Your browser is not supported. Please update it.

5 July 2006

EMI and Warner wage merger war, as Vivendi hovers

EMI and Warner Music look like finally merging after almost a decade of stop start merger talks, with the European Commission once blocking a deal. But now both companies think it’s a good idea, but neither management team can agree who should be left in power.

So when the UK’s EMI raised its bid for Warner Music this week to $31 a share, or about $4.6 billion, Warner turned right back and made a bid for EMI. Funnily enough both share prices initially rose.

Perhaps the logic of the deal is irresistible after all and that investors can see the natural synergies of putting together the two smallest tier one record labels into one giant. Or perhaps investors sense that someone is going to overpay for the deal, and they want a piece of it.

The bid for EMI is worth about $4.6 billion too, and EMI immediately rejected the deal, making all the usual noises about it being wholly unacceptable.

But negotiations continue, and by now they may have created such an investor expectation that they will just HAVE to find a deal, or risk their share prices crashing around them. If either one of them pays too much, then there are fears that it will create a debt laden monster where interest kills off all the presumed benefits. A combined company says it can find $400 million in cost cuts, and would hold around 25% of the music label market, number 2 behind Vivendi Universal.

The two management teams are headed by Eric Nicoli, longstanding EMI chairman and Edgar Bronfman Junior the Seagram heir. EMI’s latest deal is $31 a share, all in debt funded cash, which Warner has formally rejected.

EMI said that is would sell off Warner’s music publishing arm, to part fund the deal.

In the meantime Vivendi has been reported by UK newspapers as preparing a bid for the Warner publishing arm as well as acquiring BMG Music Publishing.

The Warner Chappell publishing business should yield about $1.5 billion, to sweeten the EMI deal and reduce debt straight after a merger is complete. Our prediction is that the stodgy British style of EMI versus the new age online approach of Warner may make the deal impossible to complete.

Also the last thing that recorded music wants globally are more mergers that take music into fewer and fewer hands. Despite past mergers the operations remain bloated and overmanned. The private equity world could get itself into a good business taking one or two of these monsters and breaking them up into assets that can be acquired by smaller, independents or floated, cutting fat during the process and updating their publishing models to embrace online more aggressively. But we don’t think they will, not while big is beautiful and piracy still haunts the music scene.