellent start on achieving our full year guidance target of 1.6 million net additions, particularly given the seasonality of our RGU growth which is weighted to the fourth quarter.’
The results came across the board of service offerings with new broadband Internet and VoIP additions strong, but stronger still were the 250,000 new customers for cable video services.
During the first quarter and since the quarter ended Liberty Global has bought Austrian broadband firm Inode, and sold off its French and Swedish operations.
Revenue increased 38% in the quarter to $1.63 billion a growth of 11% which were particularly strong in Central and Eastern Europe and Chile and the company has recently entered Switzerland and added scale to it Romanian operations.
The company spent a lot of money in the Netherlands rolling out a full triple play service there, and but this has temporarily depressed the groups cash flow.
The company now has 19.3 million revenue generating units, which is one for each service at each customer, not the total number of customers.
The company has recently launched VoIP services in Austria, Poland, Romania and the Czech Republic, and plans to launch in the Slovak Republic and Ireland later this year and says it is on track to beat its guidance figures once this is adjusted to account for the sales of the French and Swedish operations.