Your browser is not supported. Please update it.

21 August 2014

EPL warns over Twitter Vines users uploading clips

The English Premier League’s (EPL’s) warning to fans not to post clips of matches via Twitter’s Vines app looks like bluster without legal teeth, but could end up clearing the air at last over what fans can legally record both at matches and when watching on the TV. Vines only allows six second clips which is perfect for posting goals or similar incidents and is used more often by fans watching matches on the TV at home, although also by spectators with laptops, tablets and smartphones in the grounds. A key factor therefore is the ability to pause and rewind live TV and record a goal at high resolution using a camcorder for immediate tweeting with Vines.

As such Vines is no threat to the holders of full live broadcast rights, which is BSkyB and BT for the EPL. It is not even a threat to owners of rights to show highlights after the event, such as the BBC for Match of the Day, so the EPL’s main concern is over the online rights held by the Times and Sun newspapers owned by Rupert Murdoch’s News Corp, which charge a subscription for access to clips. For example the Sun+ digital entertainment package, including premier league goals, costs £2 ($3.30) a week or £86.70 a year. The EPL has stated that the use of Vines and GIFs to show clips is illegal and ‘we would encourage fans to use legitimate means to access this content, such as The Sun or The Times goal apps.’

The EPL insisted it is getting cooperation from social media providers to take down pirated clips and was working on a Vines crawler to identify offending material. It will certainly need to crawl very quickly since here we are talking about just a minute or two, which is all it takes for someone to access a clip and copy it if desired. The main target for the EPL are Twitter users with large numbers of followers who are posting clips on a serial basis. If the EPL or individual clubs get too heavy handed against individuals posting clips for a few of their friends, it will prove counterproductive and also most likely unsuccessful in the courts. Technically just emailing a clip to a few friends or sending it via say WhatsApp is also illegal, but there has been no suggestion so far that action will be taken against people doing that.

As it happens a side plot emerged just before the EPL came out with its warning, when Manchester United, in recent years the EPL’s most successful club, decided to ban supporters from bringing tablets and laptops in to the ground during matches, although smartphones are permitted as long as they measure smaller than 5.9in by 3.9in (15 x 10 cms). The club cited security considerations in the wake of the apparent discovery that terrorists could deploy stealth bombs in the battery compartments of laptops, batteries or large smartphones, evading current scanning equipment. The club pointed out reasonably that it was not practical to deploy airport style checks on supporters’ devices as they entered the ground given the numbers involved, but the reasoning still sounded bogus.

When asked why Manchester United alone had decided to take this step, the club attempted to extract marketing capital by arguing that its iconic status made its ground a more likely target for terrorists than rivals. This did beg the question of why the likes of Real Madrid and Barcelona have not followed suit, being equally iconic. The real reason may have more to do with rights for clips, although another motive that has been cited is to avoid annoyance when people on the row in front stand up to get a good view with their tablets to record a clip, precisely when there is an exciting goalmouth incident.

While it is impossible to eliminate all recording and posting of clips the combination of technology and likely cooperation from the social media sites will probably bear down on major sources of sporting clips in the leading markets. The underlying issues are legal and commercial rather than technical. As so often there are precedents to draw on, going back well over two decades to 1991, again concerning UK football clips as it happens. Then the BBC had exclusive rights to all football from FIFA, the world governing body, and sued British Satellite broadcasting, BSkyB’s predecessor, for showing clips lasting between 14 and 30 seconds of goals, sometimes in slow motion, in this case taken from the 1990 world cup.

However the court took a dim view of this action, deeming that the short clips were covered under fair dealing provisions and therefore could be rebroadcast legitimately, without infringing the BBC’s larger rights. Of course this was before the public Internet age had even dawned and so the EPL might contend that the situation is different now with online rights more clearly affected. But there is also the Restricted Practice Act to consider, since this suggests that these exclusive rights deals do not cover all possible usage and that attempting to ban short clips and certainly photos would be considered anti-trust, especially regarding pay-per-view events that are also defined as so-called Listed Events. In the UK some sporting events are defined under Category A, which means they must be shown Free To Air. This includes the FA Cup Final for football, the Grand National jump horse racing event and the Wimbledon Lawn Tennis championships. But here we are talking about Category B events, which can be restricted to pay per view for live showing but for which highlights on a delayed basis must be freely available. The implication is that attempts to sue for uploading clips could involve something of a legal minefield.

Legal and commercial considerations tend to overlap, as the US National Football League (NFL) and Major League Baseball (MLB) discovered when they engaged in the practice to which major US corporations seem particularly prone of taking protection of copyright to absurd and sometimes surreal lengths. In 2007 the MLB attempted to argue that it owns statistics associated with the league and that any fantasy league must pay it for what effectively is just promoting the sport. It even appealed against the negative verdict.

Similarly the NFL sued anybody who tried to use the name Super Bowl for anything. Then even more absurdly the NFL tried to trademark the name ‘The Big Game,’ after advertisers had used that phrase precisely to avoid falling foul of NFL lawyers over the Super Bowl. The NFL also issued threats to people posting YouTube clips in those early days which in the US were very clearly covered by fair usage rules. But since then the NFL and MBL have softened their stance and become innovative users of social media themselves for engaging with fans.

It could be said the EPL is almost a special case given the phenomenal value of TV rights upon which it is now so dependent for its existence, with the current live package earning £3 billion ($4.3 billion) over three years. The EPL is jittery because it fears that anything that even chips away at the edges of its rights could jeopardize future contracts. The fear is that commercial partners and broadcasters may include serial copyright infringement in their bargaining to get the price down, even if this is just clips and highlights. But this is a red herring and the EPL should come to its senses and devise a model that satisfies consumer demand for near instantaneous football clips legitimately, something along the lines of Netflix that has worked so well for TV shows and movies. The current spat after all is not about Vines, but any uploading, given the general ease of recording and posting video at decent quality. In fact consistent high quality could be a selling point, providing the cost is brought down well below the current £2 a week charged by The Sun and The Times for clips, which after all is about what Netflix charges.

Ironically when the EPL and individual clubs first noted how Vines was being used to upload clips to Twitter early in 2013, they immediately started experimenting with it themselves as a possible service to fans. One London club, QPR, started using it to announce new signings on Twitter, while others posted views of players practicing and new signings that way. This seems to have foundered over the fear of not cannibalizing the online package owned by The Times and the Sun, but the genie is out of the bottle. When the rights are renegotiated for the seasons from 2016 onwards it is likely online will be treated differently than it is now and perhaps not sold to a third party at all.